Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Congestion Pricing

Compromise “Ruled the Day” at Congestion Pricing Hearings

#Persons
%Persons
Position
39
26%
Support congestion pricing as proposed by Mayor Bloomberg in April 2007 PlaNYC proposal
46
31%
Support the concept of pricing, have concerns and recommend changes/additions to Mayor Bloomberg's proposal
13
9%
Express serious concerns with the current proposal and offer suggestions for improvement
39
26%
Oppose congestion pricing, suggest other strategies for alleviating traffic
12
8%
Do not address congestion pricing

Source: Environmental Defense

Just before Thanksgiving, Environmental Defense tallied up all of the public testimony delivered to the Traffic Mitigation Commission and found that 57 percent of the witnesses who testified "support the concept of congestion pricing." Based on the analysis, ED's Neil Giacobbi concluded:

The public hearings show that New Yorkers do in fact support the concept of congestion pricing, although they may want to see the original proposal tweaked and they want to see the revenues spent on transit improvements. Polls showing majority opposition to the original congestion pricing plan don't take these facts into account.

John DeSio sees it otherwise. DeSio (who readers may recall as the messenger for Jeffrey Dinowitz's angry response to a Streetsblog item in September), writes in the Village Voice:

The same survey also paints a grim picture of the state of civic engagement in this City, illustrating what could be described as a disturbing lack of interest on the part of the general public when it comes to voicing their opinions on a plan that would radically change the urban landscape. Just 149 individuals testified at the seven total hearings. When you subtract elected officials, civic organizations and other interested parties, you are left with just 28 percent, 42 total regular people, who felt the need to testify.

While Giacobbi agrees that the Commission's accelerated timeline has not been ideal for gathering public input, he believes that the hearings were productive, noting, "compromise, not blind support or opposition, ruled the day during the seven commission hearings." ED's analysis found that 26 percent of people testified both for and against congestion pricing, but even more speakers, 40 percent, offered suggestions to improve the policy.

Giacobbi said there are great lessons to be learned in studying the responses of the accumulated testimony, that the support for congestion pricing is not as cut and dry as polls might make it seem. "We're trying to do anything we can to demonstrate that there is more flexibility on this issue than people might believe," said Giacobbi. When people are given more than a yes or no option, he said, they tend to offer their support for congestion pricing, albeit with their own unique changes.

"Most people haven't thought about this critically," said Giacobbi. "Once you get into the details of the plan, they come around to it." Transit improvements have to come from somewhere, he added, and congestion pricing is the best way to pump that money into the system. The sooner people realize that the better off commuters will be, said Giacobbi.

"The poll says that New Yorkers do not fundamentally understand congestion pricing," he said. "If they did understand it, they would support it."

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Friday Video: Amtrak Is Way More Successful Than You Think

Why do so many people still treat Amtrak as a failure — and what would it take to deliver the rail investment that American riders deserve?

October 24, 2025

Hundreds of Community Groups — From the Conservatives to the Socialists! — Demand Daylighting

Two hundred New York City groups from across the ideological spectrum joined calls to ban parking at corners in order to improve safety and visibility, also known as daylighting.

October 24, 2025

OPINION: Canal Street — Not The Vendors — Is the Problem

If Zohran Mamdani becomes mayor — and is true to his vision for a fair, livable city — he will have to take on this long-ignored corridor. Here's how.

October 24, 2025

Vision Zero Cities: Bicycles Are Not Cars So They Shouldn’t Have to Follow the Same Rules

The default in nearly all states is to impose the same traffic rules on bicycles as on motor vehicles even though the needs of cyclists are so different.

October 24, 2025

Friday’s Headlines: Today’s the Day Edition

Mayor Adams's new 15 mph speed limit is officially goes into effect today. Plus more news.

October 24, 2025

Cough, Cough: DEP Considers Largest Ever Exemption Request to City’s Anti-Idling Law

Academy Bus claims no technological alternatives exist for heating and cooling buses without idling. Advocates warn an exemption would "gut" the city's 50-year-old idling ban.

October 23, 2025
See all posts