Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Car-Free Streets

Carpocalypse Now: NYSE Traders Return to Work on Tuesday — Barred from Public Transit

The horror. The horror.

The horror.

The influx of car commuters that many experts believe will be a long-term affect of the coronavirus pandemic begins in earnest on Tuesday with the reopening of the New York Stock Exchange trading floor, whose members are explicitly banned from taking public transportation to get to work — and the de Blasio administration has done little to prepare for the carvasion.

Margaret Chin wants affordable housing instead of parking. Will her City Council colleagues join her? Photo: NYC Council
Lower Manhattan Council Member Margaret Chin. Photo: NYC Council
Margaret Chin wants affordable housing instead of parking. Will her City Council colleagues join her? Photo: NYC Council

The New York Stock Exchange has not responded to press inquiries since it announced earlier this month that it would reopen the floor for trading with the requirement that no employee use public transportation — and the de Blasio administration has ignored queries about the potential of hundreds of cars flooding the cramped Federal Hall area.

The administration has not even responded to an urgent letter from Council Member Margaret Chin, who said the ban on public transit "has raised serious questions about how Lower Manhattan streets will be impacted" — not to mention raising "deep concerns about the precedent it sets for other companies who are also eager to reopen."

"Not only does a public transportation ban send a message of exclusion, it is unclear what kind of public health rationale, if any, was involved in this decision," Chin added, bemoaning the de Blasio administration's lack of "clarity ... on what is being done to mitigate a likely surge in vehicular traffic in the downtown area."

The de Blasio administration has created a temporary protected bike lane on Lower Broadway — but it is unclear how many NYSE traders will opt for two wheels rather than four. Plus, many visitors to the area have reported that the bike lane is effectively useless because NYPD officers park their cars in it.

Useful or not, Chin is concerned that "the return of traffic congestion will not only negate positive outcomes [such as open streets and the bike lane], but will also worsen air quality, which has been increasingly linked to COVID-19 exposure and transmission."

For Chin, the issue gets down simply to leadership: "These are decisions that require robust interagency planning, not arbitrary arrangements," she wrote. "The city must play a leading role in overseeing and approving company reopening policies, especially in matters related to public health, transportation, and workforce protection."

A spokesman for City Hall said the mayor's fair recovery task force would report back to Hizzoner by June 1. The mayor's "surface transportation" task force is not expected to issue a report at all, but has begun its work. The mayor "will be meeting with the transportation sector advisory council in the coming weeks," said spokesman Mitch Schwartz. "I'm sure the traffic impacts of reopening will be discussed at length. It is obviously a major consideration, and the mayor looks forward to hearing their recommendations."

The panel is dominated by cab and trucking interests, as Streetsblog has reported.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

World to Council: Say ‘Yes’ to the End of Parking Mandates in City of Yes

What do some of the city's wealthiest developers, strongest YIMBYs, venerable environmental groups, key labor groups, top architects, livable streets non-profits, housing advocates and Shams daBaron have in common?

November 14, 2024

KOMANOFF: A Positive Lesson for Congestion Pricing Came Last Week from Washington State

New York's Gov. Kathy Hochul should heed the message sent by Washington State voters, who supported a carbon tax measure that they once voted down.

November 14, 2024

The Instacart Loophole: Workers Are Not Covered By Minimum Wage

Recently arrived immigrants from Africa are turning to Instacart with few other options for work.

November 14, 2024

Thursday’s Headlines: Wait to Hurry Up Edition

Gov. Hochul turned herself into a pretzel over congestion pricing — now she is rushing to get it in place before President Trump is sworn in. Plus other news.

November 14, 2024

The Brake: What New York Can Learn From the ‘Bike Mayor’ of Africa

What can we learn from developing countries where car dependency hasn't yet taken root?

November 14, 2024
See all posts