Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Street Safety

Ignoring Its Own Research, AAA Tells NYC Drivers Speeding Is No Big Deal

The American Automobile Association, often perceived as simply a non-profit that runs a friendly towing service, has lost what little credibility it had on street safety issues.

Ted Mann's story in today's Wall Street Journal about mayoral candidates addressing street safety has a few quotes from the local AAA chapter's spokesperson:

Critics of some of those efforts, such as Robert Sinclair of the AAA, continue to be skeptical. The city is "plagued by bad engineering" that makes roads more dangerous, he said, and is at the mercy of trucks that supply the city's stores. But he said bike lanes had been added "higgledy-piggledy" without regard to demand, and efforts to cut down on driver speed ignore reality.

"On some roadways in our area, the speed limit is artificially low," he said. "Everyone's not driving 30 miles an hour. If you did, the city might grind to a halt."

Besides failing to employ basic logic -- 30 mph, a speed limit that's already higher than the rule in many other American cities, is by definition not grinding to a halt -- Sinclair is doubling down on his organization's pro-speeding position. "Everybody’s driving above 30. That’s the reality," he told Streetsblog last year.

The AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety's own research [PDF] has run the numbers and reached a very different conclusion:

There is a general understanding that a pedestrian’s risk of injury or death increases as crash impact speed increases... To reduce the number of pedestrians seriously injured and killed in crashes with motor vehicles, it is necessary to reduce the risk of crashes occurring, the risk of severe or fatal outcomes in crashes, or both. In places such as residential streets and urban areas designed to allow pedestrians and vehicles to be in close proximity to one another, examples of measures to reduce vehicle speeds include traffic calming techniques such as speed bumps, lane narrowing, and changes in roadway curvature, as well as increased enforcement or reduction of speed limits.

Despite its foundation's recommendations, AAA New York has long been an opponent of speed cameras, testifying against them at the City Council and regularly stumping against automated enforcement in the press. The group's even used a flawed "ad-hoc survey" of eight cameras to attack the city's red light enforcement program.

Behind the organization's feel-good video reminding drivers that cyclists are people too, AAA regularly supports reckless policies that put all road users in danger. If arguing for unchecked speeding and unsafe road designs weren't enough, AAA has also sought to remove cycling and pedestrian programs from funds generated by the gas tax. Any elected official standing with AAA should be laughed out of the room if they claim to support safe streets.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

‘Goddamn Outrageous’: MTA Boss Blames Amtrak For Delaying ‘Penn Access’ Expansion

Janno Lieber lit into Amtrak for delays to Metro-North's Penn Station Access project: "The people in Co-op City are waiting for a goddamn train!"

October 7, 2025

Brooklyn Still Choked by Placard Elite Leaving Their Cars Everywhere With No Consequences

Drivers park illegally — often with city-issued placards — and virtually none ever gets ticketed by cops.

October 7, 2025

Tuesday’s Headlines: Rock and Roll Never Forgets Edition

Why was our house band, Jimmy and the Jaywalkers, snubbed from the journalists' "battle of the bands" on Wednesday night? Plus other news.

October 7, 2025

Likely Mayor Mamdani Supports Daylighting as DOT Digs In Heels

The next mayor will have to overcome a deeply entrenched bureaucracy opposed to the common-sense policy.

October 6, 2025

Under Pressure: Uber’s Navigation System Endangers the Public With Reckless Driving Directions

An Uber driver made an illegal u-turn and hit someone, but the in-app navigation told him to do it and the company won't give up the code.

October 6, 2025

Monday’s Headlines: Trump Games Continue Edition

Trump restored some security grant for New York, but billions of dollars in grants remain on ice. Plus more news.

October 6, 2025
See all posts