Neighborhood Residents to de Blasio: Get Reckless Recidivist Cop off Our Streets!

The car that got slapped with 63 tickets, including 34 speeding tickets and seven red light tickets, is parked in the foreground of the general mess at the 23rd station house in East Harlem. Photo: Julianne Cuba
The car that got slapped with 63 tickets, including 34 speeding tickets and seven red light tickets, is parked in the foreground of the general mess at the 23rd station house in East Harlem. Photo: Julianne Cuba

Residents of Queens — and the principal of a major high school — are begging Mayor de Blasio to rid the streets of a recklessly driving NYPD cop who has blown past enforcement cameras 41 times, endangering pedestrians, cyclists, other motorists and the students whom the cameras are meant to protect.

Streetsblog reported this week that an officer at the 23rd Precinct in Manhattan has been slapped with 34 speeding tickets and seven red-light tickets — all issued by automated systems — since 2014. Eighteen of the speeding violations were captured on Queens Boulevard at 36th Street in Sunnyside, where the Department of Transportation has set up a camera. Ten more of the speeding tickets were issued by nearby cameras.

Locals are calling on the mayor to protect them.

“I don’t feel safe,” said Mark Ray, who works in the liquor store at the site of the speed camera system. “This guy needs to be suspended. He’s so stupid. Eighteen tickets all at the same spot? There are kids here!”

Photo: Gersh Kuntzman
The rogue Manhattan cop has sped past this Queens school at least 18 times. Photo: Gersh Kuntzman

The kids to which Ray is referring pour into and out of Aviation High School, which is on the eastbound side of Queens Boulevard. Principal Steven Jackson told Streetsblog that he had seen our story on Twitter and was immediately concerned.

“We are always concerned about our students’ safety,” Jackson said. “I am definitely going to address this with the NYPD.”

This is the speed camera that he has repeatedly blown past. Photo: Gersh Kuntzman
This is the speed camera that he has repeatedly blown past. Photo: Gersh Kuntzman

Since Streetsblog reported on the recidivist officer — who has 63 tickets overall — the website has discovered many more scofflaws who rack up a dozen or more tickets as drive to or from their station houses for work. The 108th Precinct in Long Island City, for example, has a cop whose personal vehicle has been hit with 31 tickets in all, including  18 camera tickets for speeding and two for running red lights.

In all, we have run the license plate numbers of 714 personal vehicles of NYPD officers and employees and found deep evidence that the people who are supposed to be protecting our communities are actually the very people from whom we all need to be protected.

Of all the driving records we checked through the Howsmydrivingny database:

  • 552 officers’ vehicles — or 77 percent — had at least one ticket.
  • 417 vehicles — or 58 percent — had at least one serious moving violation, such as a red light or a speeding ticket.
  • 263 vehicles — or 37 percent — had repeat serious violations.

The mayor declined to comment about the numbers, even though some of the recidivists would not even be allowed to drive under a pending bill by Council Member Brad Lander that would give the NYPD the right to impound any vehicle with five or more camera tickets in any 12-month period. Both cops mentioned in this story would have been in violation of that law.

current totals

“Everyone should be alarmed at the number and frequency of these violations. That’s why I’m a co-sponsor of Brad Lander’s bill to get reckless drivers off the road,” Council Member Jimmy Van Bramer said in a statement to Streetsblog, which reached out to Van Bramer because he represents the district that includes the 108th Precinct station house and the stretch of Queens Boulevard where the officer from the 23rd Precinct is so often caught.

Van Bramer and other politicians declined to criticize the NYPD, but activists and residents were livid after reading the Streetsblog account.

“Sharing the road with drivers like this NYPD officer is terrifying,” said Laura Shepard, a Woodside resident and chairwoman of the Transportation Alternatives Queens Committee. “Those of us who walk and bike in Sunnyside are not safe on our streets while this driver is loose on the road. The city must use its power and devote resources to removing all drivers with egregious documented histories of reckless and dangerous behavior before they hurt or kill. We’ve already lost too many pedestrians and cyclists in Sunnyside and we don’t want to lose any more.”

