Joe Lhota’s Resignation from the MTA: What You Need to Know

The outgoing chair leaves the transit authority stuck in the same crisis he was tasked to solve.

Just-departed MTA chairman Joe Lhota. Photo: MTA/Flickr
Just-departed MTA chairman Joe Lhota. Photo: MTA/Flickr

Could real leadership be around the corner?

MTA Chairman Joe Lhota resigned on Friday, after just 16 months atop the nation’s largest transit system.

Governor Cuomo appointed Lhota in June of last year, just as the subway crisis was becoming a national embarrassment (for him). Lhota carried the governor’s water, never criticizing his de facto boss publicly and, instead, harping on Mayor de Blasio to help fund subway repairs. Lhota ignored challenges of the governor’s making — such as the fact that the state is still $7.3 billion short on its contribution to the MTA’s current capital plan.

Lhota’s full-time job as chief of staff of the NYU-Langone hospital system gave him little time to advocate for the transit system. Instead, Andy Byford, whom Lhota hired as buses and subways chief in January, emerged as the MTA’s most forceful advocate. That left the rest of the system, including the crumbling Long Island Rail Road, without a champion.

So what does Lhota’s departure mean? Let’s begin:

Does this mean the subway crisis is over?

When he came on as chair, Lhota said his goal was to get the agency back on track. He declared “Mission Accomplished” in his resignation statement: “The Subway Action Plan was developed in my first month at the MTA and it has successfully arrested the subway’s decline,” he said.

That assessment is not totally wrong: The subways have in fact posted improving numbers in the last few months, but the $836 million subway action plan — introduced way back in July 2017 — isn’t why.

“They’ve seen basically one or two months of better numbers,” said Jon Orcutt of TransitCenter. “You couldn’t point to anything earlier this year that showed that one year of the subway action plan was making an impact.”

Meanwhile, any straphanger can tell you that whatever Lhota may have accomplished wasn’t enough. On Friday alone, signal problems forced the MTA to stop M train service altogether — and caused delays on even more lines, Gothamist reported. Incidents of that sort continue to be a regular occurrence.

So what did Lhota actually accomplish?

The chief accomplishment of Lhota’s tenure, Orcutt said, was hiring Andy Byford, the man tasked with restoring the city’s subways and buses to their former glory.

In Byford, Lhota and Cuomo found someone who knew how to fix a transit system and, perhaps more importantly, could be a neutral advocate for the agency trusted by everyone — including Cuomo’s political adversaries. Even as they hit Cuomo for letting the subways crumble, both primary challenger Cynthia Nixon and Republican gubernatorial nominee Marc Molinaro praised Byford. Mayor de Blasio has also expressed confidence in Byford’s leadership.

But the MTA faces a credibility problem that extends far past Byford’s perch at New York City Transit. The Long Island Rail Road has struggles not unlike those facing the subways. MTA capital projects across the board continue to go over-budget and past their deadlines.

“One of the things that did not happen in the last few years sufficiently was clear accountability about how money was spent, including the money the city has contributed to the MTA,” de Blasio told WNYC’s Brian Lehrer on Friday morning.

He’s right.

What’s next for the MTA?

Byford has been able to advocate for the subways and buses while taking responsibility for the challenges they face. The next chairperson must do that for the entire agency, advocates told Streetsblog. Otherwise, state legislators will be loath to provide it with badly needed funding or pass congestion pricing.

“We need somebody who’s going to get out there and talk about what’s changing inside the MTA,” said Nick Sifuentes of the Tri-State Transportation Campaign. “The next chair needs to tell a new story about the MTA, or it’s going to be brutally hard to get the resources from Albany.”

“The politics that the MTA chairman needs to be playing are the politics of getting the funding that the MTA needs, not the politics of weighing in on the squabbles between the city and the state.”

One thing is certain: another part-time chief executive won’t cut it.

“The MTA badly needs a full-time CEO. It’s a humongous, sprawling enterprise,” said John Kaehny of the good-government group Reinvent Albany. “It’s the biggest state government entity. If you said the head of the state DOT was working full-time as a dentist, people would think you’re completely crazy. It’s a massive job.”

The newly elected Democratic state senate could be instrumental in ensuring that, or they could pass the buck to Cuomo as they did when he appointed Lhota last year: The state senate received and approved the appointment in mere hours. A “confirmation hearing,” if you could call it that, took place via video conference at around midnight. Lhota’s controversial board membership at the Madison Square Garden Company, whose 21,000-seat arena is a key impediment to improving Penn Station, never even came up.

