Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Streetsblog

Blaming Pedestrians While Absolving the Streets That Kill Them

How many pedestrians have to get killed on Louisville's deadly Dixie Highway before the press and police stop blaming each individual who dies? Image: Google
How many pedestrians have to get killed on Louisville's Dixie Highway before the press and police stop blaming victims? Image: Google via Broken Sidewalk
false

It didn't take long for Louisville to notch its first pedestrian death of the year. Brian O’Neal, 46, was killed on the sixth day of 2016 while trying to cross Dixie Highway.

The fact that Dixie Highway was the site of this fatality shouldn't have surprised anyone who's paying attention to pedestrian safety in Louisville. The city's first pedestrian injury also happened on Dixie Highway. In fact, last year, a third of the city's 18 pedestrian deaths were on this one street, according to Branden Klayko at Network blog Broken Sidewalk. Dixie Highway is scheduled for safety improvements later this year, in part as a result of a federal initiative targeting cities like Louisville where pedestrians account for a large share of traffic fatalities.

After O'Neal's death, however, police and local reporters didn't address systemic problems with the design of Dixie Highway. Instead the authorities focused almost entirely on the individual, blaming him for his death. Klayko writes:

Various police spokespeople were quoted saying the victim was wearing dark clothing, which is not a crime nor should it be noted in a report such as this. After all, we would all take offense if a police officer noted that a rape victim were wearing a short skirt.

Police also indicated that the man was not crossing in a crosswalk. What the police did not mention nor did any local media report was that the intersection includes only one marked crosswalk with the other three crossings unmarked. In order to reach the marked crosswalk, the victim would have had to walk a great distance or else cross in another unmarked crosswalk. The design here sets up pedestrians to fail, and then be blamed when they’re killed.

There are two TARC bus stops in this vicinity, one sitting in front of a brand new McDonald’s on a slab of concrete disconnected without sidewalks, illustrating the challenges facing pedestrians in the area.

Moreover, the LMPD told local news that the collision was still under investigation, but were quick to add that no charges were expected to be filed against the motorist. Regardless of whether anyone is at fault or not, it’s inappropriate to claim an investigation is taking place and then come right out and say that it won’t mean anything anyway.

Elsewhere on the Network today: The Wash Cycle reports that DC may be backpedaling on some of its increased fines for motorist misbehavior, rolled out recently as part of the city's Vision Zero initiative. And Seattle Transit Blog explains why free parking on minor holidays might not be a good idea.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

NYPD Criminal Bike Crackdown Continues Even as Mamdani Makes Overtures to Tisch

Street safety advocates should not be pleased by Zohran Mamdani's decision to invite NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch to stay on. Here's why.

November 1, 2025

Spooky Stuff: On Halloween, Some Places Have Deadlier Roads Than Others

New York City hasn't proven to be that scary on the candy-filled holiday. But it's still a bad idea to mix kids, darkness and cars.

October 31, 2025

Friday’s Headlines: After the Flood Edition

Flooding that would happen once in a while now happens a few times a year. Plus other news.

October 31, 2025

Amtrak’s Penn Station Plans Assume Gateway Tunnel Will Happen Despite Trump ‘Termination’

Andy Byford's Penn Station plans assume a capacity boost from the Gateway Tunnel project that President Trump insists is "terminated."

October 30, 2025

Judge Lets Court Street Bike Lane Live … For Now

Businesses sued too late to stall the redesign, a judge said. But a wider ruling will come as soon as next month.

October 30, 2025

Thursday’s Headlines: Janno’s Speaking Edition

Local news outlets had a field day after MTA CEO Janno Lieber reiterated his longstanding skepticism of Zohran Mamdani's free buses platform. Plus more news.

October 30, 2025
See all posts