Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Congestion Pricing

Silver and Assembly Dems Defend Their “Democratic” Process

In the latest New York Observer, Azi Paybarah talks to state legislators and other insiders about how the congestion pricing non-vote went down on Monday. Conclusion: Assembly Democrats told Speaker Sheldon Silver what to do, not the other way around. And by killing the pricing bill behind closed doors, the thinking goes, the Democratic conference rightfully exerted its power. 

The way the Democratic members see it, openingpotentially contested votes up to all the members of the Assembly wouldbe a voluntary abdication of party advantage. The will of the majorityof Democrats, they point out, correctly, might not be done.

“If you had 44 Republicans and 32 Democrats, you couldtheoretically pass a bill that a majority of the Democratic conferenceopposed,” said Assemblyman Richard Brodsky of Westchester, who emergedas the vocal public leader of the opposition to congestion pricing.“That is not the way we run the system. And frankly, it’s not the waywe should run the system.”

Assemblyman Jonathan Bing, a good-government typefrom the East Side of Manhattan, explained it by saying, “The idea thatdemocracy did not occur here [because] it was not a floor vote reallyis incorrect. Democracy occurred with every member of the Assemblymajority providing the speaker with his or her views, whether it was inconference or when the speaker polled members.”

“The process works in ways in which the committee structure weeds outbad bills and kills them,” Mr. Brodsky explained. “In this case, theissue was so important that the conference substituted for a committeemeeting. It was a committee of the whole, as it were.”

And there you have it: democracy, firing-squad style. You know the victim is dead, but you'll never know who pulled the trigger.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Opinion: Jim McGreevey Plots Comeback, But NJ Voters Have Better Options

Why do some politicians think they can recycle the politics of the past and continue to ignore the carnage on our streets?

September 26, 2025

Friday Video: How Car Culture and the Internet Attention Economy Waste Your Time

Our favorite YouTuber breaks down what happens when car culture, hyper-consumerism, and internet brain rot collide — and how to claw our way out.

September 26, 2025

Friday’s Headlines: Flatbush Ave. Sees Red Edition

Red-painted bus lanes are coming to Flatbush Avenue in downtown Brooklyn. Plus more news.

September 26, 2025

New Bill Would Force Amazon To Directly Hire Its Delivery Drivers

Council Member Tiffany Caban wants Amazon to have to directly hire its employees who make deliveries across the city.

September 25, 2025

‘It’s Bullshit’: DOT Deflects Concerns Over E-Bike Speed Limit

The cover-up is worse than the speeding.

September 25, 2025
See all posts