Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Public Health

What Should the Surgeon General Say to Get More People Walking?

What if cars came with a Surgeon General’s warning like the ones that come on cigarette packs: "Sitting in this seat could lead to obesity, diabetes, heart disease, depression, and divorce."

false

Surgeon General Regina Benjamin is getting ready to go halfway there. She announced in December that she’d be issuing a call to action on walking sometime in 2014. Yesterday, she and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention asked for help crafting the call.

The CDC opened a docket yesterday to solicit information from the public “on walking as an effective way to be sufficiently active for health.” That information will be used as part of the call to action.

The wording is notable. The CDC is making the case that even if walking is the only exercise you do, it could be “sufficient” to stay healthy.  It echoes the recent findings of Australian researchers, who concluded that going to the gym isn’t as effective as active transportation at keeping weight off – largely because it’s easier to work exercise into your day when it accomplishes two goals at once.

What the CDC is trying to do is identify not only what government agencies can do, but what civic organizations, health care providers, educational institutions, worksites, industry, and others can do to provide access to "safe, attractive and convenient places to walk (and wheelchair roll)."

The CDC is off to a good start even before the public chimes in with its collective wisdom. The request for public comment laid out the scope of the problem:

Less than half (48 percent) of all U.S. adults meet the 2008 Physical Activity Guidelines… and less than 3 in 10 high school students get at least 60 minutes of physical activity every day. Only 13 percent of children walk or bike to school, compared with 44 percent a generation ago. More than a quarter of trips made by car are within one mile of home.

The CDC also highlights population groups with lower activity levels:

Physical activity levels decline with age; activity levels are lower in low-income communities and among racial/ ethnic minorities; and, in general, persons with disabilities are less active than those without disabilities.

The agency acknowledges that it’s not just an exercise promotion campaign – it’s about changing the built environment:

Causes for lower physical activity levels vary but may in part be due to a lack of available and/or accessible places for safe and enjoyable physical activity.

And the request for information calls attention to walking as a form of transportation, not just exercise:

Walking can be an enjoyable recreational, occupational or purposeful (e.g., for transportation) physical activity in which many Americans can engage. It can enhance health and quality of life and can also serve as a gateway to other enjoyable types of physical activity.

Having laid out the problem, the CDC is looking for help on the solution. They're requesting information from the public on “evidence-based strategies” for breaking down barriers to walking and “community walkability” for people of all ages who don't get enough exercise. They're especially interested in helping people with developmental and chronic disease-related disabilities to be more active, and also "groups having health and physical activity disparities or lack resources and opportunities to be physically active" -- racial and ethnic minorities and low-income communities.

You have until Tuesday, April 30 to submit a comment. If you do, please copy it into the comment section here as well -- we'd also like to hear new ideas for solving this persistent problem.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Street Safety Foe Paladino Joins the War on Cars After Queens Hot Wheels Mob Turns Violent

The longtime critic of street safety measures demanded action — but her proposed solution, speed bumps, wouldn't make much of a difference.

November 24, 2025

Republican Signs On To Super Speeder Bill, After Defending Reckless Driving

A Brooklyn politican who defended speeding at a funeral for victims of traffic violence now supports preventive legislation.

November 24, 2025

Money for Something: Uber is Driving The Race for City Council Speaker

What does Uber expect to receive in return for $250,000 in donations to two Council Speaker candidates?

November 24, 2025

‘The Permanence Agenda’: Paint and Plastic Won’t Deliver Real Street Safety

DOT’s quick-build approach to redesigning streets with paint and other temporary materials has worked well enough — but Mayor-elect Mamdani should aim for permanence.

November 24, 2025

Monday’s Headlines: Cartoon Bromance Edition

The president and the mayor were all smiles, but lots of Streetsbloggy topics were discussed in the Oval, as it turns out. Plus other news.

November 24, 2025

NIMBY-Mania: Middle Village Has a Love-Hate Relationship with the IBX

The idea of making it easier to reach Middle Village clearly put some Middle Villagers on edge.

November 23, 2025
See all posts