Point/Counterpoint: Parking Reform Now or Later (or Never)?

What better time than Park(ing) Day (or should I say “Parrrrking Day”) to break out a fascinating piece from the magazine known as Parking Today, “the leading publication serving the diverse needs of
today’s parking industry.”

The trade pub recently ran a debate between parking planner Don Norte and performance parking guru Donald Shoup. Norte contends that cities shouldn’t adopt reforms like off-street parking maximums until they have reached a certain level of density and transit service:

Once a city or region has achieved transportation efficiency by
accommodating the number of trips generated by the appropriate mode of
travel, then the option of reducing minimum parking requirements across
the board can truly become a positive and cost-effective solution for
our policymakers.

But holding off on parking reform will only interfere with cities’ attempts to become more walkable and transit-oriented, responds Shoup:

Every developer knows that cities’ minimum parking requirements are
often the real limit to urban density. Minimum parking requirements
often force developers to provide more parking than they would
voluntarily provide, or smaller buildings than the zoning allows.
Off-street parking requirements do not promote a walkable and
sustainable city. Instead, off-street parking requirements promote a
drivable and unsustainable city.

If West Hollywood or any other city waits until there is excellent
public transit before it reduces its off-street parking requirements,
most people will continue to drive everywhere, even if Santa Claus
miraculously builds the transit system.

If planners insist that cities must have good public transit
before they can reduce their off-street parking requirements for every
land use, cities will never get good public transit. The smartest step
cities can take is to convert all their minimum parking requirements
into maximum parking limits, without changing any of the numbers.

More from Shoup, including plenty of observations that apply to parking reform in New York, after the jump.

City planners have no professional expertise or training to set parking
requirements. They don’t know how much parking spaces cost at any site,
and they don’t know how the parking requirements affect development or
the transportation system. City planners also know little about the
effects of parking requirements, but they are expected to know exactly
how many parking spaces are required for every land use.

In trying to foretell the demand for parking, urban planners
resemble the Wizard of Oz, deceived by his own tricks. No one should
blame planners for dispensing the elixir of ample free parking,
however, because everyone wants to park free. Nevertheless, planners
can be faulted for their pretension to special skills in dealing with
parking. Planners cannot predict parking demand any better than the
Wizard of Oz could give the Scarecrow brains or send Dorothy back to



Donald Shoup, an Appreciation

On Tuesday, the news came that after 41 years of teaching at UCLA, Donald Shoup, distinguished professor of urban planning, will retire. For all of us who have had our paths in life profoundly influenced by his research, writing, and teaching on parking and transportation, it’s a good time to reflect. I never got to […]

Planning Commission OKs Paltry Parking Reform for Downtown Brooklyn

The New York City Department of City Planning announced yesterday that the City Planning Commission has approved a measure to reduce Downtown Brooklyn’s onerous parking minimums. But the commission, chaired by Amanda Burden, appears to have wasted an opportunity to improve on the timid reforms. The good news is that new developments in Downtown Brooklyn, […]

De Blasio Housing Plan Meekly Suggests Parking Reform

There’s a deep connection between parking policy and housing affordability. The more space New York devotes to car storage, the less space is available to house people. And yet, 50 year old laws mandating the construction of parking in new residential development persist in most of the city, driving up construction costs and hampering the […]

Atlantic Yards Could Become Much Less Car-Centric

Off-street parking for the Atlantic Yards project, which sits near one of the world’s great confluences of transit lines, was once projected to include space for as many as 3,670 cars. Now the number of parking spots could get chopped down to 2,876 or, in one scenario, a significantly less car-centric 1,200, according to a […]

DC to Devote Parking Fees to Livable Streets

  In a first for a big east coast city, Washington, DC, is putting the ideas of celebrated parking reformer Don Shoup to work. Spurred by concerns over game day traffic surges caused by the opening of a new baseball stadium, the city council recently created two performance parking pilot project zones. The most important […]