De Blasio Gives NYPD an “F” on Transparency

Image: Office of Public Advocate Bill de Blasio

Public Advocate Bill de Blasio has given NYPD an “F” for its record of withholding information from the public.

De Blasio’s “Transparency Report Card” rates city agencies’ response to freedom of information requests [PDF]. Looking at 10,000 FOIL requests over a three-month period in 2011, the report awards grades to 18 agencies “based on timeliness of response, requests left unanswered, and the ease of filing a request.” The report includes a history of the New York State Freedom of Information Law, and outlines what information city agencies are obliged to provide to the public, and how they should do it.

The report found that NYPD had the highest number of unanswered FOIL requests; that 31 percent of requests never received a response; and that 28 percent of answered requests took more than 60 days to process. The report noted that NYPD provides a mailing address for FOILs, but “no clear way to follow-up or appeal after a request.”

The report’s findings jibe with the experiences of Streetsblog and others who have filed FOIL requests to obtain information on fatal traffic crashes. It takes a tremendous amount of persistence, if not legal action, to wrest the barest details from NYPD, even if the petitioner is related to the victim.

“When an agency fails to respond within the stipulated timeframe, such failure constitutes a denial,” the report reads. “In these circumstances, an agency can be forced to comply through legal action — an option beyond the capacity of many petitioners.”

The report recommends a number of improvements to the FOIL process, including more oversight by the city, the publishing of more information online, establishing a centralized venue for filing requests, and assessing fines to city agencies for non-compliance. Such fines have resulted in greater compliance rates in Washington State and Illinois, the report says.

“The City is inviting waste and corruption by blocking information that belongs to the public,” said de Blasio in a press release that accompanied the report. “We have to start holding government accountable when it refuses to turn over public records to citizens and taxpayers.”

Other than NYPD, the Housing Authority was the only agency to receive a failing grade.

Of the three agencies that received more than 1,000 requests during the study period — DOT, NYPD, and the Department of Environmental Protection — DOT was the only one to receive an overall “A” rating. The report found that 99 percent of all requests received a response, and that 90 percent of responses were provided in less than 60 days.

  • This sums up the two problems that we are the most anxious about in the next mayoral term: the irresponsibility of the NYPD, and the misinformation provided by NIMBYs that the DOT is not responsive or is dishonest when asked to address community concerns (and thus shouldn’t be allowed to modify streets against the wishes of obstructionists). Putting aside concerns about the MTA, fixing those things would go a long way in meeting many of our transpo goals.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

NYPD Is Still Shielding NYPD Crash Data From the Public

|
It’s been almost six months since Streetsblog filed a freedom of information request for data on traffic crashes involving NYPD personnel. NYPD has not released the data, or given us a reason for not doing so. The 2016 Mayor’s Management Report, released this week, says crashes involving city-owned vehicles increased 10 percent from FY 15 to FY 16 — […]

Streetsblog FOILs NYPD for Data on Crashes Involving Police

|
Streetsblog has filed a freedom of information request for NYPD data on traffic crashes involving NYPD personnel. NYPD doesn’t tell the public — or other city agencies — how many crashes police officers and other department staff get into, or what the costs are in terms of injuries, deaths, and property damage. When the Department of […]

Help Uncover the Truth About Traffic Violence

|
Want to channel your anger over pedestrian and cyclist crashes into productive action? Livable Streets member BicyclesOnly has a plan for you. The police report revealed that the driver who killed cyclist Rasha Shamoon in 2008 had six prior convictions, and that NYPD interviewed only him and his passengers. BicyclesOnly has launched a working group […]
A motorist, in the white SUV at right, waits to make the same turn taken by the driver who killed Jenna Daniels. Image: Google Maps

NYPD Ignores Streetsblog FOIL for Crash Report on Death of 15-Year-Old Jenna Daniels

|
NYPD has not responded to a Streetsblog freedom of information request for files related to a crash that killed a teenage jogger in Staten Island. Jenna Daniels, 15, was struck on the afternoon of November 15, 2014, by the driver of a pickup truck making a left turn from Hylan Boulevard onto Bayview Avenue in Prince’s Bay. NYPD never revealed the identity of the driver, and would not disclose how he was penalized for failing to exercise due care.

Witness: Crash That Killed Marlene Baharlias Likely Caught on Video

|
A man who says he saw the Tuesday crash that killed Marlene Baharlias echoes the story told by others: The driver backed into the senior on a Sheepshead Bay sidewalk. The witness believes a security camera in his building recorded the crash, but NYPD does not share details of crash investigations unless compelled by freedom of information requests. […]