De Blasio Says He’s Fully Funding Vision Zero Priority Projects. He Isn’t.

Despite what Mayor de Blasio says, NYC is not funding street redesigns at the rate prescribed by Vision Zero.
Despite what Mayor de Blasio says, NYC is not funding street redesigns at the rate prescribed by Vision Zero. Image: Transportation Alternatives

On his weekly Brian Lehrer show appearance this morning, Mayor de Blasio said the city is fully funding Vision Zero street redesigns. The numbers tell a different story.

During the Q&A segment, Families for Safe Streets member Mary Beth Kelly told de Blasio 204 people walking and biking have been killed by drivers on Vision Zero priority corridors since January 2015, and that only a fourth of those corridors have received redesign treatments. Kelly asked the mayor to commit to speeding up funding for Vision Zero priority projects.

Here is de Blasio’s response in full:

I appreciate the question very much and I appreciate the work that you do and your colleagues do because it’s been decisive to Vision Zero, particularly in terms of the fights you’ve waged in Albany to get us things like the speed cameras around schools. And we want to do even more of that, and I’m very hopeful there is a Democratic Senate. There’ll be a willingness to go farther with us in protecting kids and seniors and implementing Vision Zero.

We are very aggressively moving those safety redesign efforts. There’s no lack of funding, and there’s no lack of will. And you know Queens Boulevard is a huge example of this, a place we used call the ‘Boulevard of Death’ and thank god we have not fatalities the last two years because we’re doing redesign, because of bike lanes, because of the reduction in speed limit, because we’re enforcing the speed limit with the NYPD. So we’re very, very adamant about moving these as quickly as possible. I’ll talk to Commissioner Trottenberg to see if there’s anything else that she needs to continue to speed things up, but she’s gotten the order from me to do everything as quickly as humanly possible.

We will also be doing more enforcement. The NYPD is continuing to ratchet up enforcement on speeding and on failure to yield, and you’re going to see more checkpoints as well to inhibit drunk driving. So there’s a lot of Vision Zero pieces that are going to be growing, and the redesigns are absolutely a priority.

Budget figures don’t back up the mayor’s claims. As Streetsblog has reported, last spring Transportation Alternatives found that at the current rate of funding it will take almost 40 years to redesign the priority corridors identified in the DOT’s pedestrian safety action plans — a timetable that stretches decades beyond the Vision Zero goal of eliminating traffic deaths by 2024.

After TA released its analysis and called on officials to act, the City Council recommended increasing the DOT budget for quick-to-implement “operational” projects by about 25 percent. The council also proposed $250 million in annual capital funding for redesign projects. De Blasio declined to follow the council’s recommendations.

Yesterday Families for Safe Streets and TA rallied on the steps of City Hall to urge de Blasio to ramp up street safety funding, after two children were killed last week by reckless drivers in Queens. The mayor says he’s doing everything he can, but his budget says otherwise.

  • mfs

    Is it this mechanical- that street designs that cost x amount of $ lead to x # of deaths reduced? I love me some redesigned streets, but there is a culture of unsafe driving that no amount of engineering can end.

  • Jason

    Street design is the easiest way to get people to drive safer. Look at Manhattan and observe the difference between how people drive on the one-way crosstown streets (which are typically two parking lanes and one travel lane) and how they drive on the avenues and wider multi-lane two-way crosstown streets (86th, etc).

  • AnoNYC

    Reconfiguring streets forces a cultural change in the way people drive.

  • JudenChino

    Fixing street design is the way to go. Just think of the avenues in Manhattan. They’re freaking designed like highways. I, at night, when driving, honestly feel comfortable going at or around 40+ mph.

    Just putting up some signs that say, “25 mph speed limit,” won’t change the driving culture or behavior at all. But designing the road, such that, it’s narrower, has more physical obstacles (tree, boulevard medians, other physical barriers) that signals to the driver, that you’re not on a 5 lane highway, but you’re driving through a residential neighborhood.

    Especially thinking of Manhattan avenues, having curb extensions on every intersection and other physical barriers such that cars cannot take turns at high speeds, would for sure eliminate traffic deaths including a few recent ones involving seniors in crosswalks.

    We know driving culture can be very unsafe and having roads designed like highways in dense urban residential environments is a recipe for deaths.

  • Jesse

    ” I’ll talk to Commissioner Trottenberg to see if there’s anything else that she needs to continue to speed things up, but she’s gotten the order from me to do everything as quickly as humanly possible.”

    Sounds like de Blasio has given Trottenberg the order to not capitulate to NIMBY community boards. That should be all the political cover she needs. They should be held to this.

  • Joe R.

