Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Studies & Reports

Report: Most States Have Poor Safeguards Against the Revolving Door

false

Last week we looked at three state DOTs which are currently led by former lobbyists for the asphalt or energy industries. The "Revolving Door" series highlighted how billions in federal funding for transportation get funneled, with no oversight, to states where money and politics corrupt policy and lead to shocking amounts of waste.

While it's outrageous that a state DOT chief can flit back and forth between lobbying gigs and the public sector, or dole out enormous contracts designed to benefit the governor's political benefactors, such antics aren't limited to the three states we profiled. For a good survey of the lax ethics rules that prevail in most American statehouses (affecting not just transportation but all aspects of state policy), check out the Center for Public Integrity's State Integrity Investigation.

CPI's recent analysis found that loose state ethics rules and oversight are the norm, not the exception, in state capitals around the country. The group graded all 50 states, and not a single one scored an A. Only five states managed Bs. The rest were all mediocre-to-abysmal.

The three states Streetsblog examined -- Ohio, Texas, and Oklahoma -- received Ds for overall ethics oversight and transparency.

The report found that, across the country, state-level ethics protections are weak, and where they do exist, they often lack teeth.

Tennessee, for example, started a state ethics commission six years ago, but has yet to issue a single citation.

Notably, in CPI's investigation, Ohio, Texas and Oklahoma all rated below 50 percent -- a failing grade -- on "regulating conflicts of interest by the executive branch" -- the rules and oversight that would apply to state DOT directors.

The agency responsible for ethics oversight in Austin, for example, is basically set up to fail.

"The Texas Ethics Commission is comprised of appointees by the governor and legislature, which not only presents an inherent conflict but often leads to gridlock," CPI's Caitlin Ginley said. "Commissioners are typically split along party lines, but in order to pursue an investigation, at least six of the eight commissioners must agree."

As a result their analysis, CPI reports, Maine is currently considering legislation that would establish "cooling off periods" preventing state officials from working for the industry they regulated immediately after leaving the public sector -- an attempt to halt the "revolving door."

Meanwhile, the next time you hear an elected official call investments in transit, biking, or walking a waste of money, keep in mind how road builders can exploit weak ethics rules to make sure billions get spent on highways to nowhere.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

No Charges as Bus Driver Kills Senior at Dangerous Downtown Brooklyn Crossing

No surprise: In just the 22 months since January 2023, there have been 70 reported crashes on the single block of Tillary Street between Jay and Adams streets

November 7, 2024

Want Parking? Kiss Goodbye Half of the Projected Housing in ‘City Of Yes’

Analysis: Modifications the mayor's City of Yes housing plan will result in less housing, experts say.

November 7, 2024

NO URGENCY: With the Clock Ticking, Hochul Twiddles Thumbs on Congestion Pricing

Gov. Hochul is showing no urgency to "un-pause" congestion pricing before Donald Trump takes charge of the federal government.

November 7, 2024

Thursday’s Headlines: Victory and Loss Edition

It's a great country. Let's hope nothing bad happens to it. Today's news roundup.

November 7, 2024

Tech Could Speed Up City Transportation Projects: Report

Current technology could shorten reviews from months to a few hours, one expert said.

November 6, 2024
See all posts