Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
2021 Mayoral Campaign

OPINION: New Mayor Must Champion Safety of West Side Greenway

12:01 AM EDT on July 8, 2021

The state DOT thinks you have enough room on the Hudson River Greenway. File photo: David Meyer

Danny Pearlstein
Danny Pearlstein

Tens of thousands of New Yorkers depend on Hudson River Greenway — the mixed-use, bike-pedestrian path along Manhattan’s West Side, which was resuscitated by the Bloomberg administration — for transportation, recreation, exercise, and respite. Yet the current administration often has bungled its management in a way that provides several teachable moments for our next mayor.

Now that we know who has won the Democratic mayoral primary, we can reflect on how we might promote safety and fairness on the greenway, and how we might ensure that the various government agencies work together for those purposes.

The de Blasio administration's Vision Zero plan has relied too heavily on law enforcement and failed to leverage the value of America’s busiest bicycle route in providing safe, sustainable transportation infrastructure.

Under the next mayor, the greenway and its management must be wholly reimagined. An administration genuinely committed to safe, sustainable transportation would recognize that the Hudson River Greenway and other routes through our park network, away from streets clogged with multi-ton cars and trucks, are essential arteries. It would acknowledge that long bicycle routes from affordable neighborhoods on the city’s edges should be prioritized over the loud demands of wealthy NIMBY areas

First and foremost, it would work with the state Department of Transportation to alleviate the crowded, dangerous conditions on the main greenway segment from the Battery to the Upper West Side. The greenway should be widened into the West Side Highway, by removing the westernmost lane of cars, as nine elected officials and three community boards urge. Moreover, the city must work with the state to remove the ban on pedal-assist bikes on that route — an artifact of the legislation authorizing e-bikes which unfairly hampers delivery cyclists.

The mayor also must direct the Parks Department to involve the state DOT in a safe construction detour in Washington Heights. On a mile-long section that needs resurfacing, pothole repair, and a strengthened retaining wall, Parks has proposed a lengthy closure with an as-yet-unspecified detour. 

A page of the proposal shows a rendering of the proposed bike lane in the northbound lane of the Henry Hudson Parkway.
A page of the proposal shows a rendering of the proposed bike lane in the northbound lane of the Henry Hudson Parkway.

Judging by Parks’s previous construction detours, this one is likely to endanger and inconvenience all users, some more than others, especially because the neighborhood is so hilly. Parks should ask State DOT to borrow an underused lane of the Henry Hudson Parkway, as grassroots activists and Community Board 12 have recommended. But the department inexplicably has failed to explore what is by far the safest and most convenient detour option. 

Prior instances of greenway mismanagement abound. Parks closed the heavily used Cherry Walk section between West 100th and 125th streets for several months last year for repairs to damage caused by Hurricane Sandy eight years earlier. The agency also addressed some other lingering issues, but the same section will close again for a longer period in a year or two because of a failure to combine maintenance items into a single project.

Again, the detour was a lapse of planning and coordination. Here, Parks should have worked with the city Department of Transportation to dedicate a lane of lightly used Riverside Drive to cyclists, and should have properly signed routes between the greenway and Riverside. It failed on both counts. For several weeks, a detour sign at the north end of the closure in West Harlem Piers Park directed cyclists and pedestrians to make a right turn — into the Hudson River. 

The Harlem and Washington Heights construction detour failures can be chalked up to laziness or incompetence, but not so the Boat Basin detour on the Upper West Side. Local Parks officials who live in the neighborhood relentlessly pushed to exclude cyclists from all five boroughs and beyond off of the waterfront path and onto a poorly lit series of steep hills and sharp turns from West 72nd to 82nd streets. 

Hudson Greenway Riverside Park Photo: Eve Kessler
Hudson Greenway Riverside Park Photo: Eve Kessler

The vehicle for this policy change was participatory budgeting, where only Upper West Siders were asked to decide whether to create an optional, bikes-only route for all of their fellow park goers. They voted "yes" but, even then, the result was a bait and switch, with a mandatory combined path to reach the waterfront and a prohibition on waterfront cycling. The inequitable ban remains in place, even during the night and the majority of the year when the waterfront route is too cold for all but the hardiest promenaders, and the safe, flat route becomes the exclusive domain of Parks Enforcement Patrol vehicles. 

The lackadaisical attitude of city agencies toward the greenway must change. A strong City Hall must communicate a consistent vision and effectively oversee its execution in and among its agencies — and not shirk coordination with the state, if necessary. Here’s hoping the greenway and all of us who depend on it get that in our new mayor.

Danny Pearlstein is the policy and communications director of Riders Alliance. Follow him on Twitter @dannypearlstein.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Bus Advocates Target Anti-Busway ‘Hypocrites’ at Bronx Zoo and Botanical Garden

A petition drive by Bronx bus riders calls out the institutions for boosting transit on their websites, but then trying to undermine it in the real world.

June 9, 2023

‘Duped’: A Harlem 20-Something Blows the Whistle on an Illegal Temporary License Plate Business

Kareem found out the hard way that his Craigslist gig delivering temp tags was illegal. Now he's exposing the operation that employed him, revealing clues about his anonymous bosses that all trace back to the same place.

June 9, 2023

Day 3: These Hunger Strikers aren’t Paid Lobbyists — But Albany Can’t Tell the Difference

ALBANY — “They are putting every barrier in our way to not have to face us directly and  look us in the eye and then make an unconscionable decision. This is Albany at its worst,” said Amy Cohen. 

June 8, 2023

Manhattan Pol Wants OMNY to Work With Citi Bike

Citi Bike could become even more popular if the MTA figured out a way to integrate it with the OMNY pay system.

June 8, 2023
See all posts