Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Janette Sadik-Khan

Is NYC’s “Sustainable Streets” Plan a Communist Plot?

brodsky_stalin.jpg

This week's Observer is running a profile of DOT Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan. It focuses on the speed with which many of DOT's Sustainable Streets projects are moving ahead and seems to suggest either:

a) Improving conditions for New York City's pedestrians, cyclists and bus riders is a Communist plot. Or,
b) The change that Sadik-Khan is bringing to New York City's streets is akin to the Russian Revolution.

You be the judge:

On the ideological scale of transportation planning, her policieserr far closer to Trotsky than Reagan. She is decidedly pro-bike andpro-pedestrian, and thus inherently anti-automobile, earning herconstant praise from the normally critical transit advocates.

This raises some obvious questions. If Sadik-Khan is Leon Trotsky does that mean suburban Westchester Assemblyman and congestion pricing foe Richard Brodsky is Josef Stalin? Will Sadik-Khan be exiled to an upstate gulag when Bloomberg is term-limited out of office?

All fun and games aside, as we gird ourselves for the Tony Avellafication of the 2009 mayoral race, the last two paragraphs of the article are worth discussing:

With many of Ms. Sadik-Khan’s keyinitiatives, there is a potential lack of permanency. The same featuresthat allow the DOT’s projects to get in the ground swiftly could alsoseal their fate in a future administration: The city has claimed lanesof Broadway as open space with some epoxy, sand, paint, plants andtables, yet a future administration could just as easily pack up thosetables and put lane markers right back down on the roadway.

This prospect seemed almostincomprehensible to Ms. Sadik-Khan, who seemed to think that publicresistance to it would prove too great, the ease of removalnotwithstanding. “People are very protective about their public space,”she said. “I think it would be very hard to take these spaces back tothe state that they were in before.”

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

DOT Canal Street Plan Adds Pedestrian Space, Bike Route, But Next Mayor Must Think Bigger

The changes are a good start, but Canal Street deserves a radical transformation.

September 12, 2025

Friday’s Headlines: In Spite of You Edition

A new report shows NYC DOT can accomplish a lot when the mayor cuts his meddling. Plus more news.

September 12, 2025

Jay Z-Backed Times Square Casino Shrinks Sidewalks and Bus Lanes to Serve More Cars

New Yorkers aren't only gambling with their future inside the casino: Developer SL Green wants to remove a bus lane and the 19-foot "super sidewalks" installed on Eighth Avenue just three years ago.

September 11, 2025

The Explainer: Council Seeks to Ban Sale of E-Bikes That Can Go 25MPH

A new city council bill would ban the sale of Class 3 e-bikes, which are only allowed in NYC and can reach speeds of 25 mph.

September 11, 2025

West Side Community Board Fails to Back Safety Over Parking

Oh, they're fine with safety ... as long as parking comes first. No, seriously, that's what they did.

September 11, 2025

OPINION: DOT ‘Smart Curbs’ Pilot Deserves a Chance to Succeed 

Compromising the project to protect free parking puts the interests of a tiny minority over systemic changes that would benefit everyone, says one activist.

September 11, 2025
See all posts