City Council Jacks Riverside Center Parking Supply Back Up to 1,500 Spaces

One of two levels of parking underneath the Riverside Center project, which will now total 1,500 spaces. Image: Extell Development.
One of two levels of parking underneath the Riverside Center project, which will now total 1,500 spaces. Image: Extell Development.

Council Member Gale Brewer has struck a deal on the Riverside Center mega-development, sending the 2,500-apartment project through two City Council committees and on a track to final approval. The deal increases the number of parking spaces allowed at Riverside Center to 1,500, far more than the community board or even the City Planning Commission had approved.

With the ability to build 1,500 off-street spaces on the southern edge of the Upper West Side, Extell Development got more than 80 percent of the 1,800 spaces it originally asked for. The City Planning Commission okayed 1,260 spaces — after some fuzzy math added 430 extra spaces — but the Council deal bumped that number up again.

For comparison’s sake, the community board requested 1,000 parking spaces and borough president Scott Stringer called for 1,100 spaces. If Riverside Center were simply built with the same ratio of parking as its successful neighbors, it would only need 550 spaces.

What’s more, while the City Planning Commission required Extell to move a proposed auto showroom to a location where it wouldn’t harm the pedestrian environment as much, the City Council undid that requirement as well, according to environmental planner Dan Gutman. On parking and the showroom, Extell “seems to have recouped what the planning commission took away,” said Gutman.

That isn’t to say that the deal was all bad for the community. The urban design of the project has been consistently improved over months of debate and negotiation. For example, 90 percent of the project’s open space has been brought down to street level, according to a press release from Brewer’s office. That will make the area far more inviting to pedestrians than previous designs which put Riverside Center on an elevated platform, with blank walls facing many sidewalks.

The deal also has Extell putting more money towards a new public school than it had previously agreed to do and guaranteeing that at least some of the affordable housing they must build will be placed on site, both of which are high-priority for the community. The additional parking may have been allowed in order to compensate for those community benefits. After all, said Gutman, “Extell’s argument was always that we need the money. It wasn’t about whether there was a need for these spaces objectively.”

We have a call in with Brewer to find out more about why the Council upped the number of parking spaces in the project.

  • Blind Boy Grunt

    The only upside to this is that, as excessive as the parking appropriation is, it’s still 837 spaces less than the alleged capacity of the lots currently on the site. But when this thing gets built I count more than 4,000 parking spaces for the 7,000 total housing units in the Riverside South development as a whole. This is an obscene amount of parking in a district where the zoning maximum is supposed to be 0.35 spaces per dwelling unit. Even without the City Council’s gratuitous gift of additional parking, Extell stood to make bundles from this project. Their cries of poormouth have taken them directly to the bank, and thanks to their greed, community residents will be subjected to that much more pollution, noise and danger.

  • Who can do a calculation regarding (partial) negation of street improvements for pedestrians and cyclists by additions of private vehicle storage (on- or off-street)?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

City Planning Ready to Approve 1,260 Parking Spaces at Riverside Center

By Noah Kazis |
The City Planning Commission is likely to approve a 1,260-space garage for the Riverside Center mega-development at its meeting this Wednesday, according to multiple sources. That’s space for hundreds more cars — causing more congestion and more pollution — than requested by the Upper West Side’s representatives. It’s yet another case where the commission and […]

Stringer: 1,800 Parking Spots Too Many For Riverside Center; 1,100 Okay

By Noah Kazis |
Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer approved one block’s worth of underground parking for Riverside Center, but not two. Image: Extell Development Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer released his recommendations for the Riverside Center megaproject yesterday afternoon. Like Community Board 7, he doesn’t approve of Extell Development’s request to build more than 1,800 underground parking spaces […]

Manhattan CB 7 Demands 800 Fewer Parking Spaces at Riverside Center

By Noah Kazis |
Riverside Center won’t build a second parking deck if CB 7’s recommendations are adopted. Image: Extell Development Manhattan Community Board 7 approved its recommendations for the Riverside Center mega-project in a special meeting last night, laying out a long list of demands. Many of the modifications would make the development more walkable, whether by integrating […]

Major Test for Parking Reform Shaping Up on Manhattan’s West Side

By Ben Fried |
The site plan for Riverside Center includes a large ramp for motorists to access below-ground garages (bottom center). Image: Extell Development Are New York City’s planning commissioners serious about parking reform? An important test case is shaping up on Manhattan’s west side, where Extell Development is trying to build 1,800 parking spaces in an area […]

City Planning Okays 1,260 Parking Spaces for Riverside Center

By Noah Kazis |
We got our hands on a copy of the City Planning Commission’s report on the Riverside Center mega-development [PDF], and as we reported last week, the commission is allowing Extell Development to construct 1,260 parking spaces under two Upper West Side blocks. It’s possible that the number of parking spaces could drop lower when the […]