Parsing the Council Pricing Vote
But seriously folks, here are some quick hits from last night's congestion pricing council victory:
By
Brad Aaron
12:21 PM EDT on April 1, 2008
But seriously folks, here are some quick hits from last night’s congestion pricing council victory:
- All ten Manhattan and seven Bronx council members voted in favor. In Brooklyn the vote was 7-9 against; Queens 5-9, and Staten Island 1-2.
- Eric Gioia broke with his Queens colleagues to vote in favor of pricing, proving himself no doormat.
- Two candidates for Brooklyn borough president, Bill de Blasio and Charles Barron, voted against. According to the Politicker: “De Blasio said he thinks transit projects in Brooklyn probably wouldn’t be funded under the plan. Barron, describing the plan as a tax on poor New Yorkers, said that if the mayor can oppose a millionaire’s tax, the council should avoid congestion pricing.”
- The Politicker also notes that “two city comptroller candidates — Melinda Katz and David Weprin — voted against congestion pricing, while three of their likely opponents in the race — David Yassky, Simcha Felder and John Liu — voted for it.”
- The Sun reports that Lower Manhattan’s Alan Gerson “said he had been talking to Bloomberg aides about his demands until just before the vote. He said he had been assured that the administration would add traffic enforcement agents to his district, fund a study examining the Holland Tunnel corridor, and require new commuter buses to meet high environmental standards.”
- With the exception of de Blasio, Diana Reyna and Mathieu Eugene — all from Brooklyn — every council member counted as “undecided” by the New York Times in early March voted “yes.” Gerson, Gioia, Felder, Letitia James, Joel Rivera, Thomas White, Jr. and Michael McMahon were considered to be opposed to pricing at that time, but ultimately supported it.
- The Post says Senate Republicans may take up the pricing bill “as soon as today.” Though its “prospects in the Legislature are far from certain,” Crain’s reports they “have been improving in the last week.” Sheldon Silver, meanwhile, is presumably holding out for a deal TBD.
- Streetsblog’s Jason Varone reports: “Tony Avella was on Brian Lehrer this morning, and said he is filing a FOIL request to see if any unethical persuasion went on behind the scenes during the Mayor’s attempt to pass this bill. He also said that if he is elected Mayor next year, he will stop congestion pricing immediately.”
- According to Keep NYC Congestion Tax Free, that won’t be necessary.
Brad Aaron began writing for Streetsblog in 2007, after years as a reporter, editor, and publisher in the alternative weekly business. Brad adopted New York's dysfunctional traffic justice system as his primary beat for Streetsblog. He lives in Manhattan.
Read More:
More from Streetsblog New York City
City to Close Bus-Clogged Lane on the Manhattan Bridge
Buses love to block the lane, but it’s an opportunity to think much bigger.
November 12, 2026
As NYC Debates Amazon’s Delivery Model, Its Partner Fires 200 E-Bike Workers
Just as the City Council debates reining in Amazon's business practices, the delivery giant threw workers of the job after canceling its contract with a Manhattan subcontractor.
November 12, 2026
Brooklyn’s New Bike Boulevards Will Benefit the 90 Percent of Residents Who Don’t Drive To Work
Nine out of ten Brooklynites living around the proposed bike route commute to work without a car, but lazy reporters would rather write a "neighborhood divided" piece with no context.
November 12, 2026
GET OUT: E-Bike Battery Fires are a Crisis We Can No Longer Ignore
New York City must confiscate sub-standard ebike batteries that cause deadly fires. A surcharge could pay for the sweep.
November 12, 2026
Thursday’s Headlines: Let’s Talk BQE Edition
Now's your chance to speak out against the mayor's plan to keep the BQE in place for another half-century. Plus the news.
November 12, 2026