Tuesday’s Headlines: The Hunt for John Sherman Edition
On an otherwise slow holiday, we found ourselves defending our coverage of Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez's failure to prosecute a killer driver. Plus the other news.
By
Streetsblog
12:05 AM EST on February 18, 2020
If you follow us on Twitter, you may have noticed that both our official account (@Streetsblognyc) and the account of our ace reporter Julianne Cuba (@julcuba) were defending their honor against a charge of journalistic malpractice by Brooklyn District Attorney spokesman Oren Yaniv (@orenyaniv). So let’s clear this all up:
- John Sherman ran over and killed his neighbor Stella Clinton on March 6, 2019. He was charged by the NYPD on March 27, 2019. That is nine full months before the end of 2019, plenty of time to prosecute a driver for failure to yield and failure to exercise due care.
- In February, 2020, Streetsblog reported that Brooklyn DA Eric Gonzalez had never prosecuted Sherman, letting the case lapse without holding the killer driver accountable. (By the way, since killing Clinton less than a year ago, Sherman’s car, below, has been caught on camera seven times for speeding and once for running a red light.)

That was fun. Now here are yesterday’s headlines:
- Red Hook wants buses not the BQX. (Brooklyn Paper)
- Here’s more subway graffiti to drive NY Post editors crazy. Gothamist blamed the NYPD.
- Hit-and-run carnage in Harlem. (NYDN, NY Post)
- Todd Maisel of amNY was, as always, Toddy on the spot of a hit-and-run crash in kid-filled Ditmas Park that almost killed an 11-year-old. The driver was eventually caught.
- There’s been more talk about garbage over the last few days, with Crain’s discussing how we can finally get back our sidewalks and the NY Times finally doing the broad overview of the city’s efforts to tame rogue private carters. (We wrote about it here and here and here.)
This piece was the work of the Streetsblog staff.
Read More:
More from Streetsblog New York City
Mayor Mamdani Promises To De-Weaponize Bikes As Part Of Police Reform Effort
"The NYPD will be able to continue to use bicycles as a form of transit," Mamdani said at a press conference about his disbanding of the NYPD's Strategic Response Group. "And what we’ve made very clear is a limitation on the use of bicycles as a weapon or form of aggression.”
November 18, 2026
Wednesday’s Headlines: A Tale Of Two Ribbon-Cuttings Edition
Mayor Mamdani could have celebrated buses on Tuesday but instead cheered for cars. Plus other news.
November 18, 2026
Shoppers Rejoice! The Flatbush Avenue Bus Lanes Are Officially Open
The red lanes and new boarding islands are fully open for business.
November 17, 2026
Mayor Mamdani Mulls Motor Vehicles In Central Park
Having approved the end of horse carriage rides in Central Park, Mayor Mamdani now says he may allow electric tourism vehicles.
November 17, 2026
London’s Car-Free Oxford Street Is a Lesson for Mamdani’s Fifth Avenue Redesign
The holiday season approacheth, Mayor Mamdani.
November 17, 2026