Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Bicycling

Separated Bike Path Isn’t Gay Enough for CB4

Manhattan Community Board 4's transportation committee unanimously approved DOT's plan to install a physically-separated bike path on Eighth Avenue in Lower Manhattan. The committee enthusiastically recommended the plan to the full board on Wednesday. The board then voted to ignore their own committee and block the plan. Apparently, some members feel that complete streets and safe bike infrastructure are somehow incompatible with the neighborhood's gay-friendly environment. Chelsea Now has the play-by-play:

Boardmember Allen Roskoff was more specific. “I refer to Eighth Ave. between14th and 23rd Streets as ‘Gay Boulevard,’ he said. “Large numbers ofgay people go there… It’s where we feel at home. … The atmospherethere—the restaurants, the activity, the people walking— it’s a home tomany of us that no other avenue is. I don’t think these changes are forthe positive in any way, shape or form.”

Which reminds me... Have you looked in to joining your local Community Board lately? This kind of thing is going to keep happening until either the Community Board system is overhauled or we get more Ian Dutton's, Christine Berthet's and Teresa Toro's serving on local boards.

The DOT's plan for a pilot project on Eighth Avenue, which can be downloaded here, mirrors the complete street redesign of Ninth Avenue one block to the west. The Eighth Avenue bike lane also runs through part of CB2, which unanimously approved the project last month.

It's also worth noting that outcry against the bike lane at CB4 was not at all universal and that Community Boards only have advisory power. DOT can go ahead with the project with or without the board's support. Again, from Chelsea Now:

Boardmember David Hanzel observed that “walking down Ninth Ave., I thinkit’s an improved experience.” He said there’s less traffic, fewer carsmaking sharp turns, and it’s “more of a leisurely stroll now.”

Hanzel was seconded by longtime member Bob Trentlyon, who observed thatthe discussion was the “most retro conversation I’ve heard at a boardmeeting in a long time. … There must be two Ninth Aves., because theNinth Ave. I see, the traffic is moving very smoothly along… There areno businesses that have gone out of business since this has happened;there are more people starting to use the bike lanes.”

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Most NJ Gov. Candidates Have No Problem With ‘Boondoggle’ Turnpike Widening

The $11-billion highway expansion would double road capacity heading toward Lower Manhattan. Of the contenders, only Mayors Steve Fulop of Jersey City and Ras Baraka of Newark oppose it.

June 4, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines: ‘Fairly Often’ Edition

Andrew Cuomo claims he rides the subway "every other week." Plus more news.

June 4, 2025

Tuesday’s Headlines: Stop Super Speeders Edition

There's a new member of Families for Safe Streets, which is not good news. But maybe his voice will lead to change. Plus other news.

June 3, 2025

Uptown Portion of Hudson River Greenway Closed For Another Month

Tell us, would car owners put up with a crucial road closed for months with no detour?

June 3, 2025

MTA To Finally Untangle Notorious Brooklyn Subway Pinch Point

The MTA's new capital plan will finally unclog a notoriously slow-rolling segment of the subway in Central Brooklyn.

June 3, 2025
See all posts