“We would have loved a full-time, committed Joe Lhota, but a half-time and fully compromised Joe Lhota had to go,” Kaehny said. “It’s a good opportunity for the Democratic majority in the senate to finally hold real hearings.”

  • brian43ny

    Cynthia Nixon would be perfect for this job.

  • ohnonononono

    Byford hasn’t actually improved the subway or bus system yet, so I’m not sure I think his hiring can even be considered a success yet. It feels like he doesn’t have much actual authority, as if he’s a consultant who produced a plan that hasn’t really been implemented, and he’s a public face who comes out to public hearings, but doesn’t have any ability to impact day-to-day operations of how the MTA functions.

    It also feels like many of his programs are more of the same, and there’s little assessment of why things will work this time when they haven’t in the past. For instance the new group station managers program: there have been similar station manager programs in the past and we have no idea why they didn’t work and why this will work this time. I remember the prior station manager program being unveiled with a lot of hoopla and then fading away. They initially promised that the name, photo, and contact info for each manager would be posted in each station, and many were, but the manager of my station refused to be photographed and demanded his information be taken down because he feared for his safety. Years later everyone seemed to have forgotten about the idea. The station has always been dirty and remains dirty. The MTA doesn’t need a bunch of random new ideas and initiatives, they need to perform the basics more competently.

  • Larry Littlefield

    While cutting its staff due to a budget crisis?

    Perhaps Lhota resigned because his financial advisors told him that if the MTA tried to sell those 100-year bonds he was talking about years ago, no one sane would buy them, because the agency is already broke.

  • Larry Littlefield

    Down arrow doesn’t seem to be working, but I disagree.

    She yelled about school funding for years even though it was sky-high and had soared (offset by the cost of pension increases).

    She only started talking about the subway when it hit the NY Times, and I doubt she has any idea how it works. At least as a parent, she has some experience teaching children.

    For her, that congestion pricing revenue might not be used for transportation.

  • Joe R.

    The down arrow doesn’t work on Streetsblog, and frankly, I agree with that policy. It’s better to just respond to comments you disagree with and state why, rather than down voting.

    And yes, I agree with you about Nixon.

  • Jason

    Her MTA policy may not have amounted to much more than “give the experts the resources and support necessary to do their jobs”, but, sadly, that’d still be an improvement over the status quo.

  • Larry Littlefield

    If you don’t have enough understanding to confront the experts, you are in big trouble.

    I worked with these engineers. They think Washington Roebling is the guy who built the Brooklyn Bridge, not the guy who over-ran his budget.

    “That will be $200 billion or we might as well forget it.”

    Or, the outside experts say one thing, and the inside experts another.

  • fdtutf

    I just down-voted your comment as a test (and then reversed the down-vote). It worked fine.

  • qrt145

    “On Disqus, comments only display the total number of upvotes it has received. If someone downvotes a comment, the vote gets recorded but it would not affect the displayed vote count.”

  • Eric Talbot

    The down-vote doesn’t work when there are no up-votes. It DOES work where there ARE up-votes, and counteracts (neutralizes) them, one per voter.

    So, if a comment receives ten up-votes, and then later receives ten down-votes, it then appears as if no one voted it EITHER up OR down.

  • Joe R.

    Same thing happens to me the rare times I’ve tried it. I never would down vote comments I just happen to disagree with anyway. The rare times I’ve down voted comments elsewhere it was because the person was clearly a troll who was just there to disrupt things, not participate in the discussion.

  • fdtutf

    Oh, that makes sense. Thanks for the explanation.


MTA Chair Joe Lhota. Photo:  MTA/Marc Hermann via Wikimedia Commons

Joe Lhota Is Cuomo’s MTA Chief, Again, Sort Of

Late yesterday, Andrew Cuomo nominated former MTA chief Joe Lhota to resume the role at a time when the agency is grappling with a decline in reliability that has reached crisis proportions. Lhota was hastily confirmed by the State Senate as the 2017 legislative session came to an end last night.

Cuomo Selects Joe Lhota as Next MTA Chair

Governor Andrew Cuomo today named Joseph Lhota as his pick to run the nation’s largest transit system. Lhota, a former deputy mayor and budget director under mayor Rudy Giuliani, will officially hold the position of MTA CEO after a confirmation vote by the New York State Senate, which is not expected to pose much of […]

Joe Lhota: The MTA Needs New Tax Revenue

The MTA needs new revenues, announced chairman Joe Lhota during a broad-ranging panel discussion at Fordham University this morning. “There’s going to be the need for broad-based tax revenue somewhere within the system over the next couple of years,” Lhota said, noting that he’s generally the kind of conservative person loath to call for tax […]