David Gantt, Longtime Foe of Red-Light Cams, Changes Tune

Gantt2_782058.jpgOne of Albany’s chief foes of automated traffic enforcement appears to have softened his opposition to red-light cameras, but allegations of patronage may taint his turnaround.

For years, State Assembly Member David Gantt, a Rochester Democrat, has used his position as chair of the transportation committee to block the expansion of red-light cameras in New York and other cities. When pressed by advocates, Gantt could be relied upon to dismiss automated traffic enforcement by saying that privacy concerns trumped safety benefits. Not any longer.

In a recent about-face, Gantt has introduced legislation that would allow counties outside New York City to install red-light cameras at up to 25 percent of their intersections. New York, currently the only city in the state permitted to use the life-saving devices, first installed them in 1994 but is not allowed to set up more than 100. While the Gantt bill would not raise that limit, it may signal greater willingness on the part of Albany to approve automated enforcement measures down the road.

"From the perspective of New York City, it’s neither a good bill nor a bad bill," said Chad Marlow of the Public Advocacy Group, a public relations firm whose clients include Transportation Alternatives. "But it shows that Gantt is more open to red-light cameras than he was earlier."

Gantt’s motives, however, have attracted scrutiny. The bill would steer contracts to a specific vendor, who is lobbying for the legislation with the help of a former Gantt aide. The Buffalo News has the story:

…the bill appears crafted to benefit CMA Consulting Services, an
Albany County firm that distributes for Sensys Traffic, a Swedish firm…

Lobbying, with an $80,000
contract, on the issue for CMA is Robert Scott Gaddy, a former counsel
of Gantt’s Transportation Committee.

Gaddy said the Sensys
system distributed by CMA is not proprietary and that any other company
could use it. He said it is a higher-priced system because it includes
a number of advances over other systems.

Gantt’s bill is not expected to receive serious consideration until the next legislative session. Whether it survives the whiff of patronage or not, there will be an earlier test to see if the Assembly Member has truly changed his views on automated enforcement. The bus camera legislation transit advocates are now pressing for cannot receive a full vote in the Assembly without his say-so.

  • JF

    Does Sensys make bus lane enforcement cameras?

  • md

    Is Silver not calling the shots here?

  • vnm

    I don’t care who gets the bid, as long as the cameras are put in the streets.

  • fdr

    Read this week’s New York Magazine article on Silver, and how careful he is to keep his members happy. If Gantt wants it, and his old staffer is making money on it, and it can be sold as a traffic calming measure, everybody’s happy.

  • LN

    My favorite spot is west side hwy at houston st. The flash for the camera goes off everytime the light changes!

    Thats some serious cash to pay for more bike lane striping!

  • Marty Barfowitz

    Now you know why congestion pricing didn’t make it through Albany. The legislation didn’t deliver a fat contract directly to some friend of Brodsky, Farrell, Silver or whomever.

  • Blarg

    Pricing would have passed if 10% of the net went straight to the legislature to divvy up as super pork.

  • paul


    the cameras barely pay for themselves. they are not about making money for bike lanes, ped improvements and other livable streets upgrades. they are about saving lives and injuries, especially while NYPD resources are stretched thin on crime, security, etc.

  • Josh

    I agree with vnm. Plenty of other stuff gets through the legislature despite the presence or appearance of patronage, no reason this should be any different.

  • christine

    Bribing is good news: it shows that the sustainability agenda is going mainstream…

  • If you are interesed in helping pass bus camera enforcement legislation, you can pitch in at: http://www.livablestreets.com/projects/committe-to-convince-david-gantt-of-the-merits-of-mass-transit-and-law-enforcement/blog/


Red Light Cam Expansion Gets All Clear From Gantt

Red-light running "events" have declined dramatically where cameras have been installed. Source: NYCDOT. New York City’s red light cam program is on track to expand by 50 percent, pending legislation currently winding through Albany. Since 1994, the city has run a red light camera "demonstration program" — with proven safety benefits — which has to […]

Silver Gives Gantt Two More Years Atop Transpo Committee

Sheldon Silver and David Gantt On Thursday, Sheldon Silver re-appointed Rochester’s David Gantt to chair the Assembly Transportation Committee (Excel spreadsheet via Daily Politics). Gantt is the chairman who engineered the defeat of bus lane enforcement cameras last June, when six co-sponsors of the bill wound up voting against it in his committee. With the […]

Gov’s Budget Would Beef Up Red Light Camera Program

Red light cams have been proven to increase safety on New York City streets. Photo: mwilkie/Flickr Dig deep enough into Governor Paterson’s austerity budget and you’ll actually find a few pieces of good news. Case in point: One provision would allow New York to expand its red light camera program, currently limited to 100 cameras, […]

How David Gantt Sent Bus Cameras to Defeat in Albany

After state lawmakers dealt a setback to the city's Bus Rapid Transit plans, Streetsblog looked into how Assembly transportation committee chairman David Gantt was able to bring down a bill that reportedly enjoyed majority support among his members and won approval in the New York City Council by a 40 to 7 vote.