Is “Sprawl Repair” Worth It?
Transforming the territory of strip malls and big boxes into walkable places is a hot topic, exemplified by the popular book “Retrofitting Suburbia.” But is it worth the time, money, and effort?
Robert Steuteville of Better! Cities & Towns writes that architect Kevin Klinkenberg and development expert Lee Sobel raised the question at this year’s Congress for the New Urbanism.
Klinkenberg explained in a blog that sprawl repair is a "fools errand" and new urbanists should "just say no." He said: "Suburbia, or sprawl as we interchangeably call it, is all about bigness and mass production." Put simply, "it's outside the DNA of walkable cities. Embracing sprawl retrofit is like saying we can transform fast food culture into healthy food."
He's saying that sprawl repair is the Chicken McNuggets of urbanism.
Klinkenberg concludes: "I do believe that sprawl retrofit is not a wise approach for new urbanists. I'd say, let's keep it simple — let urbanism be urbanism and sprawl be sprawl."
Steuteville disagrees. There will always be a market for sprawl, he writes, but as preferences change, it's becoming obvious that drivable places consume a much greater share of the built environment -- 95 percent -- than people actually want.
He points out that some cities, like Atlanta and Los Angeles, have few options other than retrofitting their car-centric development patterns:
Repairing the suburban fabric -- incrementally, through proper channels and Democratic means -- is necessary and can't be avoided.
Granted, you can't transform a fading commercial strip lined with single-use buildings and parking lots into a walker's paradise immediately. The outcome may not equal historic Charleston, but turning a lousy place into a decent one improves people's lives. The next generation can make a decent place great.
Elsewhere on the Network today: BikePortland breaks down an audit of local traffic safety cameras, Baltimore Spokes links to a study on how better police reports on bike crashes could save lives, and Greater Greater Washington says DC isn’t meeting its housing goals.
Stay in touch
Sign up for our free newsletter
More from Streetsblog New York City
Dynamic! MTA Could Hike Congestion Pricing Toll 25% on Gridlock Alert Days
The MTA said it had that power, and modeled it in its environmental assessment (see footnote 2 below), but no one ever reported it, until Wednesday.
Judge Orders Trial for Hit-and-Run Driver Who Turned Down ‘Reasonable’ Sentencing Offer
Judge Brendan Lantry turns down driver's request for mere probation for killing a delivery worker in 2022. The trial will start in January.
Wednesday’s Headlines: Another Big Day at City Hall Edition
Today is going to be another busy day for the livable streets crowd. So get ready with today's headlines.
Reporter’s Notebook: Will Eric Adams Ever Publicly Embrace Congestion Pricing?
The governor, the head of the MTA and the city's leading transit thinkers all celebrated congestion pricing on Tuesday as an historic moment while Mayor Adams spent Tuesday failing to live up to it.
Eyes on the Street: ‘Daylighting’ NYC Intersections Needs More Than Paint and Signs
We're gonna need more than paint and signs.
