Placard Abuse: It’s Not Just For Downtown Brooklyn Anymore!

Website review of 311 complaints shows that the problem is all over the place.

Photo: David Meyer
Photo: David Meyer

We’ve documented placard abuse in Downtown Brooklyn.

We’ve documented it in Inwood.

We’ve seen it all over W. 55th Street in Midtown.

And of course, we found it at City Hall, too.

But the pain of placard abuse is felt most acutely in Far Rockaway, Woodside and University Heights in the Bronx — according to 311 complaints crunched by the website, Localize.city.

Since May 23, 2017 — when “placard” abuse complaints started to be logged by 311 — New Yorkers have made 3,663 reports. Far Rockaway near Shore Front Parkway and Beach 102 Lane led the way with 87 complaints, followed closely by Woodside around 31-06 54th St. (86 complaints) and University Heights around 2420 Sedgwick Ave. (75 complaints).

Now, the data are hardly scientific, given that the 3,600-odd complaints represent just 1 percent of all parking-related reports to 311. But placards are a perk given to our highest officials and law enforcement personnel — so even one complaint would be telling (after all, why are placard possessors parking at fire hydrants anyway?).

When an address gets into double-digits, it’s particularly telling.

“The hot spots reveal where residents are particularly annoyed and vocal about neighbors abusing placards,” said Localize.city data scientist Michal Eisenberg.

Sometimes you don't even need a placard! Photo: @placardabuse
Sometimes you don’t even need a placard to be a placard abuser! Photo: @placardabuse

These kinds of complaints will likely persist, given that city officials steadfastly avoid cracking down on placard abusers — just 89 cars with illegal parking placards were towed last year, Streetsblog reported in June. As of February, there were 160,000 official parking placards in circulation.

The City Council could act to cut the abuse. And DOT has been mumbling about a centralized electronic tracking system. But for now, Far Rockaway and Woodside residents will just have to deal with their illegally parking neighbors.

Rounding out the top six are:

Financial District around 59 Nassau St. (37 complaints)
Bay Ridge around 134 73rd St. (16 complaints)
Maspeth around 61-33 Grand Ave. (15 complaints)

Based on number of complaints per 1,000 residents, Localize rejiggered the top 10 this way:

  1. Financial District 2.56
  2. Woodside 2.48
  3. Midtown 2.31
  4. Rockaways 2.16
  5. Maspeth 1.80
  6. University Heights 1.77
  7. Chinatown 1.76
  8. Downtown Brooklyn 1.71
  9. Long Island City 1.68
  • Alexis Leonardo Solórzano

    On Murray Street by West Street, there is authorized parking for FLEO, not sure what it stood for but I saw multiple vehicles from various agencies using it, so some of these authorized parking spots arent even being used by the proper people. I even saw the halal cart guy leave his car parked in there and just had a white sheet of paper on his dashboard that says “Halal”.

  • Jeff

    I wish to destroy that silver BMW half-suv-half-station-wagon with colored stripes that is always parked on the painted pedestrian refuge island at 170th and Ft Washington:

    https://www.google.com/maps/@40.8433876,-73.9414707,3a,75y,247.45h,75.71t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sIxIRDWHra4XOuypDDb4KMQ!2e0!7i16384!8i8192

    (surprise surprise, there’s a freaking car parked on it on the goddam google streetview).

    I wish no harm to any human being, but I would pay a lot of money to be able to smash that fucking thing to pieces.

  • djx

    I LOVE YOU. This specific SUV pisses me off so much – it’s almost always there when I go by, and it seriously impedes visibility there.

  • Emmily_Litella

    Has anyone else noticed the creeping encroachment of parked vehicle bumpers into crosswalks? I’m seeing many un-ticketed vehicles parked with bumpers up to 18″ into marked and unmarked crosswalks.

  • Emmily_Litella

    Disguise yourself thoroughly and go down to observe it in a rainstorm.

  • AMH

    How about 4-6 feet into the crosswalk!

  • AMH

    Apparently menus are the new placards.

    https://twitter.com/D00RZ0NE/status/1044369865992282114

  • Placard abuse. Auto dealerships. People placing vests in their windows. USPS. Clergy.

    It’s amazing how on nearly every block in NYC you can find people breaking the law, stealing parking, parking in illegal spots or faking legitimacy by tossing something in their windshield area.

  • qrt145

    I’m sure there’s a thousand more that could be added, but here’s one of my pet peeves as a a start: funeral homes.

  • Well stop dreaming about it and DO IT!

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

NYPD Opposes Bill to Curb Placard Abuse as Total Soars to 118,000

|
At a City Council Transportation Committee hearing today, the New York Police Department announced its opposition to legislation that would curb parking placard abuse by requiring barcodes on official placards. NYPD claimed that it has placard abuse under control and that only Police Commissioner Ray Kelly should have the power to determine what tools are […]