NYC Traffic Deaths Are Falling, But Not Fast Enough

Traffic fatalities have dropped every year since the de Blasio administration launched its Vision Zero initiative. The improvement was not substantial in 2016, however.
Traffic fatalities have dropped every year since the de Blasio administration launched its Vision Zero initiative. The improvement was not substantial in 2016, however. Image: DOT

For the second consecutive year, traffic fatalities reached a new low in New York City, according to crash data released by City Hall this morning [PDF]. Progress slowed substantially in 2016, however, and all the improvement was limited to motor vehicle occupants and motorcycle riders.

The results indicate that the de Blasio administrations’s traffic safety efforts are working, but that the mayor and his agencies aren’t acting decisively enough to reach the Vision Zero goal of eliminating traffic deaths by 2024.

Total traffic deaths declined from 234 in 2015 to 229 last year, while pedestrian deaths increased from 139 to 144 and cyclist deaths increased from 14 to 18.

“The first three years of Vision Zero in New York have been the safest three-year period in history on our City’s roadways,” said Transportation Commissioner Polly Trottenberg in a statement that noted NYC’s continued improvement bucks the national trend. Nationwide, traffic fatalities rose 7.1 percent in 2015, and early numbers indicate an increase in 2016 as well.

At a press conference this morning, city officials laid out the steps DOT and NYPD took to improve traffic safety in 2016. Enforcement of speeding and failure to yield — violations that factor into a large share of traffic deaths — has increased, and DOT has escalated the installation of safer signals and street designs.

DOT Deputy Commissioner Ryan Russo highlighted the 1,200 leading pedestrian intervals — signals that give pedestrians a head start on turning drivers — installed since 2014. The number of pedestrians killed by MTA bus drivers declined from 10 in 2015 to three last year, which Russo credited to 157 LPIs installed by bus stops. In 2016, the city put down 400 speed humps and implemented 105 street redesign projects, which can range in scope from a single intersection to miles of roadway.

The most substantial safety improvements have come at locations DOT identified as high priorities in its 2015 pedestrian safety action plans. Last year, 72 percent of DOT’s redesign projects were in priority locations, Russo said. Compared to the five-year average before Vision Zero was initiated in 2014, traffic fatalities at all the high-priority locations in the city were down 29 percent last year.

Still, in 2016 the city did not match the rate of improvement in the previous two years:

Pedestrian fatalities have stayed mostly flat since seeing a huge decline in the first year of Vision Zero. Image: DOT
Pedestrian fatalities have stayed mostly flat since a big decline in the first year of Vision Zero. Image: DOT

One factor may be that in 2014 and 2015, the city substantially expanded its automated speed enforcement program. A speed camera typically “reduces speeding violations by 50 percent within its first year,” according to the city [PDF]. But Albany leaders failed to pass a bill enabling a larger speed camera program in 2016.

Without more automated speed enforcement, DOT’s street redesign efforts are even more essential to achieving the city’s Vision Zero goals. But for two years, de Blasio has declined calls from City Council members to increase funding for street redesigns.

Asked whether additional funding would speed up the pace of progress, Russo deflected the question, citing the extensive preparation and outreach that the city conducts for redesign projects. “This isn’t simply just like repaving streets, [where] for every dollar you get a certain amount of square foot of repaving,” he said.

“We have to keep in mind that the last three years were the safest three years for pedestrians that we’ve ever had,” Russo said. “What we’re confident is that if we hadn’t done what we did — with the enhanced enforcement, with the education, with all the street engineering that was focused on the priority corridors and priority locations — we certainly would be talking about a much higher number in that scenario.”

  • Morris Zapp

    Ryan Russo, DOT Deputy Commissioner of Petulance

  • Larry Littlefield

    You didn’t mention the severe injury trend, but then neither did the report.

    As Streetsblog has noted here in the past deaths are subject to temporary annual fluctuations that don’t reflect long term trends, while injuries are more telling.

    Are subway deaths still running about 40-50 per year, half due to suicides?

  • Sean Kelliher

    My follow up question to Ryan Russo would have been this – if DOT has found these successful measures to curb injures and fatalities, why does it feel the need to conduct such extensive preparation and research for street re-designs?

    I know the answer to the question – re-designs often take away parking and make vehicle owners angry, and DOT doesn’t want to make vehicle owners angry. It’d rather make other people injured or dead.

    As an example – on West End Avenue in Manhattan, after a spate of pedestrian deaths a few years ago, DOT implemented a “road diet”consisting of a few pedestrian islands, left turns bays, and extra wide parking lanes. When advocates pushed for more such as a protected bike lane with extensive pedestrian islands, Russo made fun of the Streetsblog reporter saying something like “what planet are you living on?” and the “green awning” buildings would not allow it. Polly Trottenberg added some weak statement about easing people into seeing the street in a different way and then maybe we could move onto more “complete street” designs in the future. Likely, we wont see these changes for over a decade or more.

  • When the goal is zero, and there are 229 deaths and over 10,000 injuries, it is disturbing to hear the people responsible so satisfied with the fact the number is decreasing.. Duh! It is supposed to decrease, but much faster!

    car occupants are 20% safer but cyclists are 30% less safe ! And pedestrians are still less safe: this trend has been the same in the last 10 years with car safety getting much better, much faster. DOT is stil not with the program of putting vulnerable users first.

  • Exactly

  • Larry Littlefield

    You know what I’d like to see? Two long-term line charts, back to the 1960s if possible, showing.

    NYC murder victims vs. people killed in traffic.

    NYC aggravated assault and rape victims vs. people severely injured in traffic.

    I wonder what it would show?


The de Blasio administration released its annual Vision Zero self-assessment this morning. Photo: Mayor's Office

Taking Stock of Vision Zero Three Years In

The de Blasio administration has reduced fatalities every year -- the first time in more than a decade the city has had a streak of three years with declining traffic deaths. But the pace of improvement leveled off in 2016, highlighting how much work remains to reach the Vision Zero target.

Vision Zero: Where Do We Go From Here?

John Petro is a policy analyst for New York City affairs and the co-author of “Vision Zero: How Safer Streets in New York City Can Save More Than 100 Lives a Year.” Mayor Bill de Blasio released his administration’s Vision Zero Action Plan earlier this week, following up on a high-profile campaign promise just six […]

Vision Zero Year One: An Early Assessment

New York’s transportation reform and traffic safety movement notched huge wins when mayoral candidate Bill de Blasio adopted Vision Zero as part of his platform in 2013, and again this year when the new mayor put the policy into action within days of taking office. Vision Zero created a policy rubric for the de Blasio […]