Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Car-Free Streets

Live from Oakland: Mayor de Blasio is Wrong About Bay Area City’s Open Streets Success

These are the barricades that Oakland’s Department of Public Works put up — which Mayor de Blasio claimed were not put up. Photo: Roger Rudick

Streetsblog SF has been covering Oakland's plan to close 74 miles of roadway to thru car traffic and open them up to pedestrians and cyclists who are trying to get around and recreate responsibly during the COVID-19 crisis. Here's what we were told by the site's editor, Roger Rudick on Tuesday.

Mayor de Blasio wrongly characterized — and perhaps flat-out lied about — Oakland's experiment with opening scores of miles of roadway for pedestrians, which features barricades to alert drivers that they cannot enter.

"I asked the NYPD and Department of Transportation to analyze the Oakland plan [and] as I understand it, they said that streets were closed off, but they didn't put up any barricades," the mayor said on Tuesday.

Pictures tell a different story — and Streetsblog San Francisco's Roger Rudick published plenty.

"Oakland followed the principle of 'keep it simple, stupid' and closed streets using a few signs," Rudick reported.

This is the intersection of Shafter and 42nd streets in Oakland. Photo: Roger Rudick
This is the intersection of Shafter and 42nd streets in Oakland. Photo: Roger Rudick
This scene, from Oakland, may become the norm in New York, thanks to an announcement by Mayor de Blasio. Photo: City of Oakland

Rudick's report also emphasized that Oakland's play streets are being overseen and implemented by the city's Department of Public Works, not its police department.

One resident's video showed no need for police to enforce social distancing rules. The public can abide by them without threats.

Parts of Oakland (which has a neighborhood called Brooklyn, for Pete's sake!) are just as dense as residential neighborhoods in New York, dispelling another of Mayor de Blasio's myths about the program.

New York can't do anything like what Oakland's Mayor Libby Schaaf has done, de Blasio said on Tuesday, because "adamantly ... we are just profoundly different than those other cities." Last week, the mayor had presaged his own team's evaluation, saying, "Oakland is obviously, a big American city, but it's not New York City. It has nowhere near the population or the density we have." (De Blasio's experiment with 1.5 miles of car-free streets ended in just 11 days.)

By the time Oakland's plan fully rolls out, the city of half a million people will have 74 miles of space for socially responsible recreation and travel. Mileage like that will certainly come in handy if they mayor is forced to close beaches this summer, as the NY Post reported on Tuesday.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Safety First on Third: DOT Numbers Show a Roadway Safer for All Users

Say it again: Bike lanes make roadways safer for all users.

February 19, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines: Mayor in a Whirlwind Edition

Mayor Adams will learn more about his fate today. Plus other news.

February 19, 2025

Another View: It’s Time for Residential Parking Permits

So people in the livable streets movement think residential parking permits might actually work. Read on...

February 19, 2025

Analysis: Residential Parking Permits Would Be Bad for City Streets

Congestion pricing isn't driving more people to park Uptown — and even if it did, "hunting licenses" for parking spots wouldn't help.

February 18, 2025

Too Much Illegal Parking Prompts Community Board to Reject New Housing

Even after the city greatly reduced parking mandates in the City of Yes initiative, parking is still at the center of many debates about new housing.

February 18, 2025
See all posts