Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Elections

In Their Own Words: Ari Kagan vs. Justin Brannan for Council in Bay Ridge/Coney Island

Two incumbent Council members are on a collision course to represent a newly drawn district that includes pieces of their existing districts. Hear what they said about livable streets issues.

In the newly redrawn 47th Council District, one incumbent (Justin Brannan, left) will battle another incumbent (Ari Kagan, right). Today, they answered questions from podcaster Ben Max (inset).

Two incumbent Council members on a collision course due to redistricting (and the party switch by one of them!) met for a broadcast debate earlier today and neither emerged as a true hero of the livable streets movement.

Granted, the full debate for the 47th District in Brooklyn broached topics as diverse as immigration, casinos and whether Rep. Hakeem Jeffries should one day be Speaker of the House of Representatives in distant Washington, D.C. — but in lightning round questioning, neither Council Member Justin Brannan, the Democrat, nor Council Member Ari Kagan, the one-time Democrat who changed party to run against Brannan when his own district was redrawn, championed street safety or transit beyond Brannan's full-throated support for bus lanes for his district (which currently has none).

Here were their answers to questions from former Gotham Gazette Editor Ben Max of the Max Politics podcast. (To hear the full hour-long debate, click here.) StreetsPAC has previously endorsed Brannan in his previous elections. The group has never endorsed Kagan.

Question: What is one public transit improvement that you will be fighting for once congestion pricing is in place?

Ari Kagan: I'm using public transportation every day and I want the F train to start going Express from Coney Island all the way to Manhattan.

Justin Brannan: Bringing the ferry to Coney Island.

Kagan: I'm a strong opponent of congestion pricing.

Question: Do you want to see more dedicated protected bus lanes in this district?

Kagan: Not more. What they have right now is enough. [Editor's note: Kagan's current district, 47, ranks 41st out of 51 Council districts for bus lanes, according to data from MIT.]

Brannan: Yes, I'm a big bus lane guy. [Editor's note: Brannan's district is dead last with no dedicated bus lanes, according to the same data.]

Question: Should there be more — or in the of this district, any — protected bike lanes?

Kagan: No.

Brannan: If we're going to have bike lanes, I rather they'd be protected than just the paint in the street.

The election for the newly redrawn 47th District is on Nov. 7. The last day to register is Oct. 28. Click here for info.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Cyclist: Cop Pulled a Taser During Summons Chase

In a dramatic escalation of the NYPD's criminal crackdown on bike riders, a police officer pulled a stun gun while chasing a cyclist for allegedly running a red light on a regular bike.

May 30, 2025

Albany Pols Seize the Helm(et)

Helmet laws remain controversial — they're the "common-sense" approach pushed by lawmakers who ignore that studies show they don't improve safety.

May 30, 2025

Tisch Reveals Real Reason for Her E-Bike Crackdown: E-Bike Licensing

NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch doubles down on her cycling criminalization campaign, saying e-bike licensing is the only other option.

May 30, 2025

Friday’s Headlines: A ‘Critical’ Moment Edition

Cyclists will protest against the NYPD's bike crackdown with a Critical Mass ride to City Hall on Friday. Plus more news.

May 30, 2025

Eyes on the Street: Astoria’s Big Beautiful 31st Avenue Bike Boulevard

Streetsblog paid a visit to New York City's widest on-street protected bike lane ever, which is up and running in Astoria.

May 30, 2025
See all posts