Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
MTA

State Judge Rules MTA Payroll Tax Unconstitutional

Well, this is just crazy. A State Supreme Court judge has ruled that the MTA payroll mobility tax, which collects more than a billion dollars a year to keep the NYC region's transit system running, was enacted in a way that violated the state constitution. The payroll tax was passed in 2009 to avert devastating service cuts. It initially collected 34 cents for every $100 of employers' payroll in the 12-county MTA region, but the tax was rolled back substantially by the state legislature and the Cuomo administration in 2011.

The payroll tax remains one of the region's single largest sources of transit funding, and doing away with it would throw the transit system into turmoil.

In his decision, State Supreme Court Judge R. Bruce Cozzens, Jr. ruled in favor of Nassau County, Suffolk County, and smaller municipalities in the MTA service region, saying that the payroll tax "does not serve a substantial state interest" and therefore needed to receive home rule messages from the municipalities affected, according to Newsday.

As Transportation Alternatives pointed out in a statement, the ruling "threatens the foundation of the state’s economy."

We'll have more on this story tomorrow, but it seems as though the region's transit system is now at the mercy of an appeals court judge three appeals court judges to be named later, who will decide whether Judge Cozzens' proclamation that there's no "substantial state interest" in funding the MTA holds any water.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Christmas Sockings: Carl Heastie and Andrea Stewart-Cousins Say ‘No’ to Better Transit

The transit world is reeling this week after the two legislative leaders put a block on the MTA's capital plan.

December 26, 2024

Streetsies 2024: Vote For This Year’s Biggest Failures

Overall, it was a pretty sad year. But what was the city and state's worst failures? You get to vote!

December 26, 2024

Streetsies 2024: Vote for this Year’s Best Livable Streets Projects

This year had some bright spots for livable streets projects. Here are the ones that stood out.

December 26, 2024

Thursday’s Headlines: Christmukkah Edition

We took yesterday off to celebrate the many holidays and to see the new Bob Dylan movie. But there was lots of news.

December 26, 2024

On Christmas, Let’s Consider the Successes of the Livable Streets Movement

Here's a short, heartwarming film about the successes experienced this year by the livable streets movement.

December 25, 2024
See all posts