The 2016 NYC Streetsies, Part 1

Photo: David Meyer
Photo: David Meyer

Thanks for voting and welcome to the first slate of NYC Streetsies. This batch is all about the tangible wins of 2016 — major street redesigns, bus improvements, and other good stuff. More Streetsies will follow throughout the week. Enjoy!

Best Pedestrian Project

Photo: David Meyer

The six-legged intersection of Myrtle, Wyckoff, and Gates, straddling Bushwick and Ridgewood on the Brooklyn/Queens border, has been the site of profound loss. Ella Bandes, 23, was struck and killed by a turning bus driver while crossing the street here in 2013, and the following year, Edgar Torres, 40, lost his life in a very similar collision.

By converting one block into the car-free Myrtle-Wyckoff Plaza, DOT greatly simplified the complex vehicle movements at the intersection. The project exemplifies DOT at its resourceful best in the Vision Zero era — bold thinking applied to a dangerous location, reducing the risk to people on foot while creating a neighborhood gathering place and delivering more convenient access to two subway lines and six bus routes.

It’s also a testament to the strong activism of Ella Bandes’s parents, Judy Kottick and Ken Bandes, and the unflinching political support of Council Member Antonio Reynoso, without whom the project would not have happened.

Best Bicycle Project

Photo: David Meyer

A few of the projects vying for this Streetsie are so good they probably could have taken top honors in a typical year. But the competition in 2016 was especially fierce. The winner of the people’s choice vote was the Chrystie Street protected bike lane, and there are a couple of things that set it apart.

First is the centrality of Chrystie Street in the city’s bike network. Thousands of people ride on Chrystie every day because for many trips between Brooklyn and Manhattan, you just can’t avoid it. Second is the quality of the design — there’s no comparison between the old obstacle course bike lane, constantly blocked by illegally parked cars, vans, and buses, and the protected right of way.

This project is going to change cycling in NYC by making an essential piece of the bike network much less stressful. As a bonus, it may also put a stop to those ridiculous 5th Precinct bike stings.

Many thanks to Dave “Paco” Abraham for leading the way and putting this concept in front of Community Board 3 last year.

Best Bus Project

Boarding moves a lot faster when you don't have to wait for everyone to dip a MetroCard. Photo: David Meyer
Boarding moves a lot faster when you don’t have to wait for everyone to dip a MetroCard. Photo: David Meyer

What the Chrystie Street redesign was for cycling this year, B46 Select Bus Service on Utica Avenue was for bus riding — the project that did the most good for the greatest number of people.

The B46 serves some of the densest neighborhoods in the city that lack good subway access. Passengers make more than 44,000 trips on the B46 each weekday, making it the busiest bus route in Brooklyn. Routes with so many riders are the ones where off-board fare collection makes the biggest difference, and this was the year that pre-paid boarding came to the B46. Instead of waiting for everyone to dip a MetroCard at the front of the bus, everyone can board with a receipt at any door.

Best Precedent

How rare is it for the city to claim a lane of car traffic on a major bridge and repurpose it for biking and walking? The opening of the Pulaski Bridge bikeway this spring marked the first time in 16 years that New York had taken a lane for active transportation on a span so large.

What used to be a lane of speeding traffic next to a crowded, stressful shared path for walking and biking is now a generous two-way bikeway linking Brooklyn and Queens. New Yorkers should get similar improvements on the Queensboro Bridge, Brooklyn Bridge, and several bridges over the Harlem River without having to wait another 16 years.

Hardest-Won Victory

It took almost a decade of activism and too many community board meetings to count, but the Amsterdam Avenue protected bike lane was worth the wait. The fight to extend the protected lane further along Amsterdam hopefully won’t drag out so long.

Most Frustrating Policy Win

There’s a sizable parking-obsessed contingent on the City Council that won’t stand for the elimination of off-street parking mandates, but the de Blasio administration still managed to get rid of parking requirements for subsidized housing in much of the city. Problem is, the mayor is counting on neighborhood-level rezonings all over the city to deliver subsidized housing, and so far, few council members have shown much willingness to support these changes in their districts.

Most Common-Sense Legislating

Until this year, walking across the street while time remained on a flashing countdown signal was no guarantee that you had the right of way under New York City law. (It all depended on whether you had a white “Walk” signal when you stepped off the curb — if you didn’t, the law didn’t protect you.) Local Law 115, introduced by Public Advocate Letitia James and signed by Mayor de Blasio in September, changed that. Now people in the crosswalk have the legal right of way as long as the signal is not a steady red hand. Like they always should have.

Best Report

Second runner-up: DOT’s Mobility Report, a refresh of the agency’s annual progress reports initiated under PlaNYC, put MTA BusTime data to spectacular use, creating a citywide map that pinpoints street segments where steps need to be taken to speed up NYC buses.

First runner-up: The Transform Don’t Trash coalition’s “Clearing the Air” report laid out the public health and safety risks of New York’s commercial waste carting industry and made a compelling case for tangible reforms.

The best: TransitCenter’s Bus Turnaround report takes top honors. The report shed light on an urgent but overlooked problem — the decline of NYC bus ridership by 16 percent since 2002, and the factors behind slow, unreliable service that leads people to abandon the bus — while laying out a policy agenda that will guide efforts to improve bus service for years to come.

There’s also a great Streetfilm that goes with it:

Favorite Streetfilm

Want an inside look at the project that won Streetsblog’s best street transformation award in 2015? Let DOT’s Ryan Russo walk you through the problem-solving thought process in “The Transformation of Queens Boulevard, Block By Block”:

  • vnm

    “The opening of the Pulaski Bridge bikeway this spring marked the first time in 16 years that New York had taken a lane for active transportation on a span so large.” Does anyone know/remember what the one from 16 years ago was? I’m having trouble even hazarding a guess.

