Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Congestion Pricing

X-Citement: Union Boss and Streetsblog Columnist Fight Congestion Pricing War in Public

Get some popcorn and watch Charles Komanoff and union boss John Samuelsen battle on Twitter.

The Streetsblog Photoshop Desk

Boys, get a (chat) room.

Streetsblog columnist and congestion pricing supporter Charles Komanoff and transit workers union boss (and toll supporter-turned-opponent) John Samuelsen waged a war of words on Twitter late last night over Komanoff's recent column decrying Samuelsen's "head-scratching" abandonment of the central business district toll plan.

It all started when the notoriously anti-congestion pricing account of Liza Smith replied to our tweet about Komanoff's story with poll numbers that accurately showed that congestion pricing is not popular with voters. Now, get some popcorn and watch the show:

Round 1: Samuelsen pounced, claiming outer-borough residents were betrayed by the MTA's failure to massively increase service in advance of congestion pricing, but Komanoff was ready:

In round two, Samuelsen started his attack on the MTA for not adding more service in advance of congestion pricing, but Komanoff put the onus on the unions:

In round three, Samuelsen continued to claim that he withdrew his support from congestion pricing because he felt betrayed that the MTA did not massively increase service as, he claimed, it promised. Again, Komanoff was ready with a retort:

In round four, Samuelsen continued to peddle what Komanoff considers inferior goods:

Round five: No, Samuelsen isn't owning it. In fact, he's still going strong in this heavyweight battle. But so is Komanoff:

And that's when the bell sounded (at least for now). Our judges' cards have Komanoff the winner in a unanimous decision with no knockdowns, but plenty of aggressive counter-punching. Samuelsen is still standing and, we imagine, ready to fight another day.

Rematch anyone?

UPDATE: These two couldn't keep their gloves off each other! After initial publication of these threads, Samuelsen came storming across the ring for another blow, which, Komanoff, again, counter-punched:

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Analysis: Hochul’s $9 Congestion Toll May Stave Off Trump, But Won’t Reduce Traffic as Much

A $9 could raise enough money for the MTA and save face for Kathy Hochul, but it would not reduce traffic nearly enough.

November 8, 2024

Friday Video: Busting the ‘City of Yes’ Myths

There are many lies being told about Mayor Adams's City of Yes rezoning plan. So let's debunk them together!

November 8, 2024

New City Trash Bin Rules Begin Tuesday

New Yorkers who live in buildings with nine of fewer units must put their trash out in bins on the sidewalk starting Tuesday.

November 8, 2024

No Charges as Bus Driver Kills Senior at Dangerous Downtown Brooklyn Crossing

No surprise: In just the 22 months since January 2023, there have been 70 reported crashes on the single block of Tillary Street between Jay and Adams streets

November 7, 2024
See all posts