Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Car crashes

Ydanis: To Keep NYC Safe, Turn on Those Cameras

Politicians talk a lot about speed cameras — a montage.

How much home rule should New York City have when it comes to setting its traffic regulations? Much more, argues City Council Transportation Committee Chairman Ydanis Rodriguez — who could wind up as the next Department of Transportation commissioner if Eric Adams becomes mayor. Rodriguez pitched us this op-ed after Albany lawmakers completely failed to pass key legislation to give the city more control.

Ydanis Rodriguez
Ydanis Rodriguez
Ydanis Rodriguez

As the city begins to reopen, people return to in-person work and school, and tourists come back, our roads are once again becoming increasingly congested and dangerous.

This year is already on track to be the second-most-deadly year on our roads since Mayor de Blasio took office, with more than 70 drivers, passengers, pedestrians and cyclists already killed in traffic-related accidents, according to Vision Zero statistics. This followed a rough 2020 during which speeding on streets emptied because of the pandemic led to more deaths and injuries from traffic-related collisions. That's unacceptable.

A just recovery means not only reopening  the city to all communities, businesses, tourism and schools, but making sure it remains safe for everyone who lives, works and visits here. Unfortunately, the city is fighting dangerous driving with one — and sometimes both — hands tied behind our back. Our partners in Albany are limiting our ability to control our streets and impeding our ability to create a safer New York City for pedestrians, bikers and drivers alike.

Traffic-enforcement cameras are a critical tool in keeping our streets safe. But current state law limits the cameras' effectiveness. Albany places too-strict limits on how many safety cameras the city can use, where we can deploy them and what hours they can operate. These restrictions make no sense.

By the end of 2021, the city will have in operation almost 2,500 red-light, speed and bus-lane cameras. The city's own data show that they are very effective in making intersections safer, bus lanes more efficient and reducing speed and injuries; in fact, they reducing speeding by 71.5 percent and injuries by 16.9 percent.

It’s a proven fact that when drivers get a ticket, they change their behavior. For example, Department of Transportation data show that two-thirds of motorists fined through the use of safety cameras did not receive another violation in the same calendar year.

Take school-zone speed cameras. State law now only allows school-zone speed cameras to be on from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. on weekdays. But many deadly crashes occur outside those hours and on weekends. Crash data show as many as a third of deadly crashes occur when speed cameras are turned off. Why not use these tools to maximum effectiveness and keep them running around the clock? Why turn them off when they can be doing as much good as they do when they are turned on?

Last month, the City Council passed and the mayor signed my bill to give regulatory powers to the DOT over motorized scooter rentals. It empowers the DOT to set safety standards as well as rules for vehicle upkeep and (most important) rider behavior that will reduce the number of injuries and deaths resulting from misuse of these vehicles.

But more needs to be done. The city should have full control over the regulation of its streets — whether that is over scooters, traffic-safety cameras, speed limits, or anything else. We know our streets best and what is needed to keep them moving safely and efficiently.

Traffic-safety cameras could be a good first step. Albany ended this year’s session without taking action, but state legislators must free the city to use these cameras for maximum effectiveness to keep our streets and our families safe. The Legislature must allow us to expand the number of cameras as needed and to keep them running 24/7. They’ve already proven their worth in reducing traffic collisions, injuries, and deaths.

By taking this final step and allowing the city more control over the deployment of safety cameras, we can realize the mayor’s Vision Zero of no more pedestrian or cyclist deaths and safer streets for pedestrians, cyclists and drivers throughout the city.

Ydanis Rodriguez (@ydanis) is the term-limited Council member from Upper Manhattan's 10th district.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Hit-and-Run Driver Kills Pedestrian on Bedford Av. Hours Before Long-Stalled Safety Redesign Begins

The driver was traveling so quickly that the victim was tossed high in the air before landing back on the car hood and being tossed to the side of the road as the killer drove off.

October 11, 2024

Manhattanites To DOT: Open Queensboro Bridge Pedestrian Path ‘Without Delay’

"It’s really inappropriate for the DOT to delay," said one member of Manhattan Community Board 6.

October 11, 2024

Council Seeks to Force DOT to Build 175 E-Bike Charging Hubs 

A new bill would force the DOT to build over 100 charging hubs, but will it be enough to keep up with demand?

October 11, 2024

Friday Video: A Vision for West 72nd Street

Maybe someday, a roadway that devotes 88 percent of its space to a tiny minority of users (drivers) could finally work for everyone. We can dream, can't we?

October 11, 2024

Friday’s Headlines: Yes, We Will Mention the Yankees Edition

We are praying for the first Subway Series since 2000. Plus other news.

October 11, 2024
See all posts