Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Car Culture

The Parking Dysfunction Meter: Fines Are Five Times Revenue

expired_meter.jpg

More enduring than Big Foot, the Loch Ness Monster and the resurrection of Elvis is the deeply held belief that there is such a thing as "free" parking for the average motorist in New York City. "Free" means you do not have to pay.

But someone is paying the $579,455,152 in parking fines the city expects to collect this year, according to the Mayor's supplemental budget -- and it's not just Fed Ex and UPS. Together, those companies pay about $30 million in NYC parking fines, or just over five percent.

Meanwhile, the city expects to collect $112,248,000 from meters in 2007. This more than five-to-one ratio of fines to meter revenue may very well be the ultimate measure of the dysfunction of New York City's on-street parking policies. Why?

The revenue the city raises from parking violations does little to solve
traffic and transportation problems. Many parking tickets are penalty
fees imposed on motorists who for one reason or another need to park their car for a moment but simply can't find a legal spot (double-parking on Brooklyn's 9th Street, for example).

In contrast, special loading zones and higher meter rates encourage more parking space turn-over, thus freeing up more curbside space
and reducing wasteful cruising. This means less traffic, less double-parking and
fewer delays to buses, all of which adds up to reductions of billions of
dollars in economic and environmental costs.

When you start looking at the parking problem this way, the choice becomes clear for New York City motorists: A few dollars more for on-street parking vesus a $115 double-parking fine. So, when you hear a
motorist call higher meter rates "unfair," ask them what's fair about
paying more than half a billion a year in parking fines and still not
getting a place to park
-- unless, of course, you have a government-issued parking placard. In which case, none of the above applies to you.

Photo: DM.nyc on Flickr

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Friday Video: Five Simple Ways To Get Kids Biking To School

Kids aren't riding bikes like they used to — but that doesn't mean we can't get them back in the saddle.

October 10, 2025

Friday’s Headlines: Refining Outdoor Dining Edition

Brooklyn Council Member Lincoln Restler has a bill to bring back year-round outdoor dining. Plus more news.

October 10, 2025

State DOT Scraps Cross Bronx Expansion Road On Highway Repair Plan

The state Department of Transportation will not build a "traffic diversion" structure next to the Cross Bronx Expressway — a highway expansion project that Streetsblog exposed.

October 9, 2025

Mamdani Vows To Defy DOT Insiders, Political Bosses To Pursue His Streets Agenda

Mamdani pledged stand up to bureaucrats and political power players who oppose his plans to make streets safer and buses faster.

October 9, 2025

Want Safety in Central Park? Add Protected Bike Lanes Around and Through It: Advocates

It's time to ring the park with green paint — and add green veins through it.

October 9, 2025
See all posts