Small Step for Pedestrians & Cyclists; Giant Leap for NYC

wburg_cityplanning_images.jpgThe Department of Transportation’s recently announced streetscape renovation at the Bedford Avenue L subway station in Williamsburg, Brooklyn marks the first time ever in New York City that car parking spaces have been removed to make way for bicycle parking.

Since breaking the news of this development on Monday, Streetsblog has learned more about the project. DOT’s plan is to widen the sidewalk by five feet for approximately 112 feet along the southeast curb of North 7th Street at Bedford Avenue. For the real estate brokers out there, that’s 560 square feet of new sidewalk space for Williamsburg. New bicycle racks will provide approximately 25 bike parking spaces. DOT is aiming to complete the project some time within the first six months of 2007. It will cost about $32,000 and the funding is coming from DOT’s general budget.

This sidewalk widening project has been about three years in the making. In the last few years, the Bedford Avenue L subway station has become a popular park-and-ride for bicycle commuters. With increasing complaints of bikes blocking the crowded sidewalks, in 2004 the NYPD began dropping in and sawing bikes off of the street furniture with chain saws.

"Clearly, that was a bad solution," says Teresa Toro, chair of Community Board 1’s transportation committee and New York City Coordinator at the Tri-State Transportation Campaign. "Everybody in the community recognizes that there are so many more people biking. There was much frustration around the police doing those bike raids, clipping locks."

Toro credits Brooklyn DOT Deputy Borough Commissioner Dalila Hall for working with the community to develop solutions. As plans were being developed to build out the sidewalks at Bedford and North 7th, DOT fast-tracked the installation of about 150 new bicycle parking spots in the neighborhood.

In April 2005, Brooklyn Community Board 1 approved a plan to widen the sidewalks and remove parking along two stretches of North 7th Street at Bedford Avenue (see the draft plan below). The widening along the southeast corner — the part of the project that DOT has agreed to get done in the next six months — is aimed more at improving pedestrian access to the crowded subway stairwell than increasing bike parking. "There will be a few bike racks away from the subway stairs. But the northwest corner would have been the one with a ton of bike racks on it," Toro says.


The sidewalk build-out and bike parking on the northwest corner is on hold for lack of funding. The southeast corner is being done first, Toro says, because "It has been recognized as a real need for a while. The city’s Subway-Sidewalk Interface project (PDF file) identified that as a trouble spot and it came up again during the Williamsburg-Greenpoint rezoning discussions."

This raises the question: On the northwest corner, couldn’t DOT install the bicycle parking directly on the street rather than taking the time and money to build-out a sidewalk extension? There are many successful designs and models for on-street bike parking in other cities. Greg Raisman of the Portland DOT pointed out in Streetsblog’s comments section that the 13 on-street bike racks pictured in this video cost only $4,000 to install. Raisman also notes one downside to on-street bike parking: The street sweepers can’t get in to clean the curb.

That question aside, convincing an outer borough Community Board to get rid of car parking spaces is no small task. For Livable Streets advocates interested in pushing for similar projects in other neigborhoods, Toro’s Community Board political savvy is worth noting. One of the reasons why her community didn’t mind giving up ten car parking spaces to bicycles is because Toro’s committee was simultaneously working to reclaim curbside parking space elsewhere in the neighborhood.

"We had a lot of outdated parking restrictions from when this was an industrial community.  The use had changed for lots of buildings but the parking rules had not," Toro says. By the time the vote came up to approve the sidewalk widening and bike parking plan, her committee had already freed up 40 or 50 new parking spaces in the area. "So, it wasn’t a hardship to give up five or ten parking spots. There wasn’t much opposition to this," Toro says.

Only 30 percent of the households in Brooklyn’s Community Board 1 own cars. "More people walk and bike than drive on Bedford Avenue. I see this as an equity issue and an acknowledgement that car owners are not the only ones who use the street and use public space."


The Department of Transportation’s sketch.

  • ddartley

    Yes, yes, yes, put ’em on the street!

    Like Aaron’s pointed out, it should a lot cheaper, and heck, if street sweepers can’t get in, I bet some of the cyclists themselves would help keep it clean. (Very easy for me to say since I don’t live there–cough.)

  • mfs

    the cyclists here definitely would not keep it clean whether there it is up on the curb or on the street. seriously. the only folks that keep our sidewalks clean are businesses and homeowners, because they will be ticketed if they don’t.

  • There are some subway stairs in Chicago that take up too much room on the sidewalk. We would benefit from the taking over of a few on-street parking spaces for more sidewalk space (and with or without the addition of bike racks on this new sidewalk).

    Once place I have in mind, for those Chicago readers, is the Grand/Milwaukee stop on the Blue line-O’hare.

  • Preston

    25 Spaces is nothing. My experience suggests that available parking will generate trips. This holds true for bikes as well as cars. I suspect that the intersection already has 25 bikes on a normal day.

    Perhaps the slow rollout will give time for this process to reveal itself allowing the city to be even more ambitious with it’s parking infrastructure when the NW corner is built out.

  • ddartley

    Yes, the “cyclists would keep the space clean” probably wins the prize for the dumbest comment I’ve ever posted on streetsblog. But it comes from my firm belief that cyclists are good citizens.

    Put those bike racks on the street, not the sidewalk!

  • ms nomer

    In response to #4/Preston – the 25 planned bike racks are in addition to others already installed nearby by DOT; they’re not the only 25. Particularly, there’s already a bunch of bike racks on N7 off Bedford, near the station.

  • da

    Re: parking bikes on street vs. sidewalk:

    I believe it is currently ILLEGAL for anything other than motorized vehicles to occupy on-street parking. This point came up in reference to the Park Slope Parking Spot Squat, where some jokers “parked” a small, plastic toy car in a parking space.

  • nobody

    Not a joke, but an exercise designed to provoke a rethinking of how we use our street space, and to see if there’s a more equitable arrangement. But yes, in a fun way.


An NYC First: On-Street Parking Spaces Replaced by Bike Racks

The new bike racks have been installed at the Bedford Avenue L subway station in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. As the Dept. of Transportation announces in today’s press release, "The facility marks the first time car parking spaces have been removed to accommodate bicycle parking in New York City." DOT extended a 76-foot section of the sidewalk […]

Now the MTA is Stealing Bikes in Williamsburg

Back in July, New York City’s Department of Transportation built sidewalk extensions and bike racks on a few automobile parking spaces-worth of street space near the Bedford Avenue subway stop in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. It was the first time ever that on-street car parking had been replaced by bike parking in New York City. The Bedford […]

Streetfilms: Car-Free Bedford Avenue

Emil Kozerawski is still working on the idea of making Williamsburg, Brooklyn’s "Main Street" into a car-free pedestrian boulevard. Now Car-Free Bedford Avenue has its own Streetfilms-style video on YouTube. Speaking of which, don’t forget to tag those YouTube videos "Streetsblog" to ensure that we get a hold of them. I love the vision and […]

MTA: Not Stealing Bikes. Just Following the Rules.

The MTA has been taking a lot of flack following yesterday’s dust-up over MTA workers seizing bicycles locked to the Bedford Avenue subway station stairwell railing in Williamsburg. Perhaps the wrong transportation agency is taking the hit on this one. A camera phone-toting tipster sends along the above photo. It shows that, not only does […]