Parks Department ‘Ghosts’ Memorial For Slain Marine Park Cyclist [UPDATED]

The ghost bike for Robert Sommer in Marine Park. Don't look for it now. The Parks Department removed it. Photo: Sommer family
The ghost bike for Robert Sommer in Marine Park. Don't look for it now. The Parks Department removed it. Photo: Sommer family

Updated | The family of cyclist Robert Sommer is blasting the Parks Department for its ghoulish decision to secretly remove the ghost bike tribute to the dead biker, calling the “outrageous” act nothing short of “grave robbery.”

The white-painted bike had been installed on June 25 for Sommer, who died on May 12 when he was hit in Marine Park by a 20-year-old male motorist who was not charged. The Parks Department removed the ghost bike on or about July 9 — the same day that 1,000 cyclists gathered in Washington Square Park for a “die-in” to protest the increase in road fatalities.

Victim Robert Sommer
Victim Robert Sommer

“Installation of memorials on parks property, including the perimeters of parks that we maintain, requires official authorization,” a Parks Department rep wrote to Steve Scofield, who volunteers with the Ghost Bike Project. “When the public installs impromptu memorials on parkland, we allow a grace period of one month before removal.”

The department did not follow its own guidelines, waiting only 16 days before removing the tribute from the crash site at Avenue U near E. 33rd Street. Scofield said he was not aware of any “official” authorization process.

A relative of Sommer said the family was blindsided by the removal because survivors had been “assured” by park rangers that the ghost bike was being cared for.

“They assured me that as long as there are no burning candles and we keep the area clean and safe the memorial could remain,” Myrna Roman told Scofield in an email.

She said the family was stunned to hear that the bike had been removed.


Robert Sommer's ghost bike before it was removed.

“Here we are today unable to understand what I can only describe as the equivalent of grave robbery,” said Roman, an aunt. “This act is heartbreaking and outrageous at the same time. There exist miserable, malcontent, misfits who only understand destruction.

“Thank goodness not all of us are like them. Apparently, they have never known the kind of love, kindness and generosity that Rob showered everyone with. Rob, in heaven, has already forgiven them,” Roman added.

Scofield told Streetsblog he will fight the Parks Department’s move.

“I escalate this much as necessary to have this bike ghost bike restored,” he said.

It is unclear why Parks officials cracked down at this particular moment. The city is in the midst of a possibly unprecedented rise in cyclist deaths, with 15 bike riders being killed so far this year, up from 10 all of last year. Sommer was the eighth casualty.

It’s also unclear why some ghost bikes seem to be permitted to stay on Parks property without issue. There is a ghost bike for Madison Lyden on the edge of Central Park at West 67th Street, for example. That ghost bike was temporarily removed for the Thanksgiving Day parade, but has been restored.

After initial publication of this story, the Parks Department sent Streetsblog a statement from the agency’s Brooklyn Borough Commissioner Martin Maher:

On behalf of NYC Parks, I sincerely apologize that the Robert Sommer’s ghost bike memorial was removed without contacting the family beforehand. The removal was not intended as an affront to those mourning Robert’s passing. We respect his memory, and will ensure that other memorials in our parks are handled with care and sensitivity.

The agency also said that whomever removed the bike did so in violation of a new policy that was put into effect in April. The new policy, however, suggests that ghost bikes will not be allowed to remain on parks property beyond two weeks:

  • Patrons looking to start/place a memorial should contact their local Parks Borough Operations office so that a location can be agreed upon, get contact information, and affirm the regulation.
  • Memorials on parkland may be placed at the site of someone’s death for a maximum of two weeks’ time after which Parks will remove.
  • With the exception of flowers and candles, Parks will store any removed memorials for up to one month while we make a good faith effort to contact the family of the deceased or whomever placed the memorial in order to return memorial materials.
  • While 311 does not recognize ghost bikes as abandoned property, it is a memorial and as such, must comply with our regulations.

Update: An earlier version of this story attributed a Parks letter to Scofield as coming from the commissioner himself. That was not the case.

