Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Canal Street

Zone of Hope? DOT to Undertake Tiny Canal Street Improvements

Canal Street at Sixth Avenue. Just a terrible mess. Photo: Google

It's one small step for steppers and, perhaps, a slightly less small leap for humankind.

The Department of Transportation quietly revealed on Monday that it will soon launch a "pedestrian safety" project on a short stretch of Canal Street — a small beginning to what advocates hope will culminate decades of campaigns with a full redesign.

Per the agency's tweet, the stretch between Hudson Street and Sixth Avenue will get two curb extensions (and lose one!), and, perhaps most important, a diversion of Jersey-bound buses from the congested intersection of Sixth Avenue and Watts Street to the (also congested) Holland Tunnel mouth on Canal via a short dedicated bus lane.

It's unclear whether this will solve the epic congestion of the Greater Hudson Square region — traffic that has been so eloquently documented by filmmakers, activists and the DOT itself in last year's Hudson Square/West Village Transportation Study.

That report, the fruit of more than two years of community meetings and analysis, recommended re-routing buses away from Sixth Avenue and onto Canal, as well as the curb extensions. But the report also makes it clear that Jersey-bound buses are caught in traffic that backs up at both the Watts Street and the Canal Street tunnel maws. The advantage of having the buses stay on Canal comes from giving buses a wider turn; on Watts Street, the tight left turn sometimes exacerbates traffic.

Activists who have been championing a redesign of Canal were completely and utterly underwhelmed.

"While we applaud progress, the community deserves more," said Paul Monnes of Transportation Alternatives's much broader #FixCanal campaign. "It's heartening that DOT is finally getting started. But this is just one segment of a dangerous road that needs a true end-to-end redesign."

Monnes alluded to the agency's March workshop, when several participants pointed out how "inhospitable" Canal remains for pedestrians between Sixth Avenue and Hudson Street.

"Community members requested changes like curb extensions, crossing islands, leading pedestrian intervals," Monnes said. "However, the plan to add just two extensions — and remove one on Varick — is disappointing."

On the plus side, the DOT said the initial work next month is only just the beginning.

Spokesman Vin Barone called the improvements "a project to improve safety and bus speeds by the tunnel," but hastened to add that there will be more work done in that area and, "The broader corridor vision [of all of Canal] is ongoing."

“This work is happening on and around Canal Street [but] it is nowhere near the full improvements we hope to bring to the corridor as part of our larger Canal Street Pedestrian Improvement Study, which is just getting started,” he said.

The city is under intense pressure to make Canal Street safer. Both Varick Street and Canal and Sixth Avenue and Canal have been dubbed "high crash locations" and "Vision Zero priority corridors" by the DOT, thanks to the number of crashes and injuries in those areas.

In just the tiny area bounded by Varick and Sixth avenues and Watts and Canal streets, there have been 609 reported crashes since 2018, injuring 24 cyclists, 24 pedestrians and 92 motorists. Varick and Sixth avenues both lack protected bike lanes — or even painted lanes — as cyclists approach and leave the Canal zone. All three roadways are truck routes.

Judging from the DOT flier, the agency will create a dedicated bus-only right turn on Canal into the tunnel that appeared in the Hudson Square study and was not admired by at least one activist:

It is unclear why the DOT did not include protected bike lanes on Varick and Sixth, though one or both were initially considered for such life-saving infrastructure:

It is also unclear if these changes will help the M21 bus, which became famous late in the de Blasio administration when more and more reporters noticed that the bus rarely makes it to the western end of its route because of epic traffic that requires bus drivers to truncate their runs and dismiss their passengers blocks before the terminus.

The MTA often has to send out tweets like this:

The 950 feet of minor pedestrian and bus improvements has been a decade in the making. In 2011, for example, Streetsblog covered an earlier effort to make Canal safer — and the outlet's story included a reference to a 2002 effort to do the same. The now 11-year-old article made it clear that very little has been done to mitigate Canal's deleterious effect on residents and on commuters.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Hit-and-Run Driver Kills Pedestrian on Bedford Av. Hours Before Long-Stalled Safety Redesign Begins

The driver was traveling so quickly that the victim was tossed high in the air before landing back on the car hood and being tossed to the side of the road as the killer drove off.

October 11, 2024

Manhattanites To DOT: Open Queensboro Bridge Pedestrian Path ‘Without Delay’

"It’s really inappropriate for the DOT to delay," said one member of Manhattan Community Board 6.

October 11, 2024

Council Seeks to Force DOT to Build 175 E-Bike Charging Hubs 

A new bill would force the DOT to build over 100 charging hubs, but will it be enough to keep up with demand?

October 11, 2024

Friday Video: A Vision for West 72nd Street

Maybe someday, a roadway that devotes 88 percent of its space to a tiny minority of users (drivers) could finally work for everyone. We can dream, can't we?

October 11, 2024

Friday’s Headlines: Yes, We Will Mention the Yankees Edition

We are praying for the first Subway Series since 2000. Plus other news.

October 11, 2024
See all posts