The Comptroller Race: Who Will Stand Up for Transit?

liu_yassky.jpgJohn Liu and David Yassky might be headed for a run-off in the comptroller race.

We’ve got two more citywide elections to review on the eve of tomorrow’s primary vote — the contests for comptroller and public advocate.

If you’re a little unclear about what these positions do, here’s the short version: The comptroller is the city’s financial watchdog, and the public advocate is the watchdog for everything else, evaluating the effectiveness of city policies and sometimes serving as a check against mayoral power. Whoever holds these positions will wield important oversight powers for the next four years, and we’ll probably see one or both of the winners make a run for mayor at some point.

In the right hands, both offices can advance the cause of livable streets. We’ll review the comptroller race first and then take a look at the public advocate contenders later today.

The comptroller can’t cast a vote in Albany for a transit funding package, but he or she can certainly help frame the debate. Democratic mayoral contender Bill Thompson could have used his comptroller’s pulpit to reinforce the Ravitch Commission bridge toll plan this year. Instead he opted to push for vehicle registration fees as an alternative to road pricing, giving the State Senate additional cover for its watered down transit funding package.

The race to succeed Thompson, which will effectively be decided in the Democratic primary, pits four City Council members against each other: David Yassky of Brooklyn, and John Liu, Melinda Katz, and David Weprin of Queens. Neither Katz nor Weprin cleared the most elementary livable streets hurdle during their council tenures, with each siding against congestion pricing in last year’s vote. So let’s review the intriguing Yassky-Liu rivalry.

Liu’s inconsistencies have been well-documented here on Streetsblog. His "yes" vote on congestion pricing in 2008 somehow morphed into vocal opposition to bridge tolls this year. He lectured on pedestrian safety from his post as transportation committee chair, but when DOT actually improved safety with its Midtown reclamation projects, he scolded the city for "expropriating" street space. And when the Bicycle Access Bill came before the City Council, Liu looked ready to scuttle the historic legislation until the last minute. As a comptroller candidate, he has turned to standard-issue MTA bashing as a staple of his campaign.

In addition to sponsoring the Bike Access Bill and shepherding it through the council, Yassky has consistently supported a car-free Prospect Park and helped secure funding for the Bedford Avenue bike parking swap. An early supporter of congestion pricing, Yassky has not made transit funding a signature campaign issue. But in his response to the TA candidate survey, he gives some promising indications that he will use the comptroller’s office to highlight the necessity of funding transit with road pricing.

Pledging to "set up in-depth assessments of the economic impact congestion has" and to "advocate and support policies like congestion pricing," Yassky says his office will "provide a solid platform from which to advocate change." A comptroller who follows through on those promises would be a valuable ally in the fight for sustainable transportation policy in the New York region.

  • Glenn

    Thanks for putting all these facts together in one place. And I’ll say it since S-blog and TA can’t: VOTE FOR YASSKY if you care about mass transit and livable street issues.

    The comptoller could do a lot to advance the livable streets issues and specifically project revenue numbers from real interventions like market rate parking, red light cameras, bridge tolls/congestion pricing, etc.

  • YasskyforComptroller

    It’s quite a stretch to say that NYC Comptroller’s office has any significance to Transit/livable streets issues. The public advocate (a position with no actual responsibilities) is even less significant. To the extent that people think Yassky has been bad and Liu has been good for these issues, the best bet would be to vote for Yassky and get him out of the way.

  • Glenn

    Y4C – that makes absolutely no sense.

  • Native NYer

    Let’s be fair. It is easier for Yassky, who reps transit rich northern Brooklyn to come out for congestion pricing than Liu, who reps a more car dependent eastern Queens. It was also Liu who held hearings on the car free parks bill, which I understand hasn’t moved forward because of some opposition from community boards in northern Manhattan, and it was Liu who agreed to hold hearings on the bikes in buildings bill, which never would have gotten a hearing in the buildings committee and would never have been enacted. Yassky also was the main proponent of a bill making the city’s stipulated fines program, which encourages illegal commercial parking, permanent until TA raised opposition to it. Also, though not transit-related, I will never vote for Yassky because of the convoluted logic he used to justify overturning term limits, which were approved by voters.

  • Loco Motive

    John Liu is a typical, populist blowhard politician.

  • James Thompson

    Can someone tell me if there is a run off for City Council? Thanks!

  • Looks like there aren’t any run-offs for Council, James, because the Times declared Yen Chou the winner of the Democratic nomination in District 20 with only 25% of the vote.


How Bill de Blasio and John Liu Can Stand Up for Transit Riders

Contrary to popular belief, the mayor isn’t the only elected official with a say in New York City transportation policy. So in this installment of Streetsblog’s series on Michael Bloomberg’s third term, we’re switching things up a bit. We asked New York’s most experienced transit advocate, Gene Russianoff of the Straphangers Campaign, how Comptroller-elect John […]

Voters Reject Incumbents in Low Turnout Primary

Margaret Chin, rallying an anti-DOT crowd last December, defeated Lower Manhattan council rep Alan Gerson in one of several losses for incumbents yesterday. The biggest news from last night’s primaries has to be the ouster of no fewer than four sitting City Council members in a vote marked by low turnout. A fifth incumbent, Maria […]

TA Sends Questionnaires to Mayoral and City Council Candidates

Yesterday, Transportation Alternatives sent out questionnaires to all City Council and mayoral candidates, asking their positions on pedestrian safety, bike lanes, transit, bike-share, and traffic justice. The first responses are set to go up on TA’s website at the end of this month. TA Deputy Director Noah Budnick told Streetsblog that the organization has already heard […]

Give Espada and Monserrate the “Oil Slick” Award

It would be nice to shame every member of the Fare Hike Four, but we’ll settle for the two on the right. Thanks to the folks at the Tri-State Transportation Campaign for pointing us to this excellent survey from EPL/Environment Advocates. State Senators Pedro Espada and Hiram Monserrate are finalists for the "Oil Slick" award, […]