Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
sheldon_lg.jpg

NYU's Brennan Center for Justice just published an update of the famous 2004 report that described in excruciatingly precise detail just how deeply lousy New York State government has become. I haven't had the chance to read it yet but the title of the 2008 edition pretty much sums it up: "Still Broken."

The New York Times editorializes this morning:

New York’s government is still a secretive, boss-driven,anti-democratic disgrace.... Legislative leaders, especially Assembly Speaker SheldonSilver, have had “a stranglehold on the flow of legislation at allstages of the legislative process.” Most members have little say. Committees are run like shadow puppet theaters. Details aboutlegislation are hard for the public to get, unless they subscribe to abill-drafting service for $2,250 a year.

After the jump, some bullet-pointed lowlights from the report...

    • In both chambers, but especially inthe Assembly, leadership maintained a stranglehold on the flow oflegislation at all stages of the legislative process.
    • Committee meetings were infrequent inboth chambers and sparsely attended in the Senate, where members canvote without being physically present.
    • Most standing committees in both chambers failed to hold any hearings on major legislation.
    • There were no detailed committeereports attached to major bills in the Senate, and the Assembly rulesdo not require substantive reports to accompany bills reported out ofcommittee.
    • Legislators introduced anextraordinary number of bills in both houses during each session, whileonly a small percentage received a floor vote.
    • 100% of the bills that leadership allowed to reach the floor of either chamber for a vote passed with almost no debate.
    • Senate records indicate that many ofthe bills that received a floor vote lacked critical and requiredinformation about their fiscal impact, usually passing the full chamberwithout any meaningful debate or dissent.
    • The use of conference committees toreconcile similar bills in each chamber remained the exceedingly rareexception, rather than the rule.
    • Member resources were distributed inequitably in both chambers on the basis of party, loyalty and seniority.
    • Much of the legislative processremains opaque; records are difficult to obtain without burdensome"freedom of information" requests, and key records of deliberation-suchas "no" votes on procedural motions in the Senate-are not maintained.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

‘Just Absurd’: Adams Calls Unsafe McGuinness Blvd. Compromise a ‘Win’ Despite Lewis-Martin Bribery Indictment

The mayor sees no reason to revisit McGuinness even though the safety redesign was tainted by what the Manhattan DA calls a "classic bribery" scheme.

August 22, 2025

Friday’s Headlines: Ingrid’s Side Gig Edition

The mayor's former top adviser, Ingrid Lewis-Martin, thought she'd gotten a big acting break. But it was the beginning of the end. Plus other news.

August 22, 2025

‘Classic Bribery’: How a Powerful Brooklyn Family Crashed and Burned Over a Simple Bike Lane

Imagine destroying everything you've spent decades building to stop the city from building a bike lane. Welcome to Gina and Tony Argento's world.

August 22, 2025

Katie Wilson’s Success in Seattle Shows Again that Urbanism Is A Winning Campaign Issue

The advocate's strong early performance in Seattle's mayoral primary — following Zohran Mamdani's similar triumph — shows what you can do when you focus on transit.

August 22, 2025

Friday Video: How to Gear Up For Your Fall Bike Commute

The only must-haves for a cycling commute are a bike and a place you feel safe riding — but a few accessories don't hurt, either.

August 22, 2025

READ IT: The Argentos Bribed Lewis-Martin to Halt McGuinness Bike Lane, DA Says

Two members of a powerful Brooklyn theatrical production family bribed Mayor Adams's chief adviser to block the safety redesign of McGuinness Boulevard, court papers show.

August 21, 2025
See all posts