Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
NYPD

Source: NYPD Lets Civilians Conduct Traffic Control for Hanukkah Parade

We never did get a response from NYPD about the motorized Lubavitcher Hanukkah parade where civilians with lights and sirens on their SUVs made a mess of traffic control on Sixth Avenue. But a source affiliated with the Crown Heights Jewish Community Council filled in the blanks, saying the parade is authorized by NYPD. The source asked to remain anonymous to preserve his relationship with police. While NYPD has not responded to our request to confirm this information, the source was clearly familiar with details of the parade, his account was internally consistent, and he had no discernible motive to mislead.

The parade consists of about 200 motor vehicles (including at least one RV called a "mitzvah tank" bearing the likeness of Rabbi Menachem Schneerson) and follows a route that begins in Crown Heights and ends at Sixth Avenue and 59th Street, where participants disperse to distribute menorahs, he said.

Accompanying the parade are three NYPD highway patrol cars and about 10 to 15 vehicles with Crown Heights Shmira, according to the source. Shmira is affiliated with the 71st Precinct through NYPD's Civilian Observation Patrol program, which the department says consists of "volunteers" who "patrol their own neighborhoods and report suspicious and criminal activity that require Police attention."

The training for the COP program includes how to block streets, the source said, and the Shmira members are authorized by NYPD to perform traffic control during this parade (and only during this parade). The black traffic control SUVs in the video belong to Shmira members, who are authorized by NYPD to have lights and sirens, according to the source. Other than the parade, he said, the lights and sirens are only supposed to be used when responding to "a real emergency call."

h/t Bucky Turco for the initial tip and video

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Agenda 2026: Will Zohran Mamdani’s Left-Progressive Backers Mobilize for Faster Buses?

The new mayor must mobilize the coalition that got him elected if he wants to avoid his recent predecessors' failure to speed up buses.

December 1, 2025

‘Easy Win’: Uptowners Want To Keep Deteriorating Henry Hudson Parkway Off-Ramp Car-Free

The shuttered off-ramp off the Henry Hudson Parkway has become a draw for local residents.

December 1, 2025

Memo to Mamdani: When It Comes to Faster Buses, The Challenge Is Political

The solutions for faster bus service are obvious — it’s the politics that always get in the way, writes a former MTA bus official.

December 1, 2025

Monday’s Headlines: Canal Street This Time Edition

More violent battles in public space. Plus other news.

December 1, 2025

Not So Fast! We Rode NYC Ferry with Would-Be Council Speaker Amanda Farías

Council Member Julie Menin claims she has the votes to be the next Speaker, but Bronx Council Member Amanda Farías has shown a lot more interest in livable streets issues.

November 28, 2025

Book Excerpt Special: Jonathan Lethem’s ‘Program’s Progress’

Class struggle. Infirm secondary superheroes. Suicidal sheep. It’s all in Jonathan Lethem's new collection of short stories, "A Different Kind of Tension." Here's one — featuring class struggle with cars!

November 28, 2025
See all posts