I-81 Teardown Upstate Gains Ally In Rachel May’s Victory Over IDC Rogue

State Senator David Valesky did not take a position on replacing decrepit scar with a surface-level boulevard.

Syracuse's crumbling Interstate 81 viaduct. Photo: Onondaga Citizens League
Syracuse's crumbling Interstate 81 viaduct. Photo: Onondaga Citizens League

A years-long campaign to tear down an aging and lightly used interstate highway in Syracuse and replace it with a surface-level boulevard may have just gotten a crucial vote in Albany.

Democrat Rachel May, who upset State Senator David Valesky in the September primary, says she is a full-blown supporter of the so-called “community grid” plan to remove Interstate 81. Valesky, who was a member of the Republican-allied Independent Democratic Conference, undermined the effort by never taking a position.

“The city is for people and not for high speed vehicles,” May told Streetsblog last week. “[Removing the highway] would knit the sides of the city back together.”

Rachel May
Rachel May

Interstate 81 cuts a 3.75-mile gash through the heart of downtown Syracuse, separating communities, polluting adjacent neighborhoods, and preventing housing construction in what could be a thriving down neighborhood. With the aging viaduct nearing the end of its useful life, state DOT has spent years contemplating its future.

The Cuomo administration is currently weighing the cost and viability of three options for replacing the highway: the community grid, a new highway, and a hybrid tunnel alternative that would cost as much as $4.5 billion and take a decade to complete.

Because of its outrageous sticker price, in 2016 Governor Cuomo took the tunnel option off the table. He’s since backpedaled at the urging of some of the region’s elected officials — including Valesky — who wanted the tunnel option studied.

Valesky lives in suburban Oneida, population 11,000. Prominent voices within the city of Syracuse, meanwhile, have been proponents of the community grid option. First-year Mayor Ben Walsh is on board, as is the Syracuse Post-Standard, which ran a front page editorial touting the benefits of removing the highway and accompanying traffic from the heart of downtown.

The $1.3-billion grid project would replace the highway with a network of local streets, reconnecting neighborhoods torn apart by I-81’s construction nearly 60 years ago. Proponents say the teardown would not only provide surrounding areas safer streets, but also create new jobs, new housing, and new development. And the resulting road itself would serve the local area better than the current limited-access highway, which was designed simply to speed cars through Syracuse.

“We’re anticipating that more people, particularly stakeholders, will see the facts — of not only the cost and duration but the economic benefits the community grid will provide for the community,” said Peter Sarver, executive director of Alliance of Communities Transforming Syracuse.

Those benefits are many and great, May added.

“Syracuse is a city where most of the land is taken up with nontaxable properties, either universities or hospital or government buildings or parks and lots of parking space,” May said. “This would be an extraordinary windfall of 20 acres roughly of land that could be developed into mixed-use housing and retail and office space and could actually come onto the city’s tax rolls, which would be massively important to the city.”

The tunnel option, which Cuomo and suburban elected officials have promoted as a compromise, “would be very costly to the city over the long haul,” she said, “doubling down on the idea that the whole point of the city is to move people through as fast as possible.”

Sarver said Valesky — who is contemplating a general election run on the Independence line — would have been wise to articulate those benefits, instead of taking a wait-and-see approach.

That was Valesky’s mistake. He was just waiting for the technical experts to give him cover,” Sarver said. “Leadership isn’t just about what the experts think.”

  • Larry Littlefield

    Oneida is actually a pre-suburbanization city too, albeit a small one. It’s representatives ought to be thinking along those lines.

  • HamTech87

    Any idea of May’s chances of winning this seat? Not sure what the politics are there, but I assume the GOP is stronger there. Valesky didn’t have a general election opponent since 2010, but that election wasn’t a landslide.

  • bolwerk

    Probably not much danger, especially this year. The GOP hasn’t seriously contested that district in years.

  • Larry Littlefield

    I believe it was a Republican seat before Valesky picked it up.

    But the demographics might be radically different from back then in any event. Folks who work for the government and the retired are probably the only people left.

    “Syracuse is a city where most of the land is taken up with nontaxable properties, either universities or hospital or government buildings or parks and lots of parking space,” May said.

  • HamTech87

    It is a big, sprawling district with lots of car-dependency. We’ll see.

  • bolwerk

    Possible. At least tearing down I-81 through Syracuse shouldn’t be a driver vs. transit or city vs. suburb issue. It’s a horrendously useless corridor that mainly contributes to urban congestion.

  • LimestoneKid

    Uh, folks, it’s the Syracuse Post-Standard NOT “the Syracuse Post-Dispatch”.

  • bggb

    “The Cuomo administration is currently weighing the cost and viability of three options for replacing the highway: the community grid, a new highway, and a hybrid tunnel alternative that would cost as much as $4.5 billion and take a decade to complete.”

    Ugh. Lemme guess which one Cuomo is going to pick.

  • DoctorMemory

    Next up: the BQE.

  • Larry Littlefield

    Only if he can make NYC pay for it.

  • 24680BDFHJ

    Maybe mixed up with the nearby Observer-Dispatch in Utica.

  • JoeDokes999

    Because of the powerful oil/auto industries, there is certain to be push-back against any sensible proposals that remove highways.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Is Cuomo Ready to Rid Downtown Syracuse of I-81?

|
Speaking in Syracuse yesterday, Governor Andrew Cuomo appeared to indicate support for the removal of 3.75 miles of Interstate 81, the aging elevated highway that cuts through the heart of downtown. “That could be a transformative project that really jump-starts the entire region,” Cuomo said, according to the Post-Standard. “I-81 did a lot of damage — a classic […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Battle Lines Drawn Over Syracuse Highway Teardown

|
To keep the aging relic blighting downtown, or tear it down? That’s the question looming over many American cities with Eisenhower-era highways these days. And nowhere is that question more immediate than in Syracuse. Syracuse’s Interstate 81 is one of the best candidates for a highway teardown in the country. The aging elevated freeway is widely […]

Cuomo Taps Syracuse Ex-Mayor Matt Driscoll, His “Go-To Guy,” for State DOT

|
News came yesterday afternoon that Governor Andrew Cuomo is changing leadership at the state Department of Transportation, replacing Joan McDonald with former Syracuse Mayor Matt Driscoll. Cuomo canned McDonald, who’s been on the job since 2011, over a dispute about snow removal in Buffalo, according to Jimmy Vielkind of Capital New York. Driscoll might be familiar to Streetsblog […]