District Attorneys Can Start Enforcing Hayley and Diego’s Law Today

Diego Martinez and Hayley Ng were killed when a van left idling and unattended careened backwards into a group of pre-schoolers on a Chinatown sidewalk. The driver was not charged.

Hayley and Diego’s Law takes effect today, giving law enforcement a new tool to use against dangerous drivers. With this law, district attorneys throughout New York state can bring the charge of “careless driving” against motorists who irresponsibly injure pedestrians and cyclists.

In 2008 alone, traffic crashes killed 344 pedestrians and cyclists in New York state, and injured 20,739 more, according to the DMV. Even so, legal action stronger than handing out a traffic ticket is rarely taken, even in cases where one party is clearly at fault, like when a driver left his van idling unattended last year and the vehicle killed preschoolers Hayley Ng and Diego Martinez.

Before today, there was no middle ground between handing out moving violations and aggressive charges like criminally negligent homicide, which prosecutors say can be difficult prove. Hayley and Diego’s law creates a new option for law enforcement: charging motorists with the new crime of careless driving. Drivers who injure a pedestrian or cyclist “while failing to exercise due care” would be required to take drivers’ ed, and could be sentenced to fines of up to $750, jail time of up to 15 days, and a license suspension of up to six months.

Transportation Alternatives’ Noah Budnick said that T.A. has been in close contact with district attorneys and that most are ready to use the new law where appropriate. “Because this law came out of conversations we had with them about their previous inability to prosecute a lot of dangerous drivers,” said Budnick, “they are unfortunately intimately familiar with the use of the law.”

A spokesperson for Manhattan DA Cy Vance said that while the office doesn’t speak about hypothetical cases, “the stronger the tools we have, the more we can do with them.” Vance supported the law while it was working its way through the legislature.

Joseph McCormack, the chief of the Vehicular Crimes Bureau at the Bronx District Attorney’s office, laid out exactly why Hayley and Diego’s Law could be useful when it was signed into law. He told Streetsblog that in one recent horrific crash, which killed a person waiting at a bus stop and injured six more, a 2008 precedent meant he wouldn’t have been able to convict the motorist for criminal negligence. If Hayley and Diego’s law had been in effect, however, he said he would at least have been able to apply that law.

For Hayley and Diego’s Law to make pedestrians and cyclists safer, it’s essential that district attorneys and other law enforcement officials embrace it. The deterrent effect on dangerous driving will only take hold if the law is prosecuted consistently and visibly. In Oregon, where a similar law was first passed, spreading awareness of the law has been a challenge.

Budnick suggested that in New York, DAs would be able to successfully and quickly publicize Hayley and Diego’s Law to motorists. “The DAs are not afraid of press and they know how to use that as a bully pulpit,” he said.

The enactment of Hayley and Diego’s Law should help make drivers more careful behind the wheel, but other changes remain necessary to hold reckless drivers accountable. Advances in evidence collection from crash scenes, like the use of “black box” data recorders in cars, could help law enforcement determine driver culpability and apply firmer charges more often. The auto safety bill pending in Congress could mandate the inclusion of black boxes in new cars.

At the state level, Budnick said that T.A. is now beginning to look closely at suspended licenses. “People with suspended licenses, who aren’t supposed to be driving, drive all the time,” he said. “There needs to be some strengthening and housekeeping applied to the suspended license laws in New York.”

  • For anyone with some free time on Thursday afternoon, you’re invited to
    attend an important press conference with State Senator Daniel Squadron,
    Assemblymember Brian Kavanagh and Council Member Margaret Chin to
    announce that the Hayley and Diego Law to protect walkers and bikers
    goes into effect. The T.A. press release with the details is reprinted below.

    “Hayley and Diego’s Law” to Crack Down on Careless Driving Goes Into
    Law Named for Children Killed in Chinatown Van Crash
    Careless Drivers Will Now Face Jail Time for Injuring Pedestrians

    NEW YORK, NY – On Thursday, October 14 at 1:30 p.m., Senator Daniel
    Squadron, Assemblymember Brian Kavanagh, Council Member Margaret Chin,
    Transportation Alternatives and other pedestrian safety advocates will
    join with other local elected officials and community members to
    announce that a new law is in effect that increases the penalties for
    careless drivers who injure pedestrians, bicyclists and other road
    users. Last year, Hayley Ng, 4, and Diego Martinez, 3, were tragically
    killed in Chinatown when a delivery van that had been left in reverse
    climbed the curb and hit the children. The driver in question was not
    charged with any infraction resulting from the children’s deaths.

    WHO: Senator Daniel Squadron, Assemblymember Brian Kavanagh, Council
    Member Margaret Chin, Transportation Alternatives, other elected
    officials, and pedestrian safety advocates

    WHEN: Thursday, October 14 at 1:30 p.m.
    WHERE: Southwest corner of Essex Street and Delancey Street

  • Even if it doesn’t prove effective as a deterrent, and even in spite of frequent suspended license driving, I still support the hell out of this law: 1. motorists deserve it, and 2. if it gets just one dangerous driver to not drive for just one day, it will still make the streets safer.

    Thanks for that info BicyclesOnly. Can’t make it but I hope others can.

    Kudos to Kavanagh, Squadron, and TA.

    “T.A. has been in close contact with district attorneys and most are ready to use the new law where appropriate.” That’s why TA kicks ass.


With Hayley and Diego’s Law Unenforced, Sponsors Aim to Strengthen Law

In 2010, State Senator Dan Squadron and Assembly Member Brian Kavanagh stood on the corner of Essex and Delancey Streets to tell motorists: “Careless driving is unacceptable.” Said Kavanagh, “You can suffer serious consequences.” A year later, however, the new enforcement tool the two legislators were touting, Hayley and Diego’s Law, had gone almost entirely […]

Paterson Signs Two Traffic Justice Bills Into Law

On Friday evening, New York Governor David Paterson signed two bills intended to make streets safer by giving law enforcement greater leeway to bring charges against reckless drivers. Diego Martinez and Hayley Ng were killed when a van left idling and unattended careened backwards into a group of pre-schoolers on a Chinatown sidewalk. The driver […]

Hayley and Diego’s Law Might Be Enacted By Friday

Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer at a rally for Hayley and Diego’s Law last month. Photo: Noah Kazis The only thing that can prevent the adoption of New York state’s first "vulnerable users law" is Governor Paterson’s veto pen. Hayley and Diego’s Law, named in memory of two pre-schoolers killed by a van left idling […]

Senate Committee Votes to Close Loophole in Careless Driving Law

Just hours after the City Council transportation committee unanimously passed a resolution asking Albany to take action, the Senate transportation committee advanced a bill, with an 18-1 vote, that would close a loophole in Hayley and Diego’s Law, with the goal of increased enforcement of the state’s careless driving law by police and district attorneys. The law is named after […]

No More Excuses: Albany Bill Tells NYPD How to Enforce Careless Driving

At the February City Council hearing on NYPD traffic enforcement, council members and the public learned that a driver who injures a pedestrian or cyclist in New York City is not normally cited under the state vulnerable user laws unless an officer witnesses the violation. NYPD officials said department protocol prohibits precinct officers from issuing tickets […]