Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Bicycling

Here’s Why Mixing Zones Scare People on Bikes So Much

Along protected bike lanes, mixing zones are NYC DOT's preferred design treatment at intersections where drivers can turn across the bikeway. Drivers are supposed to slow down and let passing cyclists proceed, but if the person behind the wheel is careless or impatient, the design doesn't offer much in the way of protection -- just ask Jonathan Warner.

Warner was approaching Fourth Street in the Second Avenue bike lane yesterday when a driver veered into him across the mixing zone:

https://twitter.com/Jaxbot/status/967893349553319936

Mixing zones begin far ahead of the intersection in order to give motorists and cyclists a clear view of one another, but they often don't function the way they're intended. In Warner's case, an illegally-parked construction vehicle obstructed the view of the approaching driver, who then veered into the path without yielding.

Intersections with mixing zones have a higher rate of cyclist injuries than those where cyclists and turning drivers each have a separate signal phase, and last year, a turning box truck driver killed Kelly Hurley in the mixing zone on First Avenue and Ninth Street.

DOT has taken some halting steps toward upgrading its bike lane intersection designs. The agency has piloted this design at a handful of Manhattan intersections:

70-and-columbus
DOT's first offset crossing on Columbus and West 70th Street.

While projects like the upcoming redesign of Fourth Avenue call for similar treatments, DOT has hesitated to make this design standard.

So far, the agency has no plans to retrofit most Manhattan intersections with the design above. And last month, DOT Bicycle Program Director Ted Wright defended the inclusion of mixing zones in the agency's plan for crosstown protected lanes, arguing that they would be safer on relatively low-speed side streets than on avenues.

On Twitter yesterday, Warner said even at lower speeds, mixing zones pose problems.

When crosstown protected bike lanes were presented to CB4, we told @NYC_DOT that mixing zones would be a problem. They said speeds are low, not an issue. The problem, as you can see, is not speeds of the cars, but the fact someone hooks into your path without warning.

— Jonathan Warner (@Jaxbot) February 25, 2018

DOT has said it will release full results of its study of bicycle intersection designs sometime this spring.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Federal Drug Agents Seize New 10th Avenue Bike Lane

The Department of Transportation is letting the DEA effectively redesign a block that should have a protected bike lane.

September 24, 2025

Opinion: DOT’s Flatbush Plan Is A Model For Fast Buses in the Heart of Brooklyn

The DOT commissioner, plus two top transit advocates, weigh in on the city's bus rapid transit plan.

September 24, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines: Look, You’re the Traffic Edition

Why don't French leaders take Le Subway (which is definitely NOT what French people call the subway)? Plus other news.

September 24, 2025

Talking Headways Podcast: Live from MARS To Change the ‘Crash First, Fix Later’ Mentality

Welcome to MARS: Modern Analytics for Roadway Safety. Let's talk about it in a special edition of the podcast.

September 24, 2025

‘Treated and Streeted’: How The City’s Safety Net Fails Homeless People in the Subway

The Big Apple’s $30-billion social safety net cannot reliably get a homeless person in psychiatric crisis out of the subway and into a hospital bed, a Streetsblog investigation has found.

September 23, 2025

Tuesday’s Headlines: ‘Not In My Back Yard’? ‘Yes, In Your Back Yard’ Edition

Our editor-in-chief joins the expert panel at the popular Upright Citizens Brigade's political comedy roundtable on Wednesday night. Plus other news.

September 23, 2025
See all posts