Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Bicycle Safety

Miraculous Safety Toilet Plungers Fix Fifth Avenue Mixing Zones For Just $4.99

Members of the Transformation Department put out plungers on Fifth Avenue to demonstrate the danger of unprotected mixing zones. Photo: Transformation Department

It's time to flush mixing zones down the toilet!

Activists "fixed" the city's most controversial and dangerous intersection design in the simplest manner — deploying simple toilet plungers to keep cars out of a "mixing zone" on Fifth Avenue on Tuesday night — in the latest effort to highlight the de Blasio administration's Vision Zero shortcomings and symbolically deposit them in the bathroom fixture evoked.

Mixing zones have been deployed for several years by the city to, theoretically at least, let drivers safely turn through bike lanes and give cyclists space to veer around them, but in practice lead to drivers almost running into cyclists and in some cases killing them. So on Tuesday night, before Transportation Alternatives' die-in in Washington Square Park, members of the  Transformation Department deployed some well-placed toilet plungers near 10th Street as a barrier to give cyclists and drivers safe, conflict-free passage.

The activists, who comprise Twitter's best-loved rogue government agency, said they "wanted to show how easy and inexpensive it is to fix this known danger."

This bit of tactical urbanism forced drivers to choose: drive over a bunch of stuck up plungers or drive around them, which meant stopping to let a series of cyclists moving up the street go through the intersection first. And as the video evidence shows, the drivers waited and the cyclists took the light (and hey for you prescriptivists out there, don't forget the people going straight through the intersection have the right of way over people turning).

Look at that! Instead of "balancing" the desire of motorists to get where they're going as fast as possible without any hitch or speed bump, human or otherwise, the more vulnerable road users got where they were going safely.

The good news is that the DOT is moving away from mixing zones along First and Second avenues in Manhattan and Fourth Avenue in Brooklyn, in favor of semi-protected offset crossings. It's a switch that the Transformation Department told us is "a huge improvement," with just one caveat: "The problem is the pace of these improvements," the group said over a DM. "Where they are happening, it’s only as streets get repaved. There’s nothing stopping DOT from moving faster."

Another caveat: Not all drivers know exactly what to do at an offset crossing, as many of them veer too far into the side street on turns, blocking cyclists as they proceed — with the right of way! — straight. And the city's own report — "Cycling at a Crossroads" [PDF] — is very clear that all intersections have shortcomings. One thing is certain: Cyclists say they feel more "comfortable" at offset crossings, the report showed.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

SQUEEZED: Welcome to the Newly Unsafe Bedford Avenue ‘Bike Lane’

Bike riders are now endangered by parked cars and fast-moving traffic between Willoughby and Flushing avenues, as drivers revert to doing ... exactly what they had been doing.

Eric Adams May Veto Grocery Delivery Minimum Wage that Eric Adams Championed

A 2022 report from the former Democrat promised to expand labor protections to more app delivery workers, but he won't commit to supporting Council bills trying to do just that.

August 6, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines: Blow Canada Edition

Wow, something is really putrid in the air over New York City, and it's not the hometown ball clubs. Plus other news.

August 6, 2025

OPINION: Actually, Amazon’s Cargo E-Bikes are Good!

Amazon’s e-cargo bikes alleviate the need for delivery vans and reduce traffic collisions. They also look rad.

August 5, 2025

Inside Instacart’s Astro-Turf Group Opposing Worker Minimum Wage

Instacart is trying everything to pressure the mayor to veto a bill that would require the company to pay its workers minimum wage.

August 5, 2025

Zivarts: How ‘Week Without Driving’ Is Having An Impact

Needing to drive in a car-dependent society is not some sort of moral failure. A one-week teach-in can help elected officials see that.

August 5, 2025
See all posts