Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Barack Obama

Ask the Candidates to Talk Transportation at Tomorrow’s Debate

debate.jpg
Insert new question here.

We've noted throughout this election season that transportation policy is something of a third rail in presidential politics. Gas prices and auto industry jobs are irresistible fodder for campaign promises, but even the candidate who has decent ideas about rail travel and bike infrastructure doesn't mention transit on the stump. (The other one doesn't have much to say in the first place.)

If you want topics like intercity rail and federal support for transit projects to get more attention on the national stage, the place to go is the Transportation for America website. T4A is currently collecting signatures calling on Obama and -- suspend your disbelief -- McCain to address the future of the U.S. transportation system at the final presidential debate Wednesday night. Sign on by 1:00 p.m. tomorrow and your petition will be delivered to campaign representatives before the debate.

Wondering how to make the case for transit to a national audience? T4A policy director Mariia Zimmerman puts it in compelling dollars-and-cents terms in this piece, "Reinventing American Transportation," which accompanies the Blueprint for America series on PBS. (Excerpt after the jump.)

Today, transportation is the second highest household expense afterhousing. America has invested in a stunning national highway system,but lags far behind other nations in building transit and high speedrail corridors that could complete our national transportation system.

For some families, long commutes and a lack of affordable or convenienttransit mean that they are actually spending more on transportationthan housing, particularly in exurban areas where people have reliedupon the "drive until you qualify" approach to homeownership. And yetfor those who do have transit available, they are saving almost $9,500per year. Public transportation already saves the U.S. 4.2 billiongallons of gasoline each year.

Providing the transit, walking and biking infrastructure so that morepeople in our growing nation can live in closer proximity to dailyneeds and use their cars less could save billions more gallons of oil.It can also restore value to many of our urban neighborhoods: In mostregions, homes near jobs and/or transit stations are holding theirvalue, while those with the longest commutes are seeing steep declinesand little buyer interest.

America has a long history of visionary transportation investment thathas left a sizable imprint on our landscape and world standing. Ourcanals, railroads, bridges, and highways have shaped settlementpatterns and served as the backbone of our economy. While theseinvestments shaped the past, it is time now to ask what kind ofinvestments America needs today when gasoline prices are high, oildependence is a national threat, climate change is threatening theglobe, and families are looking for more affordable and reliableoptions.

The next president and Congress should endorse a bold program to buildmodern, world-class train and bus systems in our cities and towns,high-speed rail that connects urban and rural areas, complete streetssafe for biking and walking, and to get our highways, bridges andexisting transit in tip-top shape.

Photo: ddkim/Flickr

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Bad Data Alert: Council Tears Apart DOT Daylighting Study

The internal review, obtained by Streetsblog, dismantles DOT's fear-mongering.

November 10, 2025

Former DOT Boss: Here’s What Mayor Mamdani Needs as Transportation Commish

Bottom line: The next commissioner needs to be willing to move aside staffers who are unwilling to be change-agents and to empower all the bright (often young) players who embrace the future.

November 10, 2025

Elise Stefanik Wants to Be Governor — Yet Says Nothing About Transit

Elise Stefanik’s campaign launch suggest her intent to use the MTA as a political pawn to stoke fear, not maintain and expand transit.

November 10, 2025

Monday’s Headlines: Car Terror in Brooklyn Edition

Car drivers ran rampant in Boro Park. Plus other news.

November 10, 2025

Trump’s Penn Station Plan Could Saddle New York Commuters With New Fees

Amtrak's plan to privatize the operation of the massive transit hub could open the door to sticking transit riders with extra fees.

November 7, 2025

Q&A: Will The Bronx’s New Council Member Take On Car Culture?

Union leader Shirley Aldebol took on Republican Kristy Marmorato and won — and now she's ready to fight for better transit and safer streets.

November 7, 2025
See all posts