    Giving motorists more information is important, also. When you redesign the avenues for slower speeds you should retime the lights for those speeds AND make that information readily available to drivers. Have numerical displays which show the speed you need to drive at to make the next light. When drivers see they can go 22 mph and still safely make the next light the urgency to mindlessly gun it will eventually disappear. I personally find it amazing motorists aren’t more in tune with light timing on streets they use every day but maybe that’s something only cyclists tend to keep tabs on. If you post the information right there motorists might finally figure it out.

  • JamesR

    I want to believe that design is destiny, I really do. But when I see motorists blast down tiny, narrow NW Bronx local streets at 40mph and fly over the shallow speedbumps installed on the street a few years back, I’m skeptical that we can design our way out of a toxic, unaccountable road culture.

  • Vooch
  • AnoNYC

    They won’t be driving for long hitting speed humps at that speed. Damage to the suspension, frame, wheels and tires. Likely to lose control.

    I once saw an Escalade lose its entire front bumper hitting a speed hump at an unreasonable speed (40ish?). Vehicle was immobilized as the bumper was crushed, dragged and jammed into the wheel well/fender.

  • AnoNYC

    And check out this setup:

  • c2check

    I would love to see some chicanes, traffic diverters, neighborhood traffic circles etc.
    NYC DOT removed the Slow Zone signs from the roadway because people kept hitting them. Make them heavier.

    Add traffic calming that you have to actively avoid.
    Folks would learn to drive slow and pay attention pretty fast.

  • J

    What’s his motivation here? Why reject the safety money? I just don’t get it. Does anyone have insider info on this?

  • JudenChino

    Right! I really don’t understand the politics of it at all! He’s a coward so he defers and delegates to the NYPD and developers. Annoying but he’s a poor leader. But here, he has his own city council, asking for additional funds to finance one of his signature proposals. The amount of money requested is a rounding error but would provide for a lot of help. City Hall actually has a fair bit of cash. And he’s expanding the NYPD too! I just don’t get why he’d knee cap one of his [failing] signature policies.

  • Jeff

    That video was beautiful. Thank you.

  • Larry Littlefield

    My guess: DeBlasio fears a situation where he is blamed for being a spendthrift who bankrupted the city. He wants to hold the line on spending here and there, so when the tax revenue stops gushing in people won’t blame him for the shitstorm.

    And it may be coming. He cut contracts with the unions that defer the big pay raises until after he is re-elected. But the pirates of Wall Street are finding out what happens to top predators when the bottom of the food chain is killed off due to excess predation, and the growth of tax revenues has stopped. Meanwhile, the financial asset bubble caused by zero interest rates has plateaued — and it sucked all the future gains out of the pension funds.

    As for the NYPD, that was idiotic but imposed on him. He decided not to to play the stupid game where he proposes fake cuts to the parks and libraries and the Council restores them. So the Council demanded 1,000 more cops instead.


TA: Quicker Action on Vision Zero Can Save Thousands of Lives

The de Blasio administration is making progress on street safety, but not fast enough to achieve the mayor’s Vision Zero target of eliminating traffic deaths by 2024, Transportation Alternatives says in a new report. At the current rate of improvement, it will take nearly 40 years to reach that goal. Advocates from TA, Families for Safe Streets, […]

Advocates Ask City Council to Fully Fund Vision Zero Street Improvements

If the city hopes to dramatically decrease the number of traffic fatalities in New York City, DOT needs more resources to redesign the city’s most dangerous corridors and intersections. That’s the message 70 members of Transportation Alternatives brought to the City Council yesterday, meeting with 21 council members or their staff. “We are calling on the council to increase funding and watchdog […]

De Blasio: Street Safety Advocates Not “Looking at the Facts”

On Monday Mayor Bill de Blasio managed to dismiss very real concerns about Vision Zero progress and the work street safety advocates are doing to stem the bloodshed and grief caused by traffic violence, all in one sentence. When Politico reporter Laura Nahmias asked about New Yorkers who are holding him to his own administration’s Vision Zero goals, de Blasio […]

De Blasio’s Budget Has No Funding Increase for Street Safety Projects

Mayor de Blasio released his executive budget yesterday, and it does not include the increases for street safety projects that the City Council recommended earlier this month, says Transportation Alternatives. Without more funding for street redesigns, TA says, the administration won’t be able to improve safety at the pace needed to attain the mayor’s stated goal of eliminating traffic […]

TA: City Hall’s Spending Decisions Are Limiting Life-Saving Street Designs

Transportation Alternatives says the de Blasio administration’s failure to fully fund Vision Zero street improvements is limiting the number of split-phase traffic signals DOT can install to prevent collisions at dangerous intersections. In June, 30-year-old cyclist Olga Cook was killed by an allegedly drunk driver who made a right turn across the Hudson River Greenway at Chambers Street, one […]