Opinion: Time To Protect the City’s Street Vendors

The pandemic has hurt these mostly immigrant small businesses, which have always faced discriminatory enforcement. The administration must step up with law, open streets and policy.

Evelia's Tamales, an immigrant-owned food truck, has tried to keep its business alive during the pandemic. Photo: Street Vendor Project
Evelia's Tamales, an immigrant-owned food truck, has tried to keep its business alive during the pandemic. Photo: Street Vendor Project

In the course of a few weeks, New York City has managed to cut the red tape to help thousands of struggling restaurants and bars reopen their doors and allow them to create elaborate outdoor set-ups for diners. Streetscapes across New York City have been transformed beyond our wildest dreams. Unfortunately, street vendors, who are routinely scrutinized and punished for every inch of space they take up, were excluded from the planning process

Council Members Margaret Chin and Carlos Menchaca.
Council Members Margaret Chin and Carlos Menchaca.

It’s time for the city to turn the chapter on this history of neglect and make things right by this abandoned small-business community. Street vendors are not asking for the world. They are simply asking to be acknowledged, for a fighting chance to claim their rightful space in our city’s recovery, for a fighting chance to survive. 

The administration can reform this broken system and do something now by:

  • Launching a small-business grant program for street vendors, 
  • Identifying more open street spaces for vendors who cannot sustain their businesses in their usual location due to the loss of foot traffic,
  • And, finally, ending the longstanding permit cap that has forced vendors to operate in an exploitative underground market by passing Intro 1116 — a bill that would expand the number of permits to vend food on the streets and sidewalks and create a dedicated vending law-enforcement unit, which would exclusively enforce vending laws — as soon as possible.  This is one tool that the administration has been sitting on for years — but could take up right now. There’s no reason to wait any longer. By passing this bill,  the city would not only release new permits for street vendors to work legally for the first time in almost 40 years, but also codify the removal of NYPD from enforcement. 

Street vendors have fed New Yorkers throughout the COVID-19 pandemic. It’s time for neglected immigrant street vendors to claim their space in our recovery.

At the brink of the pandemic, bustling city sidewalks turned into ghost towns overnight. And, in turn, immigrant street vendors who depended on daily foot traffic were forced out of business.

Nevertheless, they carried on. Some even scraped together whatever resources they had left to support pop-up food pantries to serve New Yorkers facing food insecurity, many of them immigrant seniors in desperate need of culturally competent food that weren’t being offered by the city’s emergency food programs.

But in spite of our call to the administration to expand eligibility for small-business relief programs to accommodate street vendors, street vendors have been left to languish with zero financial support to run their businesses or feed their families.  

The exclusion of this small-business community from COVID relief is only the latest chapter in a decades-old story that has painted street vendors as “annoying inconveniences” instead of dignified entrepreneurs in their own right.  This is the same story that has stripped them of economic opportunities while subjecting them to excessive police interactions. The same story that has enshrined them as a tokenized symbol of New York City’s diversity while simultaneously criminalizing them for existing. 

Vendors hawk trinkets at Corona Plaza in Queens. Photo: Street Vendor Project
Vendors in Corona Plaza in Queens. Photo: Street Vendor Project

We can’t help but ask why, time and time again, street vendors have not yet been afforded the relief and respect they’ve been fighting for.

The problematic, and sometimes racialized, rhetoric used against our fight to end the unjust permit cap is not lost on us. Instead of focusing on ending the underground permit market that has forced street vendors to spend tens of thousands of dollars just for a chance to legally work, some would rather express outrage over vendors potentially “flooding” the streets.

But the recent massive success of the city’s outdoor dining program has put even that concern up for debate. 

Whether it’s a Fifth Avenue hot-dog stand, a Chinatown fruit cart, or a Sunset Park taco truck, street vendors are deeply embedded in the history and cultural identity of New York City. Their work has never been easy, but they deserve relief, too. Our city has an opportunity to be part of the solution by passing Intro 1116. This is the bare minimum.

City Council Members Margaret Chin represents Lower Manhattan and Carlos Menchaca represents Sunset Park in Brooklyn.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

NYC Can Make Room for New Food Carts and Leave Space to Walk

|
The City Council is expected to move swiftly on a bill to eventually double the number of food vendor permits. Before the package of bills known as the Street Vending Modernization Act passes, advocates want to ensure that it includes more safeguards to avoid obstructing crowded sidewalks. New York City capped the number of vendor permits at 4,235 in the […]

How Mexico City Fought and Cajoled to Reclaim Streets for Pedestrians

|
This is the first in a series of reports about sustainable transportation policies in Mexico City. Last week, Streetsblog participated in a tour of the city led by the Institute for Transportation and Development Policy and funded by the Rockefeller Foundation. Upcoming installments will cover the city’s transit expansions, particularly its new bus rapid transit […]

Meet Your New Transportation and Land Use Committee Chairs

|
It’s official: Council Member Ydanis Rodriguez is chair of the transportation committee, and Council Member David Greenfield will head up the powerful land use committee. While Rodriguez’s appointment has been greeted mostly with optimism by street safety advocates, Greenfield’s ascendance raises flags about whether the city will be able to get much-needed parking reforms through […]