  • Queensboro Bridge North Outer Roadway was not a permanent bike/ped path until 2000. The city started converting it to non-motorized use in the late 70s but there was a 22-year fight to make it car-free 24/7.

  • You could also say it’s been 38 years since the city did something like this. 1978 is when advocates first won a Queensboro walk/bike lane. But it was an incomplete victory. Here’s a partial timeline from TA:

  • During the 1980s, cyclists were instructed to use the south roadway at some times, and to stuff it other times — there was a sign that told cyclists to use the subway during certain hours.

    The first time I tried to cross the Queensboro Bridge, as a 15-year-old during the summer of 1981, I was nearly killed. My friend and I saw that the south (Queens-bound) roadway appeared open to bikes, but we checked with a cop to be sure. He told us to go ahead. Yet, when we were halfway across, we were greeted by cars coming the other way! The roadway had been opened to cars from the other side! We tried to make ourselves as thin as possible, and we just continued until we landed in Manhattan. So I look at what we have now as luxurious.

    Indeed, whenever I ride up Queens Boulevard (with the detour to Skillman Avenue) and over the bridge and then on to First Avenue or Second Avenue, on bike lanes the whole way, I marvel at having seen that stretch go from jungle to bike wonderland in my lifetime. It is pleasant to have the realisation that we are currently living in a golden era.

  • vnm

    Thanks for the info Ben!

  • DisqusNYC

    Re: Best Pedestrian Project

    I was wondering if any politician, city council member, community board member, DOT commissioner, borough president, plaza advocate, or MTA official could let us know what the six bus stops are and where they are in relation to the award-winning plaza project?

    What is the source of your information and is it publicly available?

    In addition to police cars frequently parked alongside the plaza on Myrtle Avenue I recently saw an unmarked vehicle doing the same thing. The driver’s seat was empty. Did they go to CVS, KFC, or some other store? Passing vehicles must go around the parked vehicle thereby creating an unsafe condition.

    See more at:

  • DisqusNYC

    I just returned to the litter-strewn plaza area. An MTA truck was unloading many light bulbs on one side of Myrtle Avenue. Directly opposite the MTA truck was an unmarked vehicle probably waiting for KFC to open. This left enough room for one vehicle to pass. Vehicles from both directions were riding directly on top of the double-yellow line. Way to go DeBlasio. After the very public shellacking that RPOCA took from the organization behind the Fresh Pond Road street fair, it is no wonder they, and hence CB5 did not have the wherewithal to oppose the NYC DOT’s foolishness. I seem to recall that there was supposed to be a dedicated unloading area near the plaza. How is someone to know where it is if the MTA doesn’t know where it is?

  • DisqusNYC

    I just returned to the plaza area. Vehicles were riding on top of the double yellow lines on Myrtle Avenue as usual. If the double line law cannot be enforced, why not make it a single line?

    The next thing I saw was a large truck barreling down the one-way section of Wyckoff Avenue in the wrong direction and racing through the intersection to make the left turn on to Myrtle Avenue. It was moving very fast. I think it was a municipal bucket truck with a round green logo on the cab’s door.

    I also noticed a bus making a left turn on to Wyckoff Avenue from Palmetto Street. If this is a legal turn, why isn’t the B26 final stop located within the Ridgewood Intermodal Terminal proper as suggested in an earlier post?

    All this was observed in less than ten minutes.

    The mayor can throw all the money in world at Vision Zero projects, but if his agencies do not have the vision to see the things I’ve posted all is lost and wasted.

  • DisqusNYC

    The hypocritical CB5 is still at it in 2017:

    CB5 denies permit for Fresh Pond Street Fest…again

    CB 5 turns down Fresh Pond festival


Antonio Reynoso: DOT Should Forge Ahead With Myrtle-Wyckoff Plaza

Council Member Antonio Reynoso wants DOT to move forward with its safety plan at the busy Myrtle-Wyckoff transit hub, with or without the endorsement of the local community board. Last Wednesday, Brooklyn Community 4 voted against DOT’s plan, which would dramatically reduce potential conflicts between drivers and pedestrians and create a car-free plaza on one block of Wyckoff Avenue between Myrtle and […]

This Week: Plaza for a Day at Myrtle-Wyckoff

DOT is looking to simplify the intersection of Myrtle Avenue, Wyckoff Avenue, and Palmetto Street. On the border of Brooklyn and Queens, this crossing is a hub for subway and bus commuters, and its poor design has contributed to the deaths of three pedestrians since 2009. As Streetsblog recently reported, the heart of the DOT plan — […]

A Car-Free Plaza Is the Key to DOT’s Safety Plan for Myrtle-Wyckoff

The dangerous intersection of Myrtle Avenue and Wyckoff Avenue at the Bushwick-Ridgewood border is in line for a major DOT redesign this year. The proposal calls for pedestrianizing the block of Wyckoff between Myrtle and Gates to reduce potential motor vehicle turns at the intersection by 70 percent. Myrtle-Wyckoff is a major transit hub, where the elevated M […]

Myrtle-Wyckoff Plaza Gets Near-Unanimous Approval From Queens CB 5

With 29 votes in favor, none against, and one abstention, Queens Community Board 5 overwhelmingly endorsed DOT’s safety plan for the Myrtle-Wyckoff transit hub last night. The project would significantly reduce potential conflicts between turning drivers and pedestrians, mainly by creating a car-free plaza on Wyckoff Avenue between Gates and Myrtle [PDF]. Pedestrians outnumber motorists at the six-legged Myrtle-Wyckoff […]