Meanwhile, on the Upper East Side, residents are similarly terrified to know that the 23rd Precinct officer is frequently driving on their streets.

“We expect that the first line of defense to this epidemic of traffic violence will be the mayor and the police department,” said Hindy Schachter, whose husband was killed in a crash with a cyclist in 2014. “These individuals are charged to keep our streets safe. It is bad enough when some of them do not have adequate strategies for safety. It is outrageous when police officers actually perpetrate illegal actions that endanger all of us — but disproportionately senior citizens and the young. I say enough is more than enough. We need a police department that models how we expect all members of society to behave behind the wheel — not rogue officers who become part of the problem.”

de-blasio-face cropThat’s not how the mayor sees it, addressing the issue as a non-issue in an exchange on Monday with Streetsblog, which asked if he was worried that his plan to give more free parking to cops would unleash more reckless cops in our neighborhoods:

I disagree with that on its face. …  The fact is these are our first responders, we expect them to show up no matter what. We expect them to stay when we need them to stay. A lot of them live quite far from where they work. It is important for everyone to drive safely. That’s what Vision Zero is all about and Vision Zero is filled with consequences and you are seeing more and more consequences each year. But it makes no sense to say, “OK, we know a lot or our uniform service officers have to drive to work and we are not going to give them a park.” That makes no sense. We are clearly very adamant that everyone has to follow the rules and there are consequences for those who don’t. But if we want to stop placard abuse we need to do something the root causes.

In a follow-up question, we asked the mayor about his use of the words “have to” in relation to commuting by car. Certainly, 51 percent of the police force lives outside the five boroughs, but the base salary of a New York City police officer is $85,292 after five years on the force, an income that is roughly $35,000 above the citywide median income. There is no way police officer “have to” drive to work because there is no way a police officer has to live outside the city on that salary.

Again, the mayor was irritated.

“I just said it in the beginning of my answer and I said it in the beginning of my answer last time,” he said, referring to a similar question Streetsblog had asked when the parking plan was first introduced. “Because a lot of them live very far away from the city, there’s not always great mass transit options, a lot of them have to stay all sorts of hours, a lot of them have to show up on short notice. It stands to reason.”

One man’s reason is, apparently, another man’s insanity.

After all, on Oct. 19, 2017, the mayor had positioned himself as the ultimate street safety advocate, telling reporters, “We love our city but let’s be clear, crossing the street in New York City should not be a harrowing experience. You shouldn’t feel unsafe crossing streets in your own neighborhood. We have to go after anyone who creates a threat to neighborhood residents.”

Of course, the mayor was talking about electric bike riders, who have been the subject of a two-year-long NYPD crackdown.

But on cops who rack up 41 speeding and red-light tickets, the mayor remains silent.

“I’m at a point, honestly, where I don’t give a flying fuck what the mayor does,” said Cristina Furlong of Make Queens Safer. “Crying to the mayor is not really an option for advocacy. Yes, the public shaming does occasionally work, but I’d like to see a lot of processes change so that there are guidelines and policies that change behavior.”

Furlong called for passage of bills like Landers and a state bill by late State Senator Jose Peralta and Assembly Member Deborah Glick that would trigger a 60-day license suspension for any driver convicted of three school zone tickets in 18 months.

“If (or when) this cop mows somebody down, the bigger tragedy to me is going to be that the city didn’t do more to take reckless drivers off the roads before they hurt or killed someone,” Furlong said. “As for the fact, he’s a cop, it only reaffirms for me that NYPD is absolutely clueless on training officers on the importance of traffic enforcement and it’s going to cost innocent people their lives.”

  • Joe R.

    Under my proposed fine schedule of doubling the fine for each subsequent speed camera ticket at the same location the fine for the 18th offense would have been $13,107,200. In fact, it probably never would have gotten that far. By the time this person got much past something like the tenth offense, they would already be in debt to NYC for the rest of their working lives.

  • walks bikes drives

    I understand why they wont apply points to a license for a camera violation, but I dont see any reason why the fines dont escalate with each infraction. I like the idea of doubling. While I am sure I would have dozens of tickets if I ran my own plate, they are all alternate side parking tickets – not a single speed or red light camera.

