Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
DOT

Another Bronx Judge Bows Out of Morris Park Ave. Vision Zero Case

Well, recuuuse me (and me, and me, and me, too)!

A fourth Bronx judge has declined to participate in a lawsuit brought by a group of Morris Park Avenue business owners and the local Council member to stop a street redesign project, citing “community ties.”

Judge Alison Tuitt is the fourth judge to recuse herself in the so-called “road diet” case. Tuitt herself did not appear in her Bronx Supreme courtroom on Monday but sent out her court attorney Alicia Gerez to deliver the bad news that the case had again been delayed for questionable reasons.

“Some of the judges have community ties,” Gerez told lawyers from the Morris Park plaintiffs and the city Law Department, who’ve heard it all before.

Three other judges have recused themselves in the case, which was filed last month and argues with thin legal basis that the city has no right to convert the neighborhood’s main strip from a dangerous four-lane speedway where scores have been injured into a three-lane roadway with a center turning lane and a painted bike lane.

That configuration has proven successful in other neighborhoods, but has consistently been decried by a small group of business owners and Council Member Mark Gjonaj.

A handout from DOT shows how many crashes have occurred on the notorious speedway.
A handout from DOT shows how many crashes have occurred on the notorious speedway.
A handout from DOT shows how many crashes have occurred on the notorious speedway.

All the parties are waiting in the courthouse this morning to hopefully get another judge who will hear the case, which seeks to put Mayor de Blasio and his Vision Zero initiative on trial.

“They’re recusing themselves because they’re afraid to go against the city,” said Al D’Angelo, one of the plaintiffs and a member of the local community board.

A judge has grounds for recusal only if there is an “actual or perceived” conflict, a Law Department spokesman said. In a small county with an entrenched political machine, one could find perceived conflicts anywhere.

There have been six judges overall, including the four who opted out, one who was “unavailable,” and the judge who issued a temporary restraining order last month that prevented the city from beginning work on the project.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Tuesday’s Headlines: Biking with a Dutchman Edition

You really get a fresh perspective on city cycling when you do it with someone from Holland. Plus other news.

April 16, 2024

City Urges Judge to Toss Anti-Open Streets Lawsuit

The city's not responsible for 24-7 car access to every street, officials argued.

April 16, 2024

Opinion: Connect the Dots of Manhattan’s Missing Bike Lanes

Only a few miles of missing protected lanes stand in the way of a robust bike network.

April 15, 2024

Monday’s Headlines: Thanking the Academy Edition

We would be remiss if we didn't offer some photos and copy about Friday's George Polk Awards ceremony, plus other news.

April 15, 2024

Civic Panel Pushes For (Some) Atlantic Ave. Safety Upgrades

Brooklyn Community Board 2 stopped short of calling for a more aggressive redesign of a street where drivers have killed six pedestrians in the last decade.

April 15, 2024
See all posts