Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
City Council

Council Bill Would Raise Fine for Unattended Idling Vehicles

Following two incidents in which four pedestrians were killed, a bill proposed by Queens City Council Member Elizabeth Crowley would raise the fine for leaving an idling, unattended vehicle to $250, up from the current, negligible fee of $5.

According to City Room, Crowley's bill comes in response to the deaths of Robert Ogle and Alex Paul, who were run down by a driver who had stolen an unattended car in Middle Village, Queens, and Diego Martinez and Hayley Ng, two preschoolers killed when a van that was left idling slipped into gear and backed into them as they walked along a Chinatown street.

"People need to realize there could have been situations that have been avoidable," Crowley said.

At issue, as always, is enforcement. Earlier this year the Council passed a law that allows agents of the Department of Parks
and Recreation and the Department of Sanitation to issue idling
summonses, appearance tickets and violation notices. Another bill, still making its way through the committee process, would permit traffic agents to issue idling tickets using their hand-held computers.

Unlike other anti-idling legislation, which tends to be targeted toward reducing pollution, the latest bill is intended to prevent thefts and vehicle-related injuries. Said Crowley: "This has to do with more how irresponsible it is to leave your car unattended. It’s sort of like inviting a crime."

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

‘Stupendous Potential’: Pay-Per-Mile Auto Insurance Would Cut Costs And Traffic Violence

Lowering car insurance costs doesn't have to eviscerate crash victims's rights.

March 5, 2026

Senate Majority Leader Questions Hochul’s Insurance Premium Scheme

The growing chorus of state lawmakers who want clarity on how the governor's auto insurance helps real New Yorkers now includes Stewart-Cousins, the second-most-powerful woman in state government.

March 5, 2026

Locked In: Mamdani Proposes $25M For Long-Sought Secure Bike Parking

Nine years after the city announced an unrealized plan for secure bike parking, Mayor Mamdani wants $25 million to build a network of 500 bike lockers.

March 5, 2026

Thursday’s Headlines: Mamdani’s Criminal Crackdown on Cyclists Edition

Another day, another criminal summons. And another record from Jimmy and the Jaywalkers. Plus other news.

March 5, 2026

Opinion: A Fairer — And Better — Way For Taxi Passengers To Pay The Congestion Toll

A per-minute, rather than flat, fee on passengers entering the central business district would reduce traffic, Charles Komanoff says.

March 4, 2026

NJ Scales Back Part of Gov. Murphy’s Turnpike Boondoggle

There’s now one less thing for New Yorkers to dislike about New Jersey.

March 4, 2026
See all posts