  • Joe R.

    Part of the idea here with this fine schedule is by the time the fines start reaching a few thousand dollars per offense the driver will be forced to sell his/her car to pay them off, and that will take a dangerous driver off the roads for good.

  • crazytrainmatt

    This is a great series. Why don’t you file 311 reports for the parked illegally vehicles you encounter in this series? A related story is falsification of NYPD responses (“no violation observed”), especially to placarded vehicles.

    Some more suggestions:
    – Bronx 52 precinct off Mosholu (they park on the greenway outside their dedicated lot)
    – Manhattan 13th precinct on 21st between 2nd/3rd aves. They angle park all over the sidewalk, making the 21st St sharrows useless and have commandeered the parking narrowing the 2nd Ave PBL by putting up permanent fencing. I think it was your story a few months ago that got them out of the bus lane. https://goo.gl/maps/2KXjMeSBdXB2
    – Manhattan 26th precinct off 126th street looks like an occupying army descended – https://goo.gl/maps/SftFUcpvczG2
    – NYFD engine 16/ladder 7 – on 29th between 2nd and 3rd Aves. They have gotten better about double parking since the PBL went in on 29th but there is frequently somebody parked on the sidewalk. https://twitter.com/Reported_NYC/status/998284471869825029

  • SBDriver

    The question is does the officer have to pay the under priced $50 ticket, or do they get to beat the ticket by pleading not guilty because they are “on the job”?
    Assuming they have to pay the fine, the scariest part is that someone who is is in a position of authority and carries a firearm is so oblivious that they cannot even bother to slow down to 30 mph for one block of their commute to avoid $900 in fines.

  • jeff

    Why don’t you name the officer who the car is registered to? Any licensed PI can look it up by license plate number. There are privacy rules with license plates but there are a whole bunch of exceptions to the rules as well. Could also maybe file freedom of information request.

  • Andrew

    I have no proof, but I strongly suspect that many of the fines that this system shows as paid aren’t actually paid.

  • John Smith

    The real story is how many of these tickets likely got thrown out for dubious reasons. Ticket fixing 2.0, here we come.

  • Joe R.

    You’re probably right. There’s likely some code we don’t know about which a clerk can enter for a cop, and the fine goes away.

  • William Lawson

    Yep, sounds like it’s about time for the cops in that precinct to open a bunch of burner Twitter accounts and troll Streetsblog and everyone in the anti-traffic community.

  • William Lawson

    This is a good idea since many people in NYC view traffic tickets as a legitimate cost of doing business and they work their budgets along those lines. Although I would go further and put a limit on the level the fines can reach before the person’s license is terminated.

  • Joe R.

    Even without a cap, the fines would be self-limiting. For example:

    1st offense: $50
    2nd offense: $100
    3rd offense: $200
    4th offense: $400
    5th offense: $800
    6th offense: $1600
    7th offense: $3200
    8th offense: $6400
    9th offense: $12800
    10th offense: $25600

    I’d say by about the 4th or 5th offense motorists would start getting the message to slow down here. That’s already a week’s pay going just for a fine. If not, they would probably need to sell their car down the road to pay subsequent fines. That would end their driving altogether.

  • Andrew

    The vast majority of motorists already get the point after the first or second offense. Your proposal does nothing if my suspicion is correct that the fines accrued by the placard class aren’t actually being paid.

  • Sincerely

    I prefer day fines. Figure out how much money the violator makes in a day, and that’s what the ticket costs.

    Violators like this cop should be addressed differently. Law enforcement officers should be held to a higher standard.

  • First of all. All city cops should be required to live in the city. So our taxes do not end up paying for taxes in Nassau county

  • Exactly right. And this is all the more reason to get rid of Staten Island, so that it can no longer serve as a cop haven within the City.

    Unfortunately, there is amongst police officers a seething contempt for the people of this City — the people whom they ostensibly “serve”. This dangerous trend could be mitigated if officers were part of our City’s communities.

  • Salmazza

    Mr.Cuntsmans. Your name says it all. You have way too much time on your hands. You need to find yourself a nice boy and get laid.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG