Tuesday’s Headlines: Wait, What’s Wrong with High Gas Prices Edition
12:04 AM EST on November 16, 2021
You may have noticed in yesterday's headlines how we questioned Sen. Chuck Schumer's fealty to car drivers, what with his comment on Sunday that President Biden should take federal action to reduce the price of gasoline so that New Yorkers can continue to use petroleum at the levels and expense to which they have become accustomed.
Schumer's call to release petroleum from the nation's strategic reserve came about a week after 11 Democratic senators (mostly from states that currently have cold climates, though won't for long) sent a letter to Biden asking for the same thing.
Like those self-styled Democrats, Schumer also said that after the short-term decrease in fuel cost, America could get back to the business of reducing our dependence on fossil fuels — something we have never actually done yet.
On Monday, our old man editor decided to ask Mayor de Blasio — who has long talked about the need to reduce New Yorkers' use of the automobile, has long described how excessive driving leads to increased road violence, and who has also talked about how a new congestion toll will reduce cars in Manhattan — if he would be willing to take on the senior Senator and seek to keep gas prices high to discourage driving.
Here's what we asked:
Over the weekend, the senator said that President Biden should release fuel from the strategic reserve because gas prices are very high. And he said that after this short-term reduction in fuel prices, America could then restart its effort to reduce the use of fossil fuels. But aren’t high fuel prices a key part of America’s effort to get off fossil fuels? Do you support Sen. Schumer’s call for federal efforts to reduce the price of fuel, whose cost is being driven up in part because of extremely large vehicles that Americans are choosing to buy in greater numbers and then turning around and complaining about high fuel costs?
Here was the mayor's answer:
I gave you credit you're asking a big thoughtful question, but I look at it a little differently than the way you're framing it. I'm in the camp that says we need to over time — not much time — over time, break our dependence on fossil fuels in a very radical way. But I also want to respect the fact that everyday working people in this city and in this country are hurting right now. They're hurting from all the effects of COVID, they're hurting from inflation. I think Sen. Schumer is right about what we need to do right now to help people through. I hear your bigger point. I really do. And in the future, we got to figure out the right way to help get people away from fossil fuels. But I don't, wouldn't put that in the context of this immediate question, when folks are coming out of COVID and dealing with the challenge of inflation simultaneously.
Let the record show, Mayor de Blasio is on the side of delaying our response to climate change, which only last month he said "poses an existential threat to New York City, and we must do everything in our power to confront this crisis head on." (He then flew to Washington, D.C. to be on hand as President "Amtrak" Joe Biden signed the $1.2-trillion infrastructure bill — optics, Mr. Mayor, optics! Take a train next time.)
It's also important to remember that in New York City high fuel prices affect mostly the 22 percent of workers who commute to their jobs in their own car (at least according to pre-pandemic Census numbers). The vast majority, 73.3 percent, took transit, walked, biked or worked from home. And it's also important to remember that America has been on an SUV-buying spree for years now — and now that particular chicken has come home to roost. (Worth noting that Schumer's bid to reduce fuel costs would mostly help Republicans who don't seem to care about the ramifications of their wastefulness; according to the market analysis firm, Strategic Vision, consumers who self-identify as Republican buy eight pickup trucks for every one purchased by a self-identified Democrat. They also buy roughly twice as many SUVs as their blue counterparts, giving them a 55-percent share of the sport utility market overall, though just 25 percent of Americans identify as members of the GOP.)
We weren't alone in thinking Mayor de Blasio and Chuck Schumer have been sniffing too many gas fumes lately. After hearing these comments, we reached out to responsible people and discovered that our old man was actually onto something:
"You are 100 percent right," said Beth Osborne of the progressive group, Transportation for America. "Higher fuel prices should be the actual reason for a major push to address reliance on gas. Why would this high cost burden be a reason to pause forcing people to just deal with it? We should help people get off this roller coaster as soon as possible."
And Noa Banayan, the director of Federal Affairs for People for Bikes, added that the high cost of fuel should encourage federal officials (paging you, Sen. Schumer) to incentivize the purchase of vehicles that neither waste fuel nor congest the roads.
"To fight the climate crisis and enhance mobility, the federal government must invest in low-cost, emissionless active transportation infrastructure and incentives for all Americans," she said. "The Build Back Better Act includes billions in funding for climate and equity focused infrastructure, a tax credit for e-bikes and commuter benefits for biking to work. If Senator Schumer's goal is to keep Americans moving and support low personal mobility costs, then we urge him and his colleagues to send the package to the president's desk before the end of the year."
And Julie Tighe, president of the New York League of Conservation Voters, added, "There's no question that fossil fuels are bad for the environment and extremely economically volatile. We need to prioritize clean fuels and electric options for cars and trucks, as well as reliable and convenient mass transit and micro mobility alternatives. These are not just environmental issues, but kitchen-table issues as well."
So maybe we were onto something.
In other news:
- The big story yesterday was Gov. Hochul's announcement that the MTA would freeze fares, thanks to that aforementioned federal infrastructure package. (NYDN, NY Post, NY Times, amNY, Gothamist)
- Permanent — and regulated! — outdoor dining in the public curbside space moved forward with a City Planning Commission approval. The zoning plan is off to the City Council next (NY Post). Meanwhile, the Times did its big takeout on the "issue," which included this buried treasure: "City planners say they will look to cities like Barcelona as a model to create larger scale pedestrian-only blocks in neighborhoods." (They will?!) That said, why does the Times reflexively not see that curbside space is not automatically for parking?
- Nice "Hamilton" reference in the Jefferson statue headline, NY Post!
- PATH is going OMNY like the MTA. (NYDN, amNY)
- You gotta wonder about hand it to the New York Times. On the day the infrastructure bill passed, every reporter in town (even Streetsblog's old man ... twice!) ran stories about what it would mean for projects in our region. Finally, a week later, a team of Times reporters put out their roundup ... which didn't add all that much to the discussion.
- Please don't run over cops with your Mercedes (or any car). (NY Post)
- Please remove the FDR Drive below the Brooklyn Bridge. Please. (The City)
- Writing in amNY, Friend of Streetsblog Sophie Maerowitz wants more Citi Bikes in the East Village now. (We covered the shortage last week.)
- And, finally, Friend of Streetsblog and future poet laureate Alex Beers was in the Green-Wood Cemetery the other day and noticed that someone has fully declared the Mets dead:
More from Streetsblog New York City
Manhattan Pol Upset at Delayed Rollout of Electrified Citi Bike Docks
"I urge the Department of Transportation and Con Edison to expedite the electrification of [Citi Bike] stations," Erik Bottcher wrote to the colossuses of conveyance and current last Friday.
On Eve of Congestion Pricing, Plate Scams at Bridge Tolls are Way Up
About 1.5 percent of the cars that passed through the MTA's bridges and tunnels in 2023 had unbillable license plates. And that number is up.
Thursday’s Headlines: Victory on Underhill Edition
Mayor Adams has decided to allow the agency to move forward with its plans to improve safety by finishing the Underhill Avenue bike boulevard. Plus other news.
Pols Want Covered Bike Parking at Parks, City Buildings
More parking in parks, but in a good way!