Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Environmental Review

The Original Sin of Environmental Review

10:54 AM EST on December 8, 2008

sprawl.jpgNo EIS necessary. Photo: tlindenbaum/Flickr

In the past few months we've reported on opponents of bike lanes, car-free parks, and congestion pricing using the pretext of environmental review to stymie initiatives that would reduce vehicle emissions. Norman Oder at the Atlantic Yards Report points us to another unintended consequence of the National Environmental Protection Act, the 1970 legislation that established the EIS process.

AYR recounts a talk given by progressive developer Jonathan Rose, who says that NEPA -- favored by a real estate industry that did not want to subject itself to an alternative law based on land use planning -- was flawed from the start:

"So the effect was that we turned our back on national planning, and weturned our back on a national infrastructure policy," Rose said. "And,at the same time, here’s what happens: 1000 individuals choose tosubdivide a parcel in the suburbs, or the exurbs, and it falls underthe screen of an environmental impact statement, each one is oneindividual act."

"One person chooses to build a 1000-unit urbanproject in a city and they get held up for five years in anenvironmental impact statement," he concluded. "And so the unintendedconsequence of NEPA actually was one more of the many things that madeit easier for suburban sprawl to proceed from 1970 to 2000 instead ofurban redevelopment."

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

MTA: Don’t Ask Us How Much It’ll Cost to Keep This System Running Another 20 Years

Some costs were provided, but outside observers were baffled why the MTA neglected to say how much the repair and refresh part would cost.

October 4, 2023

Wednesday’s Headlines: Concerted Effort Edition

The Great Lawn will be closed to the public six weeks earlier than normal because of those damn rockers. Plus other news.

October 4, 2023

Broadway Vision: Watch 15 Years of Transformation in a Single Streetfilm

It's hard to see the big picture of just what has been accomplished between Times and Union squares. That's where Clarence Eckerson Jr. comes in.

October 4, 2023

What Do ‘Livable’ Streets Look Like in an Era of Driverless Cars?

In today's Brake podcast, Kea Wilson asks Bruce Appleyard what future livable streets have in a world of autonomous cars.

October 4, 2023

NYPD Steps Up Effort Against Illegal Mopeds, But Some Advocates Want a Different Approach

The NYPD seized some illegal wheels from delivery workers in the middle of their route on Wednesday, part of a stepped-up effort.

October 4, 2023
See all posts