  • Tooscrapps

    Classy comments in the Brooklyn Paper.

    “a cyclist death in no worse than any other, yet we don’t see memorials going up in every square foot of our landscape” – Great solution. We should paint bodies (with family permission) on streets and intersections where peds are struck and killed. Maybe that would wake some drivers up to the real carnage.

  • Joe R.

    Have a ghoulish looking corpse model every place a pedestrian is killed. No grace period of a month, either. Leave it there forever. When the city is full of these people might finally wake up.

  • Teofila

    It is conceivable to easily abandon yr less paying 9 am to 5 pm job and then start earning check each month approx 12000 dollars working at home. Let’s be real, no matter where you’re doing work from, you’re still doing just that: working. While doing a home based job you might have Extremely flexible daily schedule – you can take breaks any moment, feel absolutely no rush to hang up on your family while they contact you, and have meal at any unusual time you choose, Forget crowds and heavy traffic – Absolutely no stuffing yourself into a rickety transportation tube, having people scuff your brand-new shoes, or walking behind agonizingly slow people who apparently don’t know what a straight line is, More time with loved ones -Take care of a sick significant other at your home, get ready for your children earlier in the daytime, get some extra snuggles in with your doggo, or simply just have some relaxing time to your self! Give it a look, what it is about…

  • AMH

    “[Madison Lyden’s] ghost bike was temporarily removed for the Thanksgiving Day parade, but has been restored.”

    Interesting–who removed and restored it? Parks? NYPD? The installer?

    “The agency also said that whomever removed the bike did so in violation of a new policy that was put into effect in April. The new policy, however, suggests that ghost bikes will not be allowed to remain on parks property beyond two weeks.”

    So…the person who removed the bike actually was following the new policy?

  • Thanks for another excellent article. Where else could anyone get that type of information in such a perfect way of writing – GHD SPORTS APK

  • iSkyscraper

    Parks can’t properly manage concessions, geese, litter, hookah, loud music… what makes you think they can manage something as delicate as memorials?

  • Rubye

    Late night hours job at the office , handling all of the annoying work load. The promotion and recognition you always wanted. A family getaway you constantly desires for. So, you have the possible opportunity to achieve all and more. A web based occupation which ensure that you get everything you ever wanted. Freedom to get the job done from anywhere , the income you always wanted and a valuable time which you are able to spend with the one you love , You will capable of doing everything. Therefore, work in the direction of your dream. A web-based chance which makes accomplish all your aims. Do the job few hrs daily and make lot of money , nearly $26000 every week. This opportunity really excellent. So get set go and explore >>>


Sanitation Department Spares Ghost Bikes From Trash Heap

The Department of Sanitation has backed off its controversial plan to remove ghost bikes from the streets of New York, relenting to a public outcry in favor of the memorials to cyclists killed while riding. Proposed rules governing the removal of derelict bicycles released in June would have taken away even the best-maintained memorials, but […]

In Defense of Ghost Bikes

Aaron’s piece questioning the memorialization of bike fatalities reminds us that cycle advocacy is rife with paradoxes. Drawing attention to cycling deaths and injuries can be powerful politically and symbolically but may also scare off would-be riders. Moreover, cycling is safer for all when there are more cyclists. We’ve all wrestled with these contradictions and […]

This Week: West Side Greenway Changes, Giovanni Nin Memorial

A late addition to the Streetsblog calendar that Hudson River Greenway users will want to squeeze into their schedules tonight: Community Board 7’s Parks and Recreation committee will hear from the Parks Department about changes to the greenway in Riverside Park intended to reduce conflicts between pedestrians and cyclists. The greenway can get uncomfortably crowded […]

Ghost Bikes Memorial Ride Marks Another Year of Loss

Grief, solidarity and resolve brought out two hundred New York cyclists yesterday for the third annual Ghost Bikes Memorial Ride, to commemorate cyclists killed by motor vehicle drivers last year. At the Canal Street & Bowery triangle by the entrance to the Manhattan Bridge bike path, Steve Hindy raised his empty arms in a pantomime […]