Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Car Culture

Cars and COVID-19: A New Way to Look at Virus Spread

3:37 PM EDT on April 29, 2020

Photo: U.S. Air Force/Azaria E. Foster

Remember that MIT study that suggested that transit worsened the coronavirus crisis in New York City?

Well, the same (equally unlikely) thing can be said about cars, too!

Earlier in the month, Streetsblog posted Aron Levy's blistering takedown of MIT Economics Professor Jeffrey Harris's thesis that the subway system "was a major disseminator – if not the principal transmission vehicle – of coronavirus infection." Despite the debunk, Harris's contention remains part of the dialogue to this day — and contributes to the public perception that transit is dangerous.

But what if car ownership is the real vector? Inspired by a tweet from Aaron Carr, Streetsblog took the city's maps of COVID-19 infection rates and car ownership rates and turned it into a short movie (citywide and then focusing on several areas):

From comparing the maps alone, one could easily draw the conclusion that high rates of car ownership correlate to high rates of COVID-19 infection. But real data experts (and MIT economics professors) should never do that.

Besides, regardless of what maps of COVID-19 infection rates you use, the painful truth about this virus is clear: it punishes the poor, who are already cheated by a city playing with a marked deck.

"[The] noticeable correlation is with income – working-class areas have higher infection rates, perhaps because they have higher rates at which people are required to still show up to work, where they can be infected," wrote Levy.

https://twitter.com/aaronAcarr/status/1255559786189459465?s=20

So the point is not to blame areas of higher car ownership for spreading COVID-19, but to point out that just as cars didn't cause COVID, it's just as unlikely that transit caused it. Still, Carr isn't the first to notice the connection between COVID-19 and areas of high car ownership. Earlier this month, Market Urbanism writer Selim Furth also debunked Harris's paper and pointed the finger at cars — well, not really at cars, but at their owners.

"Affluence is a very strong, negative predictor of [COVID-19] case growth during April, partially because affluent people have fled the city in large numbers," Furth wrote.

"There are two reasonable explanations for the likely fact that coronavirus spreads more along roads than rails," Furth concludes. "First, subway-dependent people may have cut their travel more than car-dependent people. Since travel brings us in contact with others at our destinations (stores, jobs, restaurants), the excess drop in travel may have made subway people safer precisely because the subway seems so dangerous. Second, and less obviously, subway-dependent people likely have more geographically-determined circles of contact. Car owners can move freely well beyond their immediate neighborhood."

The main solution, of course, is more subways, not less, in a crisis — which, ironically, was one of Harris's conclusions, despite his accusatory tone.

“We agree with only one opinion in Harris's thesis: ‘From the public health perspective, the optimal policy would have been to double—maybe even triple—the frequency of train service,'" said Nick Sifuentes, executive director of the Tri-State Transportation  Campaign.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Adams Caves to Opposition, Abandons Bus Improvement Plan on Fordham Road

The capitulation on Fordham Road is the latest episode in which the mayor has delayed or watered down a transportation project in deference to powerful interests.

September 22, 2023

Friday’s Headlines: Yes He Said Yes He Will Yes Edition

That headline above is a reference to the last line of James Joyce's Ulysses, which we won't pretend to have read. But we have that ... and other news.

September 22, 2023

Madness: Port Authority Will Spend $8M to ‘Study’ Widening Outerbridge Crossing

Will this $8.3 million find out anything we don't know about induced demand?

September 22, 2023

Study: How Low-Income People Really Use Micromobility

Shared bikes and scooters are meeting low-income people's basic mobility needs — but they're not being subsidized like it.

September 22, 2023

School Bus Driver Hits Cyclist, Injures 3, On Major Brooklyn School Bike Route

The crash happened on the route of the weekly Bergen bike bus.

September 21, 2023
See all posts