Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Around the Block

These State Lawmakers Indulged the Violent Fantasy of Ramming Protesters With a Car

After the white supremacist "Unite the Right" rally in Charlottesville, Virginia, Americans have now seen homegrown terrorists adopt the tactics of ISIS. James Fields, 21, drove his car into a crowd of counter-demonstrators -- killing 32-year-old Heather Heyer and injuring 19 others.

The violence of the rally was so ghastly that Republican officials rushed to distance themselves from it. But let's not forget that Fields was acting on an impulse that some lawmakers have encouraged.

In the aftermath of Black Lives Matter and Dakota Access Pipeline protests, lawmakers in Tennessee, North Dakota, Rhode IslandTexas, Florida, and North Carolina introduced legislation that would indemnify drivers who smash into crowds.

We want to name a few names.

    • Rep. Keith Kempenich in North Dakota compared Dakota Access Pipeline and Black Lives Matter protesters to terrorists in defense of his legislation.
    • Rep. Justin Burr in North Carolina proposed protecting drivers who hit protesters from civil liability. It passed the House 67-48.
    • In Tennessee, State Sen. Bill Ketron, State Rep. Matthew Hill backed legislation to shield drivers who plow into protesters from civil suits. That was shortly after a driver did just that in Nashville during a Black Lives Matter protest.
    • In Texas, Rep. Pat Fallon wanted to legalize hitting protesters, full stop.
    • In Florida, State Senator George Gainer proposed civil immunity for drivers who hit protesters.
    • In Rhode Island, State Rep. Justin Price was behind another civil immunity push.

In most cases, defenders of these bills have stated that they would not apply to someone who intentionally rams a car into protesters, as Fields did. For example, drivers who fail to exercise "due care" would in theory not be shielded by Rhode Island's legislation.

But as Gary Kavanagh writes in an excellent thread, these lawmakers were playing with fire:

Vehicular attack was not an aberration, a culmination of broadly expressed rhetoric & fantasies of killing street protesters on the right. https://t.co/ctwXUEe9H2

— Gary Kavanagh (@GaryRidesBikes) August 13, 2017

These bills fed an undercurrent of rage against people exercising their right to assemble, and all these men bear a portion of the blame for what happened to Heather Heyer. It was only a matter of time before an extremist like Fields acted out the violent fantasy these bills tacitly encourage -- to kill and injure people with a car.

Bills to legalize hitting protesters with a motor vehicle gave a not-so-subtle wink and a nod to extremists with violent fantasies (including the leader of the Santa Fe police union, who posted this meme on Facebook).
Bills to legalize hitting protesters with a motor vehicle gave a not-so-subtle wink and nod to extremists with violent fantasies (including the leader of the Santa Fe police union, who posted this meme on Facebook). Via Aaron Cantu
false

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Budget Crunch: Advocates Push Mamdani For Massive Fair Fares Expansion

The expansion would offer free transit on the subway and bus for people making up to 150 percent of the federal poverty level, which is not a lot.

February 5, 2026

AV Snub: School Bus Drivers Close The Doors On Autonomous Vehicles

School bus drivers are joining the chorus of opposition to a possible statewide expansion of Waymo, but it could be too late.

February 5, 2026

Thursday’s Headlines: Menin to the Rescue Edition

Al fresco is back on the menu, Council Speaker Julie Menin said on Wednesday. Plus more news.

February 5, 2026

Commentary: US DOT’s Misguided War on Bikeways

"European genes do not produce some kind of innate affinity for human-powered mobility — [and] people on any continent will use bike infrastructure if it is safe."

February 5, 2026

City Council to Bring Back Year-Round Outdoor Dining After Adams-Era Decimation

New Council Speaker Julie Menin wants to scrap Adams-era rules that shrunk the program to just 400 approved locations from a pandemic era high of 8,000.

February 4, 2026

Meet Steve Fulop, Corporate New York’s New Mouthpiece

Streetsblog sat down with former Jersey City Mayor Steve Fulop last week to discuss his new role at the Partnership for New York City.

February 4, 2026
See all posts