Dear Mr. Brodsky: What Now?

In today’s Times, Richard Brodsky weighs in on the pitfalls of shortchanging capital needs in the face of the immediate MTA budget crisis.

"The need for investment in the system is gargantuan," said Assemblyman Richard L. Brodsky,
a Democrat from Westchester County who is chairman of a committee that
oversees the authority. "Twenty-five years from now what we do on the
capital plan will resonate much more loudly than what the debate is
going to be about fare increases."

"It would be a terrible mistake to take whatever resources may be
available and use them all on the operating side," Mr. Brodsky said.

The key words here: "whatever resources may be available." As the MTA contemplates eliminating bus routes and subway lines in addition to raising fares, we have not yet heard a proposed solution from Brodsky, who promised Streetsblog in April that he and his colleagues, having killed congestion pricing, would "continue … good faith efforts to deal with the real problems of congestion and mass transit funding."

We have a message in with Brodsky’s office in hopes of getting his views on potential service cuts, fare hikes, and the possibility that the Ravitch Commission will recommend measures that he has opposed in the past, including congestion pricing.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Twenty-One NYC Reps Back Brodsky’s Student Fare Falsehood

|
On Friday we noted that Assembly Member Richard Brodsky’s latest anti-transit argument — that "the actual cost of free and discounted student fares is close to zero" — doesn’t hold water. A letter from Brodsky addressed to MTA CEO Jay Walder calls for reinstating student MetroCards, laying blame for the program’s potential elimination at the […]

Brodsky: Assembly “Working to Find Partners” for MTA Funding

|
Last week we e-mailed a short list of questions about the MTA financial crisis to Assembly Member Richard Brodsky. Here are his responses, received yesterday, shortly after we posted our "doomsday" scorecard. Streetsblog: Given the MTA’s need for both operating and capital funds, what revenue streams would you like to see tapped at this point […]

Traffic Pricing Is Evolving. Can Its Opponents?

|
“The difficulty lies, not in the new ideas, but in escaping from the old ones,” wrote John Maynard Keynes in his ground-breaking 1935 treatise, “The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money.” Keynes was bemoaning budget-balancing nostrums that deepened the Great Depression. But the famed economist’s lament applies equally to Richard Brodsky’s exhumation last week […]