Earth to ‘Cycling’ Commish O’Neill: Here’s How the NYPD Rank-And-File Think About People Who Bike

crumpled bike

If NYPD Commissioner James O’Neill truly loves people who get around on bikes, he has a funny way of showing it.

We learned as much on Monday, three days after someone at the 103rd Precinct in Queens offended cyclists with a Vision Zero-themed tweet that featured a crumpled up bicycle and a suggestion that it’s perfectly OK to hate cyclists.

“Love ’em or hate ’em, they’re here,” read the emoji-filled March 29 tweet from the Jamaica precinct (below). “Keep an extra eye Screen Shot 2019-04-01 at 4.55.49 PM out for them cyclist emoji (and Motorcyclist) as you drive they are harder to spot.”

This tweet has since been deleted — after it enraged city cyclists.
This tweet has since been deleted — after it enraged city cyclists. Screenshot: Eben Weiss

The tweet outraged many cyclists, with its “Animal Farm”-in-reverse implication that people who get around on two wheels are bad and those who get around on four wheels are good. The other implication, of course, is that it’s all right to harbor anti-cyclist bias in your heart.

“Bikes are ridden by people. People. Who have died because of thoughtless street design and no police enforcement,” tweeted Gail Thomas. “We are People. Who die.

On Monday, while the original tweet was still active, O’Neill was asked by Streetsblog whether the tweet conveyed an anti-cyclist bias within the NYPD, namely that cops agree that it’s perfectly acceptable for drivers to “hate” people who chose to get around by bike.

“Maybe the tone of the message — and the picture — was definitely not appropriate,” said O’Neill, who frequently refers to himself as a cyclist. “‘Love ’em or hate ’em.’ … As everyone knows, I love ’em.”

Then, without pausing, he veered into territory that suggests he shares the view of many drivers that people who bike are acceptable as long as they’re not in the way.

“But bicycles do have to adhere to the rules of the road,” O’Neill said, apropos of nothing, before describing the greatest thing about cyclists … from a driver’s perspective: “The fact is there are less cars in Manhattan because of bicyclists.”

Streetsblog asked if O’Neill was concerned about his officers being “anti-bike.” Again, he downplayed the concern.

“I don’t know about whether all 36,000 cops love bicycles. I know one,” he said, again referring to himself. He did not allow another follow-up, which would have centered on what his reaction would have been if a top police official tweeted, “Love ’em or hate ’em” about a racial or ethnic group.

Still, the tweet must have been something of a black eye for a commissioner who prides himself on his commitment to Vision Zero. Indeed, sometime after the press conference, the tweet from the 103rd Precinct was taken down and replaced with something far more anodyne — yet still with the picture of the crumbled bike, a haunting image for anyone who has been hit or nearly hit by a 3,000-pound machine.

This is the supposedly better tweet.
This is the supposedly better tweet.

A call to the 103rd Precinct was referred to the community affairs office, which did not respond. O’Neill’s spokesman at 1 Police Plaza also did not respond to several follow-up questions.

The tweet will likely be dismissed by some observers as just an awkward attempt at humor — you know, from one put-upon driver to another. But it comes as new research confirmed what cyclists have long known: Drivers see cyclists as less than human.

In the study, Australian researchers asked participants about their attitudes toward cyclists — and 31 percent rated cyclists as less than human. The dehumanization was even worse among non-cyclists: 49 percent viewed people who ride a bike as non-human, according to the study published in the journal Transportation Research,

The study also connected the dehumanization to actual aggressive behavior toward cyclists. The more dehumanization that a person admitted to, the more likely that that person behaved aggressively towards a person on a bike, the study found.

“Respondents who rated cyclists as 89 percent human or less showed 1.87 times more direct aggressive behaviors to cyclists compared to the respondents who rated cyclist as more than 90 percent human,” the research team wrote.

Aggressive behavior toward cyclists is fairly widespread, previous research has shown. About 70 percent of cyclists have experienced some sort of harassment from motorists, some research has shown. One study found 15 percent report having had an object thrown at them.

“Public references to violence against cyclists are not uncommon and rarely given the same condemnation as, for example, violence toward women or bullying,” wrote the lead researcher, Alexa Delbosc.

To put violence towards cyclists in perspective, in the 103rd Precinct last year, there were 3,354 crashes, causing injuries to 43 cyclists and 216 pedestrians.

But, you know, love ’em or hate ’em.

  • Bustoff

    Every time (well most) I ride, I get close passed. 3 foot law in place in my state for 10 years, nobody has ever heard of it. Wave people off and they get aggressive.

  • William Lawson

    ““But bicycles do have to adhere to the rules of the road” – this exact statement seems to be a common vocal tic of virtually every non-cyclist who offers their opinion on anything to do with cyclists, regardless of how irrelevant it is to the subject. They just have to get it in there otherwise they’ll apparently burst into flames. The story could be about a truck driver who drove down a protected bike lane taking out dozens of cyclists and these assholes would end their statements of condolence with “having said that, it should be said that cyclists have to respect road law too….”

  • Seriously, the slightest challenge to one of these metal box operators, and they get extremely aggressive. Even supposedly civilized people tend to get all f’ing crazy whenever their god-given right to drive however they want is questioned.

  • Sincerely hope I cross paths with Commissioner O’Neill, while I am riding my Univega at full speed.

  • Vooch

    I believe the correct term is

    Hulking Death Machine


  • david

    He’s a cyclist right? Sounds like a poor attempt at something aimed at positive.

  • Otto Carnage

    “Every car is a potential weapon, every motorist a short fuse.”- BSNYC

  • The thing is they show the bike, not the person.. totally missing the point that bicyclists and pedestrians are PEOPLE being hurt..

  • Boeings+Bikes

    What if a prominent voice in the cycling community tweeted: “Cops, love ’em or hate ’em, they’re there so try not to kill them” with a photo of a police funeral? No one would think that was acceptable, so when we turn the tables…

  • Alicia

    And 99% of stories about a bicyclist being injured or killed will mention whether or not the cyclist is wearing a helmet despite the fact that it is not a legal requirement in most places in the US (with a couple exceptions ).

  • Dave

    Fucking pigs; the rabbis and imams are right–pork IS bad for one’s health!

  • Dave

    “She was asking for it the way she was dressed.”

  • penny

    A trip to the most amazing places in the world with your loved ones and a beautiful house you aspire to to purchase. Is your present job truly capable of fulfilling your dreams? If your answer is no then it truly is time for you to change. We bring to you an internet based job which is certainly as simple as being on any search engine like google or doing copy paste task. It does not require any technical knowledge and it does not require anything to sell. It surely is not like any fakes that claims to make you “rich over night” and then ended up being pyramid schemes or stuff where you need to sell to your friends and family. It is easy to start and you will get the instruction guide within few weeks. You could make nearly $13,000-$4,000 on a monthly basis. You are able to dedicate some more time with my family members and can go out for incredible trips. This job offers you opportunity to be own own boss and can work from any location. Do not wait for too long, Go and check it out this awesome online job opportunity.>>>>>>>>>>>> ENTER NOW