Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Bicycle Infrastructure

City Asks Cyclists Where To Put Protected Bike Lanes; Cyclists Respond, ‘Um, Everywhere!’

2:49 PM EDT on September 25, 2019

Cyclists want more protected bike lanes — and it’s not protected if someone can park on it. Photo: Paco Abraham

City planners are asking New York cyclists what neighborhoods would be best for protected bike lanes — and cyclists are already responding defiantly: "All of them."

Last week, the Department of City Planning quietly started circulating a questionnaire — through the Department of Transportation's NYCycles newsletter — to "increase knowledge and understanding of bicycle use in New York City."

A sample question.
A sample question and a sample answer.
A sample question.

"We hope to help you enjoy better cycling in this community," the agency told cyclists. "By filling out this survey, you can help us do so."

Early response suggests that cyclists are responding aggressively to the survey's signature question: "Are there any neighborhoods where you believe increased bike infrastructure — including bike share, etc. — could increase cycling."

The question asks for five specific neighborhoods or ZIP codes, but judging from Twitter, many cyclists have taken the opportunity to go beyond small zones (see examples below):

Other questions seek to understand "why" people ride. The survey lets cyclists pick such reasons as "enjoyment" or because it's just the best way to get around town (though it's unlikely cyclists will say they ride because, "There is good bike infrastructure").

Another question asks "What factors would get you to ride a bike more?" Choices include: "More protected bike lanes" and "safer traffic conditions."

Though the survey will seem ludicrous to many daily cyclists, there is some good news: Its very existence suggests that the de Blasio administration does want to increase cycling, which has stalled due in part to the blood tide crashing over New York's streets this year. And the survey doesn't offer cyclists a real chance to express their opinions about the real problems on the streets of New York, including poor enforcement of basic safety rules by the NYPD and tens of thousands of illegally parked, placard-protected city employees.

Still, the Planning department said it's a crucial first step.

"The purpose ... is to better understand why cyclists choose to ride bikes rather than use automobiles and to find ways to make biking a more convenient and viable alternative to automobiles, increasing sustainable mobility choices," Department of City Planning spokesman Joe Marvilli told Streetsblog. "This will help the city focus improvements for cyclists across New York City."

The agency said it would share the survey more widely than the DOT's obscure newsletter, including more outreach via social media and distribution of physical copies at "heavily used bike parking locations in all five boroughs" (what bike parking locations?)

Marvilli said the agency will share the results when it is finished compiling them.

Fill out the survey by clicking here.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Feds One Step Closer to Requiring Safety Standards for Lithium-ion Batteries

Safety standards are fine, but the responsibility for securing better power packs will still fall on the lowest-paid workers in our city.

December 11, 2023

City Adds Another Moving Lane to Appease Car Drivers Near Williamsburg Bridge

Induced demand isn't just a theory — it's apparently a policy of the city Department of Transportation.

December 11, 2023

Monday’s Headlines: The Bronx Nobody Knows Edition

If you know someone who loves The Bronx and loves to walk, have we got a stocking stuffer for you. Plus, more important, the weekend's news.

December 11, 2023

Third Ave. ‘Complete Street’ Adds Wide Bike Lane, But Still Keeps Too Much Space for Cars

The bike lane is a good start, but the city must aim higher for its "complete streets," advocates say.

December 8, 2023
See all posts